Question

In: Physics

There have been some very nice discussions recently centered around the question of whether gravity and...

There have been some very nice discussions recently centered around the question of whether gravity and the geometry and topology of the classical world we see about us, could be phenomena which emerge in the low-energy limits of a more fundamental microscopic theory.

Among these, @Tim Van Beek's reply to the question on "How the topology of space [time] arises from more fundamental notions" contains the following description of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem:

It describes "action at a distance" in a mathematically precise way. According to the Reeh-Schlieder theorem there are correlations in the vacuum state between measurements at an arbitrary distance. The point is: The proof of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem is independent of any axiom describing causality, showing that quantum entanglement effects do not violate Einstein causality, and don't depend on the precise notion of causality. Therefore a change in spacetime topology in order to explain quantum entanglement effects won't work.

which is also preceded with an appropriate note of caution, saying that the above paragraph:

... describes an aspect of axiomatic quantum field theory which may become obsolete in the future with the development of a more complete theory.

I had a bias against AQFT as being too abstract an obtuse branch of study to be of any practical use. However, in light of the possibility (recently discussed on physics.SE) that classical geometry arises due to the entanglement between the degrees of freedom of some quantum many-body system (see Swingle's paper on Entanglement Renormalization and Holography) the content of the Rees-Schilder theorem begins to seem quite profound and far-sighted.

The question therefore is: Does the Rees-Schlieder theorem provide support for the idea of building space-time from quantum entanglement? or am I jumping the gun in presuming their is some connection between what the theorem says and the work of Vidal, Evenbly, Swingle and others on "holographic entanglement"?

Solutions

Expert Solution

No. The Reeh-Schlieder theorem is a consequence of the Wightman axioms and of the Haag-Kastler axioms, both of which assume a Minkowski space, complete with the trivial metric structure, underlies everything. Variations of these axiomatic systems either allow or do not allow an analogue of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem to be derived. The idea that we might build space-time from quantum entanglement, while conceivable, presumably introduces either an axiomatic or some less well-defined mathematical structure, which will then either allow or not allow a Reeh-Schlieder-like theorem to be derived. Some thought this afternoon has suggested to me no way in which the Reeh-Schlieder theorem might of itself suggest a particular underlying mathematical structure. I take the lack of other Answers to suggest that no-one else immediately thought of such a thing either.

I personally take the Reeh-Schlieder theorem to say that there is a sense in which modulations of vacuum fluctuations are nonlocal, in a way that is weakly analogous to the nonlocality of analytic complex functions, for which the equivalent to the Reeh-Schlieder theorem is the possibility of analytic continuation. Analyticity, in a relatively sophisticated sense, is fundamental to the proof of the Reeh-Schlieder theorem. This is talk rather than mathematics, but to me it suggests the negative reply that I began with.


Related Solutions

You have been looking around for a nice car and have found the car you want...
You have been looking around for a nice car and have found the car you want for the right price. All along, you have told the dealer that you want to purchase the car. It will cost you $45,000 out the door. You will put 25% down and take out a 4-year car loan. The interest rate you got from a local bank is 2.99% for 48 months. You made the deal and now you need to “finalize” the paperwork...
We work for Cola Company and there have been some discussions on which pressure setting is...
We work for Cola Company and there have been some discussions on which pressure setting is best for filling out bottles. If we overfill the bottles then we are spending money we do not need to. If we are under filling the bottles we run the risk of dissatisfaction of the customers. If we can fill the bottles using a higher psi we can run the line faster and thus increase our production. Our current fill pressure is 25psi. Management...
Outline some economic models and concepts that have been used in discussions of risk-taking, and assess...
Outline some economic models and concepts that have been used in discussions of risk-taking, and assess their relevance to debates on instability of the financial system during the past two decades. You can include graphs and tables
Recently, there have been a number of aircraft accidents around the world in Indonesia, Papua New...
Recently, there have been a number of aircraft accidents around the world in Indonesia, Papua New Guinea, and in Guyana. Each accident is investigated for probable cause. For 35 extra credit points, prepare a one page summary of the international rules that apply to commercial air carrier accident investigations. Be sure to research ICAO standards and recommended practices.
2020 has been a very unusual year with the worldwide pandemic. Economies around the world have...
2020 has been a very unusual year with the worldwide pandemic. Economies around the world have been greatly affected by it. What has been the impact on the Canadian economy? The objective of this assignment is to find an answer this question. You will research and find answers to the following questions. How has the pandemic affected the Canadian GDP, Unemployment, Inflation and Government deficit? Compare the February numbers with the latest numbers for August. In your opinion, is the...
You have been told that some of the variances that are generally calculated are not very...
You have been told that some of the variances that are generally calculated are not very useful. Explain the meaning and value of each of these variances. With meaning, this includes what it measures. Min 3 sentences per variance. Direct materials price variance Direct labor price variance Variable manufacturing overhead efficiency variance Fixed manufacturing overhead volume variance
1. Anton and Klara must decide whether to be nice to each other. Klara has been...
1. Anton and Klara must decide whether to be nice to each other. Klara has been given $5, and can decide whether to keep these $5 for herself or sacrifice the money for Anton. If she sacrifices the $5, Anton gets $10. Similarly, Anton has been given $5, and if he sacrifices his $5, Klara gets $10. However, Klara does not know Anton’s choices, believing that Anton has no choices to make and cannot get money unless she sacrifices for...
Some virtual teams at Boeing have discussions focused on military aircraft. Do some Internet research on...
Some virtual teams at Boeing have discussions focused on military aircraft. Do some Internet research on UC security mechanisms and identify and briefly describe several that Boeing should have in place to ensure the privacy and integrity of such discussions. I need the answer with no plagarism.
Would like to have a nice summary for each question. The Profit Maximizing decision for the...
Would like to have a nice summary for each question. The Profit Maximizing decision for the Monopolist with the Perfectly Competitive firm/industry. How do they differ? Note the differences between the Demand curve for the PC firm and the Demand curve for the Monopoly. What kinds of profits accrue to the Monopolist? Why is it said that the Monopolist’s profits persist? Why is that not true for the firms in a Perfectly Competitive industry? Thanks
Please focus only on the variables I have provided as I have been very specific Question...
Please focus only on the variables I have provided as I have been very specific Question 1 The core elements of the Growth Employment and Redistribution (GEAR) strategy of the South African government in 1996, under the leadership of the then finance minister Trevor Manuel, were amongst other things:  budget reform to strengthen the redistributive thrust of expenditure  monetary policy to prevent a resurgence of inflation  a reduction in tariffs to contain input prices and facilitate industrial...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT