Question

In: Physics

If our universe comes from a flux compactification of string theory over 6 dimensions with a...

If our universe comes from a flux compactification of string theory over 6 dimensions with a nonzero flux, then it can't be continually deformed to another compactification with zero flux as the total flux is a topological invariant. The cosmological constant of our universe is positive, which in string theory means it is a metastable state. The stable vacuum for a flux compactification in string theory is a BPS compactification with negative cosmological constant.

What if our metastable observable universe is actually embedded in a larger stable anti de Sitter background? An inflating metastable or slowly rolling or chaotically inflating patch of this asymptotically AdS universe inflates to our observable universe. By the AdS/CFT correspondence, our universe can be described by a superconformal field theory in 2+1D with no gravity.

Is there any flaw in my reasoning?

Solutions

Expert Solution

No-one has dared to answer this question yet. So let me get the ball rolling. It seems that there are a large number of problems to be solved for this proposal to work, but I'm not aware that any of these problems are definitely unsolvable (though that might just be my own ignorance).

(1) This is to be an AdS4/CFT3 duality, then we are dealing with M-theory (a stack of coincident M2-branes) on AdS4 x a 7-manifold, or equivalently, Type IIA string theory (a stack of coincident D2-branes) on AdS4 x a 6-manifold. As pointed out in a surprising dialogue from 2005, we immediately face the problems that (i) there's far too much supersymmetry for a realistic model (ii) the 7-manifold is as big as the AdS space. I don't know what to do about the latter problem, but for the better known AdS5/CFT4 duality, we have many variations on the original construction in which supersymmetry is broken a little or a lot, so let us suppose we can do that with AdS4 too.

(2) In order to get the universe we see, a local or temporary patch with de Sitter geometry has to form within the AdS space. I have no idea how that would be represented in terms of the boundary CFT. In fact, I cannot even find a known CFT dual for any AdS space which is used as the basis for a construction of dS space in string theory. The dialogue above mentions a quest for CFT duals of the AdS spaces appearing in the KKLT paper from 2003; it doesn't seem that they are known yet, even in 2011. Embedding de Sitter space in the CFT framework is an even bigger challenge and figuring out how to do so would be a breakthrough.

(3) The KKLT construction adds anti-D3-branes to the AdS space, to lift it to dS, but they were working in IIB string theory, and it looks like the gravity theory in our AdS4 space will be IIA. Fortunately, there's an alternative mechanism available for IIA.

(4) We also have to get the fields of the standard model out of this somehow. I'll mention just one problem here, and its potential solution: "the inclusion of particles in the fundamental representation of the gauge group, i.e. quarks. Since AdS geometries arise as near-horizon limits for coincident branes, the dual field theories have only adjoint matter. The same is true for deformations of AdS. It turns out that fundamental representations can be introduced by including appropriately embedded probe branes."

So there you have it. There's a whole raft of problems that would have to be solved to turn AdS4/CFT3 into a source of phenomenological and cosmological models. Some of them may already be demonstrably unsolvable, for technical reasons I don't appreciate, while at least one other basic element of the plan (dS/CFT) is a major unsolved research problem of string theory. Good luck!


Related Solutions

Super string theory establishes that at each point of our 4 dimensional spacetime, there is attached...
Super string theory establishes that at each point of our 4 dimensional spacetime, there is attached a 6-dimensional Calabi-Yau (CY) manifold which encodes the geometry of the additional compactified spatial dimensions needed to formulate the theory. It is postulated that the size of these compactified dimensions is of the order of the Planck scale. On the other hand, I've always understood that in quantum gravity, we are confronted with the big problem of wild quantum fluctuations -due to the Heisenberg...
Write a Java application that checks a string for correct parenthesization. The input comes from the...
Write a Java application that checks a string for correct parenthesization. The input comes from the keyboard and should (but might not) consist solely of the delmiters (, ), [, ], {, and } separated by whitespace. The output of the program must include following: OK Opener/closer mismatch Missing closer Missing opener Unexpected symbol The name of your class should be ParenChecker. For example, if the input was: ( [ { } ] ) the program should produce the following...
Almost everything we know about the universe comes from information carried in electromagnetic radiation: radio waves,...
Almost everything we know about the universe comes from information carried in electromagnetic radiation: radio waves, microwaves, X-rays, visible light, and gamma waves have been travelling to us for billions of years, all at the speed of light. Using spectroscopes that work on the same principle as the ones we used in lab, scientists read the line spectra that the hot gases emit to determine the elements that compose the stars. Explain.
What is the most accepted theory as to where oil and gas comes from?
What is the most accepted theory as to where oil and gas comes from?
A block hangs from a string that runs over a pulley and is attached to a...
A block hangs from a string that runs over a pulley and is attached to a rolling cart. The cart, the block, and the pulley each have the same mass (M) . The cart an pulley roll without friction, and the pulley is a disk with moment of inertia: Icm=12MR2 The hanging block is released from rest and allowed to evolve freely under the influence of gravity. Find the speed of the hanging mass, v, after the block has fallen...
Entropy permeates our universe. Five systems are listed below. Pick three systems from the list or...
Entropy permeates our universe. Five systems are listed below. Pick three systems from the list or pick two systems from the list and come up with a third system of your own. For each system you choose, give an example of something that could happen to increase the entropy of that system and explain why entropy increases. Systems: -An automobile -The human body -A building -An ocean -A solar system
The data in the attached excel file comes from Consumer Reports and was collected over a...
The data in the attached excel file comes from Consumer Reports and was collected over a two-year period. It gives the average mpg over a 195-mile trip, the weight of the vehicle (pounds), engine displacement (liters), number of cylinders, horsepower, type of transmission (0 = manual, 1 = automatic), the number of gears and whether the car was foreign (1) or domestic (0). Part a: Build a model for predicting the average mpg based on the data in the attached...
This question comes from Integrated Theory and Knowledge Developement in Nursing textbook. Identify a study that...
This question comes from Integrated Theory and Knowledge Developement in Nursing textbook. Identify a study that you consider to be isolated from theory. How is its value limited because a deliberate linkage to theory is absent?
Fix this broken code? # Get our input from the command line import sys string =...
Fix this broken code? # Get our input from the command line import sys string = sys.argv[1] # Your code goes here if string 'Bingo' print('Missed') else: print('Hit!')
Our most accurate information about the current pandemic comes from Italy, where there are 101,739 confirmed...
Our most accurate information about the current pandemic comes from Italy, where there are 101,739 confirmed cases out of a population of 60 million. This means about 0.17% of the entire population are confirmed cases. Suppose you have 30 extended family members in Italy and each one independently has a 0.17% chance of being a confirmed case. Use binompdf and binomcdf to find the following probabilities: 4a. What is the probability that exactly 0 of your extended family members is...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT