Question

In: Operations Management

As with most legal principles, the hearsay rule has many exceptions. Under the excited utterance exception...

As with most legal principles, the hearsay rule has many exceptions. Under the excited utterance exception to the hearsay rule some statements made out of court may be repeated inside of court. What is the rationale that an excited utterance is probably truthful? Construct a hypothetical example where an excited utterance made under the stress of the moment should be admissible in a criminal trial.

Solutions

Expert Solution

An excited utterance is probably truthful

The rationale behind this exception to the hearsay rule is that when a statement is made as an immediate response to a schocking statement then in most cases it won't be a lie as the statement can be seen as a reflex action. According to many psychological studies a human mind needs time to frame a lie and in cases that a lie is framed in less time it is not generaly in an excited response to a statement. In such situations a person tends to speak truth in spur of the moment and excitement generated in the mind at that moment won't let a person lie as easily as in other situation.

For Example-

A suspected murder in form of an accident took place on a street where the cctvs were non functional but the man who took the victim to the hospital asked the homeless man who was attending the victim when he reached there,his words in shocking state of mind were, "a car crashed the victim's car twice and two other people in car shouted kill him, kill him while their car crashed into the victim's car". Now the homeless man could not be found at the time of the hearing of the case but the man who took the victim to hospital told his exact words to the court and an incident that could have been seen as an accident changed in an attempt of muder due to the words of that homeless man as they were in the spur of the moment and he wasn't in a drunk situation as described by the other man and his words were said in an absolute shocked state without any hesitation whatsoever. Though there were chance that it was not a preplanned murder but something that happened at the moment in a drunk state but those words certainly proved that it wasn't a mere accident and the cases on them would be completely different from that of an accident.


Related Solutions

What exceptions to the "hearsay rule" have courts recognized? Describe the reasoning behind these exceptions. 300+...
What exceptions to the "hearsay rule" have courts recognized? Describe the reasoning behind these exceptions. 300+ words
Do a bit of research on the hearsay rule in legal proceedings. In your own words,...
Do a bit of research on the hearsay rule in legal proceedings. In your own words, explain the hearsay rule and describe how it relates to the concept of an expert witness. Write a short paper, 300-400 words
Explain any THREE (3) exceptions to the nemo dat rule under the Sale of Goods Act...
Explain any THREE (3) exceptions to the nemo dat rule under the Sale of Goods Act 1957. ( 10 mark)
Chapter:7 (Book - Business and legal principles)   Q: legal issue in construction What single most important...
Chapter:7 (Book - Business and legal principles)   Q: legal issue in construction What single most important fact about a subcontract distinguishes it from a purchase order? What may be provided by the subcontractor in addition to on-site labor? Must the work of a construction subcontract necessarily be directly and completely spelled out in the prime construction contract? May it be? Cite examples.
The principle of the separate legal entity has been considered as the most fundamental principle of...
The principle of the separate legal entity has been considered as the most fundamental principle of modern corporate law. This independence or distinction is not a new concept as it forms the backbone of the corporation’s legal issues. It is argued, however, that the sanctity of the principle of corporate veil principle is only drawn under compelling Critically analyses the above statement in light of recent development of cases in the commonwealth jurisdiction of Malaysia and United Kingdom.
Many of the? fruit-flavored beers most likely are operating under what type of? strategy? A. Cost...
Many of the? fruit-flavored beers most likely are operating under what type of? strategy? A. Cost Leadership B. Focus C. Differentiation D. Both A and C
Intelligence has been under debate for many many years. Why is this an important topic to debate?
Intelligence has been under debate for many many years. Why is this an important topic to debate? According to what you have read in this class what do you think are the most important aspects of intelligence? Why? How important is emotional intelligence?
The quantitative data set under consideration has roughly a bell-shaped distribution. Apply the empirical rule to...
The quantitative data set under consideration has roughly a bell-shaped distribution. Apply the empirical rule to answer the following question. A quantitative data set of size 90 has mean 40 and standard deviation 6. Approximately how many observations lie between 22 and 58? Approximately _____ observations lie between 22 and 58.
Question 77: The Ethics of Care has many similarities to Question options: Rule Utilitarianism Act Utilitarianism...
Question 77: The Ethics of Care has many similarities to Question options: Rule Utilitarianism Act Utilitarianism Kant’s Categorical Imperative Rawls’s Theory of Justice Part B: Which of the following is not a reason why a feminist perspective has called for rethinking the history of ethics? Question options: Traditional ethics has excluded women’s voices. Traditional ethics stresses autonomous man and the ethics of strangers. Traditional ethics has not emphasized justice. Traditional ethics invalidates the priority of intimate relationships.
A firm evaluates all of its projects by applying the IRR rule. A project under consideration has the following cash flows:
  A firm evaluates all of its projects by applying the IRR rule. A project under consideration has the following cash flows:     Year Cash Flow 0 –$ 28,800   1   12,800   2   15,800   3   11,800        If the required return is 13 percent, what is the IRR for this project? (Do not round intermediate calculations. Enter your answer as a percent rounded to 2 decimal places, e.g., 32.16.)
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT