Question

In: Psychology

Jodie and Mary were conjoined twins sharing a single heart and a single pair of lung....

Jodie and Mary were conjoined twins sharing a single heart and a single pair of lung. Without intervention, both would die within six months. If separated, Jodie would live but Mary would die immediately. The parents refused permission to operate, believing that it would be wrong to hasten Mary’s death. Devout Catholics, they said that “nature should take its course” and “If it’s God’s will that both our children should not survive then so be it.” After a court intervention, the operation was performed over the parents’ objection and as expected, Jodie lived and Mary died.

For the purposes of this discussion, we will assume that Jodie can go on to live a fairly normal life. This is not a case where Jodie’s death would not be a harm to her.

Also, we will be concerned with which course of action would be the right one, and not with who has the right to make the decision. Plausibly, the parents had that right and it was violated by the court. But we can still ask: What decision should the parents have made?

Utilitarians are consequentialists, and consequentialism itself is a hotly debated idea among moral philosophers. The idea that we should always act so as to bring about the best outcome is incredibly attractive, but many have found it to be very objectionable. Kantians, for example, are anti-consequentialists and would argue in this case that it is always wrong to sacrifice the life of one to save the life of another.


Solutions

Expert Solution

This is an ethical delimma as the parents will find it very difficult to chose between botht the girls. As they are told that both girls will die within 6 months but they are devout Christians so they left it on the will of God. However, doctors have a moral obligation that is why they must have taken it to court and the court ordered that the surgery be done soon. Here, the court acted with a utilitarian view when it intervened because it felt that it was making the right decisions for the parents. This is debatable from from the parents view point, they gave birth to the girls and they are their responsibility, therefore they have the right to decide what is best for them. Therefore they took the Kantian approach where it is believed that it is wrong to sacrifice one life to save another.

In situations like these, it is a very tough call to take. If the parents take a utilitarian view, they will alsways feel guilty that they didn't give both girls a chance to live. When they took the Kantian view, they felt maybe there is a chance of survival for both girls.


Related Solutions

The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute completed a large-scale study of cholesterol and heart disease,...
The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute completed a large-scale study of cholesterol and heart disease, and reported that the national average for blood cholesterol level of 50-year old males was 210 mg/dl. A total of 89 men with cholesterol readings in the average range (200 – 220) volunteered for a low cholesterol diet for 12 weeks. At the end of the dieting period their average cholesterol reading was 204 mg/dl with a SD of 33 mg/dl. a. What is...
A) Six different mutations were derived from base pair substitutions at a single codon. In this...
A) Six different mutations were derived from base pair substitutions at a single codon. In this codon, the mutant alleles had asparagine, glutamic acid, g;lutamine, methionine, arginine, and a stop codon. What was the wild-type codon?
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. Note that...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. Note that identical twins are genetically the “same” person. One child was taken at random from each pair to form an experimental group and this group participated in a program designed to promote creative thinking. The other child was placed in a control group where no training was provided. At the end of the program, each group was given a creative problem-solving test with the results...
At the heart of Agency Theory are the twin issues of Goal Conflict and Risk Sharing.  ...
At the heart of Agency Theory are the twin issues of Goal Conflict and Risk Sharing.   Discuss each of these what each is; why it creates problems; and what can be done to counteract it (only one option is needed).
At the heart of Agency Theory are the twin issues of Goal Conflict and Risk Sharing....
At the heart of Agency Theory are the twin issues of Goal Conflict and Risk Sharing. Discuss each of these what each is; why it creates problems; and what can be done to counteract it (only one option is needed).
At the heart of Agency Theory are the twin issues of Goal Conflict and Risk Sharing.  ...
At the heart of Agency Theory are the twin issues of Goal Conflict and Risk Sharing.   Discuss each of these what each is; why it creates problems; and what can be done to counteract it (only one option is needed).
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child was taken at random from each pair to form an experimental group. These children participated in a program designed to promote creative thinking. The other child from each pair was part of the control group that did not participate in the program to promote creative thinking. At the end of the program, a creative problem-solving test was given, with the results shown in the...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child...
Six sets of identical twins were randomly selected from a population of identical twins. One child was taken at random from each pair to form an experimental group. These children participated in a program designed to promote creative thinking. The other child from each pair was part of the control group that did not participate in the program to promote creative thinking. At the end of the program, a creative problem-solving test was given, with the results shown in the...
Access the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute of the National Institute of Health (NIH) and...
Access the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute of the National Institute of Health (NIH) and obtain client/patient teaching information regarding hypertension. Design a client/patient teaching handout (no more than 2 pages) discussing hypertension prevention, treatment (medications), and dietary modifications. This is a handout you could print and give to your patient to take home.
a) Discuss the operation of the heart lung machine, detailing the individual functionality with necessary diagram/s....
a) Discuss the operation of the heart lung machine, detailing the individual functionality with necessary diagram/s. [10 marks]
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT