Question

In: Economics

Critical Thinking Assignment Four Should Social Security be privatized? Would you support a partial privatization? How...

Critical Thinking Assignment Four

  1. Should Social Security be privatized? Would you support a partial privatization? How would you go about investing your private share for your retirement? What is the drawback of letting individuals bear all the risk in their retirement? Is this a safe plan for the future of Social Security?

PLEASE WRITE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE!!! I need to complete a full page

Solutions

Expert Solution

Social Security Privatisation

I could not support social security privatisation.

Social security is an enormously successful program which is essential to the retirement security of the vast majority of employess all over the world.In America, social security is the single largest source of retirement income. About 62%of social security benefiaries receive over half their income from social security. For over 20% of retirees, social security is their only source of income. without social security over 40% of elderly would fall into poverty.Social security provide a sound, basic income that lasts as long as employee live.

But I could support partial privatisation of social security. Becouse , partial privatization provide dual opportunity to multiple income or contribution. Portion of retirement contribution investing in private securities give more profit or return than social security. I think , this dual play ensure at same time safety and risk of return.

Partial privatization of social security is an only optional, those who love risk or those who are able to contribute more they can choose, this is an extra source of revenue. Partial privatisation is more benefial for both government and individuals. Following are the benefit of privatization of social security:

Privatizing social security can boost workers rate of return by allowing retirement contributions to be invested in private assests, such as stocks, which yield a better return than the present pay-as- employees- go retirement system.It would replace the pay-as-employees-go social security system with privately run-system in which each taxpayer has a seperate account. Those in favor of privatization believe this approach would result in a higher rate of savings, better returns, and a higher standard of living for retiress.

The ideological advantages, for moving toward a private retirement system:

  • Social Security privatization lift the rate of return workers obtain on their retirement contributins
  • It boost national saving and present and future economic growth. So government can contribute more income to social security and social wealfare.
  • Privatization of social security has practical political advantages in comparison with a social security rescue plan based on higher payroll taxes and a bigger accumulation of social security reserves.

How would you go about investing your private share for your retirement

Diversification of Investment.

Aims to maximise returns by investing in different areas that wuold each react differenly to the same event. Diversification provide both security and high level of risk for returns.If people are willing to take systematic and unsystematic risk, this is the best way of retirement investment.

Drowback of social security privatization

  • Privatization is not a plan to save social security

Privatization isn’t a plan to save Social Security. It is a plan to dismantle Social Security. Private accounts do nothing to address Social Security solvency. In fact, because private accounts are financed by taking money out of Social Security, privatization nearly doubles Social Security’s funding gap and moves forward the date of its insolvency.

  • Huge cut of social security benefit

Privatization results in huge cuts in Social Security benefits with no guarantee that private investment can replace lost benefits. Most plans would reduce guaranteed Social Security benefits over time, even for those people who do not choose a private account. For those who opt for a private account, benefits would be reduced even further.

  • No surety for account and benefits

Privatization leaves little to be passed on to one’s heirs. Many plans would force account holders, upon retirement, to use the assets in their private accounts to purchase, at a minimum, an annuity sufficient to raise their total remaining Social Security benefits and monthly annuity payments to a poverty level income. The remaining assets in the account could then be used during retirement to make up for the plan’s huge cuts in Social Security benefits. Only the excess after required annuitization and after expenses of retirement would be available to pass on to one’s heirs.

  • Chanse of bias and manipulation

Private accounts may be voluntary, but the cuts are not. Even for those people who choose not to participate in a private account, Social Security benefits would be cut. Those cuts would effectively transfer money from those who opt out of accounts to those who opt in, forcing workers who decide against exposing themselves to the risks of Wall Street to subsidize those who are more willing to gamble with their retirement.

Is this a safe plan for the future of Social Security

No, this not a safe plan for the future of social security. Becouse, Investment risk is huge. Privatisation would eliminate the pay-as- you-go process,Instead, each taxpayer's contribution would be invested in a seperste account for their retirement, and its value would fluatiate with the value of thier investment in the market.

For example : Due to coronavirus outbreak, badly affected global the share markets, private securities.All most capitalist countries face unbelivable financial crisis and inflation.

If employess are no able to bear this type ( covid-19 financial risk) risk, create social and financial problems in society. So, full privatization of social security is challenging and not a safe plan .

Thank you....


Related Solutions

Critical Thinking Assignment Four The student should read appropriate parts of Chapter 17 “Domestic Policy” and...
Critical Thinking Assignment Four The student should read appropriate parts of Chapter 17 “Domestic Policy” and the course supplement before starting this analysis. Do you have health insurance? If so, how much do you pay each month? Are you satisfied with your coverage? There are 45 million Americans without any health insurance. Do you think access to health care ought to be a basic right? If so, how would you guarantee it and do you agree with ‘Obamacare’? If not,...
read the critical thinking question:How should companies respond to government request to break their own security...
read the critical thinking question:How should companies respond to government request to break their own security systems. Apple has had numerous requests from law enforcement to break into iPhones confiscated in criminal and terrorism cases. Can Apple be forced to provide a “backdoor” allowing government agencies to defeat the security they have designed into their products? and write a two page paper about this issue.
Critical Thinking Assignment Four Generally, liberals believe that people are poor because of circumstances beyond their...
Critical Thinking Assignment Four Generally, liberals believe that people are poor because of circumstances beyond their control (economics, health, society, family background), while conservatives believe people are poor because of their own individual failures (laziness, lack of character, decision not to study or pursue higher education (or lack of the discipline to do so or to follow through and work hard)). What do you believe? What steps would you propose to reduce poverty, on the basis of what you think...
Critical Thinking Assignment Four We often say that education is the key to improving one's chances...
Critical Thinking Assignment Four We often say that education is the key to improving one's chances in life, but is our educational system really equal? Compare, for example, schools in different states where you or your friends have lived. Then compare schools in the suburbs with schools in the inner cities. Why is there such a variation? Only about one-third of all high school math and science teachers majored in math or science in college. Where do you think those...
What is critical thinking? What kind of mindset should you develop to become an effective critical...
What is critical thinking? What kind of mindset should you develop to become an effective critical thinker? Is it important to understand what an argument is to be an effective critical thinker? Why or why not? In your essay, touch on Socrates and independent thinking as well as concepts such as truth. Be sure to provide examples in your essay.
How would you rather address the problems in the social security program. Will you fix the...
How would you rather address the problems in the social security program. Will you fix the current problem that we have now or create a new system like a pre-funded system where everyone did have their own account that will be airmaked for them. Discuss any problems you see with either one of them and which one would you rather support.
define Critical Thinking. Describe and explain how you will use critical thinking skills during your work...
define Critical Thinking. Describe and explain how you will use critical thinking skills during your work day as a Nursing Assistant.
Identify any four critical advantages the EHR would provide to the practice. How would you manage...
Identify any four critical advantages the EHR would provide to the practice. How would you manage the project planning and implementation of this EHR? Explain the technology security considerations and how HIPAA governs its implementation. *PLEASE ANSWER IN YOUR OWN WORDS AND IF YOU USED A WEBSITE TO HELP WITH YOUR ANSWER PLEASE PROVIDE THE SITE AS A REFERENCE, THANKS IN ADVANCE!*
For this week’s Written Assignment, you have a chance to practice your critical thinking skills. Read...
For this week’s Written Assignment, you have a chance to practice your critical thinking skills. Read the Loyalty Dilemma Case Study https://my.uopeople.edu/pluginfile.php/847836/mod_workshop/instructauthors/12.135.Harry%20Markham%20%28A%29.Minahan.pdf and write an analysis. The goal is to demonstrate critical thinking in your analysis; you do not need to become an accounting expert to critically analyze this case study. In your analysis, be sure to include: A summary of the issue. Use of at least one critical thinking strategy or tool to analyze the situation and highlight key...
What are the pros and cons of replacing social security with private funds? Do you support...
What are the pros and cons of replacing social security with private funds? Do you support privatization or not support it? Provide arguments to support your side.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT