Question

In: Physics

I'm interested in the meaning of the phrase "continuum limit" specifically as it is often used...

I'm interested in the meaning of the phrase "continuum limit" specifically as it is often used in expressions relating to the ability of a quantum gravity theory to recover GR in the continuum limit.

I believe I understand the meaning but want to make sure I am not missing some important part of the precise definition as my intuition may be off and I have not seen it defined anywhere.

Pointers to a place where it is defined in an online resource would be appreciated. A google search just turned up many references to it being used in papers and articles and such.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Usually it relates to discrete models where it means "becoming less discrete".

To make this more formal and give a simple example, consider a set

and imagine there is an edge between nearest neighbors so that part of it looks like this
this can be thought of as discretization of a -dimensional cube of side modelling some crystal. Now by continuum limit one understand the limit . In this case one would recover the original cube . The reason this is important is that lattice is a much simpler object than a continuous space and we can compute lots of things there directly. In some cases we are then able to carry out limits and recover the original continuous theory.

As for your talk about GR, I think there is only one possible interpretation in the context of Loop Quantum Gravity which deals with discrete space-time. I don't know much about this theory but I'd assume that in order to recover GR one would need to perform the continuum limit of the space-time spacing.

But note that LQG doesn't mean quantum gravity in general. It is just one of proposed theories for quantum gravity and other theories (e.g. string theory) don't assume discrete space-time, so there is no continuum limit to carry out.

Update: David has made a very good point about the nature of continuum limit, so I decided to elaborate on the matter.

There are two semantically different concepts of continuum limit (although mathematically they are the same):

One can start with a discrete microscopic theory that is already complete (e.g. lattice of crystals; or with space-time in LQG). In this case the semantics of continuum limit is getting rid of microscopic physics. Once you perform the limit, you obtain a simpler theory.

But sometimes the complete theory can already be continuous (e.g. Quantum Field Theory) and one first wants to discretize it in order to be able to perform the calculations more easily. In this case when we are shrinking the scale we are actually making the discrete model a better approximation to the original theory until in continuum limit we recover the original theory completely. So here we also lose the microscopic degrees of freedom but we don't care because the discrete model wasn't physical anyway -- it was just a mathematical tool.


Related Solutions

OPTICAL INSTRUMENTS: a) Explain the meaning, in terms of physics, of the phrase etched on the...
OPTICAL INSTRUMENTS: a) Explain the meaning, in terms of physics, of the phrase etched on the right side mirror of most cars: “Objects in mirror are closer than they appear." b) What is the difference between a real image and a virtual image? c) The image focused on your retina is actually inverted (sketch a simple ray diagram showing this observation). What does this fact say about our definitions of “right side up” and “upside down”? d) Experimental subjects who...
What phrase has the same meaning as "the molecular pathways of photoreceptors"?
What phrase has the same meaning as "the molecular pathways of photoreceptors"?
What is the meaning of the following phrase?. "treating equals equally and unequal’s unequally but in...
What is the meaning of the following phrase?. "treating equals equally and unequal’s unequally but in proportion to their relevant differences”. Justice does not mean treating all individuals the same".
Explain the intent or meaning of the phrase “defense in depth”, especially noting what the three...
Explain the intent or meaning of the phrase “defense in depth”, especially noting what the three key elements of defense in depth are and providing an example of a failure in each domain. Define defense in depth: Domain 1: Domain 2: Domain 3: Failure in Domain 1: Failure in Domain 2 Failure in Domain 3:
Americans often think of themselves as quite diverse in their political opinions, within the continuum of...
Americans often think of themselves as quite diverse in their political opinions, within the continuum of liberal to conservative. Let’s use data from the 2006 GSS to investigate the diversity of political views. The percentage distribution shown displays respondents’ self-rating of their political position. Political Views Percentage Extremely liberal 3 Liberal 12 Slightly liberal 11 Moderate 38 Slightly conservative 17 Conservative 15 Extremely conservative 4 Total      100.0 What is the IQV for this variable?
I'm a social psychologist, so I'm interested primarily in the situational and contextual factors that drive...
I'm a social psychologist, so I'm interested primarily in the situational and contextual factors that drive human behavior. When you're seeking to predict or explain a person's actions, looking at the social norms, and the person's context, is usually a pretty safe bet. Situational constraints typically predict behavior far better than personality, intelligence, or other individual-level traits. So when I see a student failing to assignments, missing deadlines, or not delivering results in other aspects of their life, I'm moved...
• specifically explain why cancers are often called wounds that will not heal.
• specifically explain why cancers are often called wounds that will not heal.
Life histories are often organized along a slow-fast continuum. Contrast the life histories of organisms at...
Life histories are often organized along a slow-fast continuum. Contrast the life histories of organisms at the slow end of the continuum with the lifr histories organisms at fast end. Give an example of a species with a slow life-history, and hypothesize the abiotic or biotic conditions that cause this life history
a) A psychologist is interested in whether or not handedness is related to gender. Specifically, she...
a) A psychologist is interested in whether or not handedness is related to gender. Specifically, she wants to know if the percentage left-handed men in the population is different from the percentage of left-handed women. She collected data on handedness for 200 men and 200 women. What type of statistical test would be appropriate? options: a) Chi-square goodness of fit test b) Independent samples t-test c) Paired t-test d) Chi-square test of independence b) Nima investigated the relationship between optimism...
Balance in neutral solution: MnO4- + S2O32- ---> SO42- + MnO2 I'm specifically having trouble with...
Balance in neutral solution: MnO4- + S2O32- ---> SO42- + MnO2 I'm specifically having trouble with using H2O, H+, and OH- in balancing the half reactions.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT