Question

In: Finance

Suppose you have to decide whether selling an old machine or keeping it with a major...

Suppose you have to decide whether selling an old machine or keeping it with a major overhaul:

A) Selling the machine at time zero for $750,000 with zero book value and paying the tax of 40%.

B) Keeping the machine, which requires a major overhaul cost of $1,000,000 at time zero. The overhaul cost is depreciable from time 0 to year 5 (over six years) based on MACRS 5-year life depreciation with the half year convention (table A-1 at IRS (https://www.irs.gov/publications/p946)). In this case machine can produce and generate equal annual revenue for five years (year 1 to 5) and salvage value of the machine will be $250,000 with zero book value at the end of year 5. The operating cost of the machine will be $400,000 per year from year 1 to year 5.

Calculate the minimum annual revenue that machine has to generate to break-even the selling with NPV of keeping the machine. Consider 40% income tax rate and after-tax minimum ROR of 16%.

Expert Solution

(A) Cash flow if machine sold in 0 year = $450000

(B) cash flow in case of overhaul

step 1 initial investment 1000000

step 2 depreciation.

yr. op block. depreciation

0. 1000000. 200000

1. 800000. 320000

2. 480000. 192000

3. 288000. 115200

4. 172800. 115200

'5. 57600. 57600

step 3 :_ salvage value at 5th yr. = 250000*0.6 = 150000

step 4:- calculations of reoccurring cashflow here we need to do reverse calculations to find minimum annual revenue hence let's assume minimum annual revenue = x

part/yr 1. 2. 3. 4. 5

cash flow. x. x. x. x. x.

less

depn. 320000. 192000. 115200. 115200. 57600

exp. 400000. 400000. 400000. 400000. 400000

profit before tax. x-720000. x-592000. x-515200. . x-515200. x-457600

pofit after tax. 0.6x-432000. 0.6x-355200 0.6x-309120. 0.6x-309120. 0.6x-274560

?ADD

deprn. 320000. 192000. 115200. 115200. 57600

cash inflow. 0.6x-112000. 0.6x-163200. 0.6x-193920. 0.6x-193920. 0.6x-216960

step 5 Calculations of present value

yr cash inflow. pv fector. pv

0. -920000 (note 1) 1. -920000

1. -112000. 0.8621. - 96555

2. -163200. 0.7432. -121290

3. -193920. 0.6407. -124244

4. -193920. 0.5523. -107102

5. -66960. 0.4761. -31880

(216960-150000)

0.6x(note 2) 3.2743. 1.9646x

TOTAL. 1.9646x-1401071

there fore x = 1401071/1.9646 = 713158

there for annual revenue required to break even = 713158

note 1 cash inflow for yr 0

= depn for 0 yr = 200000 where tax saving = 80000 ( 200000*0.4)

therefore cash inflow = (-1000000+80000)=-920000

note 2 here 0.6 is available in all year hence taken as common and multiply with pvifa @ 16% for 5 yrs

jeff jeffy answered 2 years ago

Suppose you need to decide whether to keep a machine or replace it with a new...

Suppose you need to decide whether to keep a machine or replace it with a new one: Old machine: The old machine can operate for 5 years with operating cost of $120,000 per year. New machine: Replacing the old machine with a new one requires a capital cost of $250,000 in year zero (assume that there is zero salvage value for old machine). The capital cost is depreciable from year 0 to year 5 (over six years) based on MACRS...

Suppose you are shopping for a private jet, you have to decide whether to get a...

Suppose you are shopping for a private jet, you have to decide whether to get a jet with one engine or two. Let p denote the probability that an engine fails during a flight. A “catastrophic engine failure” is an engine failure that makes the plane unable to fly. (a) What is the probability of a catastrophic engine failure during a flight of the plane with only one engine? (b) You are also considering a jet with two engines, however...

10-14 Otter Outside Gear must decide whether to replace a 10 year old packing machine with...

10-14 Otter Outside Gear must decide whether to replace a 10 year old packing machine with a new one that costs. $142,600. Replacing the old machine will increase net operating income (excluding depreciation) from $75,000 to $105,000. It will decrease NWC by $16,000. The new machine falls in the MACRS 5-year class. If the new machine is purchased, it will be sold in six years for $20,000; whereas, if the old machine is kept, it will have no salvage value...

We are trying to decide whether to replace the original machine with a new machine. Original...

We are trying to decide whether to replace the original machine with a new machine. Original Machine: Initial cost = 1,000,000; Annual depreciation = 180,000; Purchased 2 years ago; Book Value = 640,000; Salvage today = 700,000; Salvage in 3 years = 150,000 New Machine: Initial cost = 600,000; 3-year life, straight-line depreciation; Salvage in 3 years = 100,000; Cost savings = 50,000/year Required return = 10% and Tax rate = 40% a. Should we replace the original machine with...

Put yourself back in the late 1780s, and argue whether you would have supported keeping the...

Put yourself back in the late 1780s, and argue whether you would have supported keeping the Articles of Confederation, or whether you would have supported replacing it with the Constitution. Make sure to explain why.

Problems Allred Inc. is trying to decide whether to purchase Machine A or Machine B. Below...

Problems Allred Inc. is trying to decide whether to purchase Machine A or Machine B. Below are the associated costs. Which are relevant? Machine A Machine B Relevant or Not Relevant? Cost of Machine $46,000 $50,000 Setup Costs $5,000 $5,000 Costs incurred for research of the machine $400 $600 Annual operating costs for the machine $6,000 $5,000 Outsourcing Decision Animals United currently outsources pet beds for their product line.The beds are purchased for $30 each.The company is considering making the...

Imagine that you have decided to acquire your dream car. You now have to decide whether to...

Imagine that you have decided to acquire your dream car. You now have to decide whether to buy or lease that car. Write a report specifying the differences between leasing and buying your dream car and make a decision on whether to buy or lease. In writing your report you must do the following: Gather the terms under which you would lease the car, such as the necessary down payment amount and monthly payment amount. Calculate the total costs when leasing...

A firm has to decide whether to (1). stay with current machine as it is (2)....

A firm has to decide whether to (1). stay with current machine as it is (2). upgrade it with an enhancement or (3). buy a new machine. Cost of upgrade is $1000, and the cost of a new machine is $8000. Revenues are estimated as follows, based on the performance of the economy next year: stagnant economy growth economy no change 8000 8000 upgrade 8500 10000 new machine 8500 18000 It is estimated that the probability of a stagnant economy next year...

The owner of a small deli is trying to decide whether to discontinue selling magazines. He...

The owner of a small deli is trying to decide whether to discontinue selling magazines. He suspects that only 10% of his customers buy a magazine and he thinks that he might be able to use the display space to sell something more profitable. Before making a final decision, he decides that for one day he will keep track of the number of customers that buy a magazine. (a) Explain why this is a binomial experiment. (b) Assuming his suspicion...

High Tax Rates and Summer Employment. Suppose you are trying to decide whether to take a...

High Tax Rates and Summer Employment. Suppose you are trying to decide whether to take a summer job at Clark's Camera Store that pays $20 an hour, or work for your uncle as his graphic assistant for $16 an hour. At Clark's Camera Store you would have to pay both income and social insurance taxes on your earnings, but if you work for your uncle, he will pay you in cash so you can avoid the tax. You will prefer...