Question

In: Physics

In general relativity, light is subject to gravitational pull. Does light generate gravitational pull, and do...

In general relativity, light is subject to gravitational pull. Does light generate gravitational pull, and do two beams of light attract each other?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The general answer is "it depends." Light has energy, momentum, and puts a pressure in the direction of motion, and these are all equal in magnitude (in units of c = 1). All of these things contribute to the stress-energy tensor, so by the Einstein field equation, it is unambiguous to say that light produces gravitational effects.

However, the relationship between energy, momentum, and pressure in the direction of propagation leads to some effects which might not otherwise be expected. The most famous is that the deflection of light by matter happens at exactly twice the amount predicted by a massive particle, at least in the sense that in linearized GTR, ignoring the pressure term halves the effect (one can also compare it a naive model of a massive particle at the speed of light in Newtonian gravity, and again the GTR result is exactly twice that).

Similarly, antiparallel (opposite direction) light beams attract each other by four times the naive (pressureless or Newtonian) expectation, while parallel (same direction) light beams do not attract each other at all. A good paper to start with is: Tolman R.C., Ehrenfest P., and Podolsky B., Phys. Rev. 37 (1931) 602. Something one might worry about is whether the result is true to higher orders as well, but the light beams would have to be extremely intense for them to matter. The first order (linearized) effect between light beams is already extremely small.


Related Solutions

General Relativity Q: What is Einstein’s equivalence principle? Q: What is gravitational lensing? Why is it...
General Relativity Q: What is Einstein’s equivalence principle? Q: What is gravitational lensing? Why is it useful for cosmology? Q: What is gravitational time dilation? Q: What are MACHOs? What does the MACHO microlensing result mean for dark matter in the Milky Way? Q: What is the bullet cluster? How does it give evidence for dark matter and against modified gravity?
Is the sun's gravitational pull on the moon greater or less than the earth's pull on...
Is the sun's gravitational pull on the moon greater or less than the earth's pull on the moon? The sun doesn't steal our moon away, so the earth must be pulling harder, right? If you do the calculation, you find out that's not true. The sun pulls more than the earth, so why don't we lose the moon?
what is the one way light time from moon to earth, calculate with general relativity effect....
what is the one way light time from moon to earth, calculate with general relativity effect. Please explain each step.
Explain General Relativity. Give examples.
Explain General Relativity. Give examples.
6) EscapeVelocity In order for an object to escape a planet's gravitational pull, it must attain...
6) EscapeVelocity In order for an object to escape a planet's gravitational pull, it must attain a minimum initial velocity called the escape velocity. The escape velocity varies from planet to planet but it is the same for all objects on a given planet. Assume that we are analyzing the data that a small probe has collected while exploring some mystery planet. The probe has managed to obtain the circumference of the planet and the acceleration due to gravity at...
How does the following brief thought experiment fail to show that general relativity (GR) has a...
How does the following brief thought experiment fail to show that general relativity (GR) has a major problem in regards to black holes? The full thought experiment is in my blog post. The post claims that GR violates its own equivalence principle at the horizon of a black hole. The principle says that the laws of physics in any sufficiently small, freely falling frame are the same as they are in an inertial frame in an idealized, gravity-free universe. Here's...
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory...
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory of general relativity includes gravity. b) The theory of general relativity describes the behavior of subatomic particles. c) The theory of special relativity applies only to very massive objects. d) Only the theory of special relativity includes gravity.
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory...
Which statement best describes the difference between special relativity and general relativity? a) Only the theory of general relativity includes gravity. b) The theory of general relativity describes the behavior of subatomic particles. c) The theory of special relativity applies only to very massive objects. d) Only the theory of special relativity includes gravity.
a) Explain Einstein’s theories of special relativity and general relativity. b) Include at least one piece...
a) Explain Einstein’s theories of special relativity and general relativity. b) Include at least one piece of evidence in support of each theory.
Why does Quantum Mechanics not follow Einstein's Theory of General Relativity? If that's completely true, [we...
Why does Quantum Mechanics not follow Einstein's Theory of General Relativity? If that's completely true, [we know that "The Higgs boson does not technically give other particles mass. More precisely, the particle is a quantized manifestation of a field (the Higgsfield) that generates mass through its interaction with other particles." ] will it follow the famous equation E=mc²?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT