Question

In: Psychology

Was Milgram's work ethical in terms of professional scientific conduct? Were the "benefits" obtained from his...

Was Milgram's work ethical in terms of professional scientific conduct? Were the "benefits" obtained from his work enough to offset the "costs"? Were subjects truly debriefed at the end of their participation?

Solutions

Expert Solution

  • Milgram's 1963 experiment broke the code of conduct in regard to what constitutes an ethical study in a number of ways, and if presented today, Milgram would likely not gain the approval to carry out his study in the first place.
  • The first issue was that Milgram used deception; he thought this to be necessary to help meet his aims in a valid way, and although some levels of deception are sometimes acceptable, in this case not disclosing the true nature of the study led to further issues. Due to this, full informed consent could not be gained and only in a debrief were participants told that the study was not about intelligence, but rather the effects of authority on obedience.
  • However, throughout and some time after the experiment, several participants experiences psychological harm as they believed they were seriously harming an individual, and later felt sever guilt that just because they instructed, they would in fact administer fatal electric shocks to another human being.
  • Moreover, psychological conduct states that participants should be allowed a right to withdrawm from a study at any given time, however in this experiment, whenever the participant expressed signs of distress and wanting to quit, they were urged to continue by the 'scientist' until they continued, with only a small minority not seeing the experiment all the way to the end.
  • Therefore, even though participants did not experience any pain or long-term damage, they were not put in a position where they could give full informed consent, were placed in highly stressful situations and found difficulty in withdraing from such circumstances, making this one of the most unethical experiments in psychological history.
  • Milgram suggested that the subjects were "dehoaxed" after the experiments. However, Perry's findings revealed that of the 700 or so people who took part in different variations of his studies between 1961 and 1962, very few were truly debriefed.
  • A true debriefing would have involved explaining that the shocks weren't real and that the other person was not injured. Instead, Milgram's sessions were mainly focused on calming the subjects down before sending them on their way. Many left in a state of considerable distress. While the truth was revealed to some months or even years later, many were simply never told a thing.
  • Due to time limit,any remaining questions can be asked as another question,they will be answered,thankyou for your cooperation


Related Solutions

Create an ethical code of conduct for those in governance, management, and professional staff for a...
Create an ethical code of conduct for those in governance, management, and professional staff for a long term care facility
List some of the professional conduct and ethical practice expected in the clinical setting.
List some of the professional conduct and ethical practice expected in the clinical setting.
Jimmy Football is retiring from his sport. Under terms defined by his professional league, Jimmy has...
Jimmy Football is retiring from his sport. Under terms defined by his professional league, Jimmy has a choice. He can receive either (a) monthly payments of $21,000 each for 20 years (240 total monthly payments) with the first monthly payment occurring precisely five years from today or (b) monthly payments of $19,000 each for 20 years (240 total monthly payments) with the first monthly payment occurring one month from today. A discount rate of 2.64%/year is appropriate for valuing these...
First, review the terms and definitions identified in the “Principles of Professional Conduct” section of the...
First, review the terms and definitions identified in the “Principles of Professional Conduct” section of the preamble to the AICPA Professional Code of Conduct. Select one of the principles (e.g., responsibilities, public interest, integrity, objectivity and independence, due care, or scope and nature of services) and research a current event that demonstrates that principle being threatened or otherwise not adhered to. (This does not need to be a case strictly about accounting—it could be any relevant business scenario. If you...
According to the Code of Conduct for management accountants (IMA’s Statement of Ethical Professional Practice), the...
According to the Code of Conduct for management accountants (IMA’s Statement of Ethical Professional Practice), the resolution of an ethical conflict in a firm that has not developed its own processes: A) should begin with the employee’s immediate supervisor as long as he or she is not involved B) should never involve lower level or newly hired employees C) does not have to take place as long as your supervisor deems that the problem should be ignored. D) should immediately...
Using the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (the Code), imagine an ethical situation that arises in...
Using the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct (the Code), imagine an ethical situation that arises in your work involving you. Discuss whether you can resolve it using the Code. Are there any limitations to the guidance that the Code provides? If yes, what are they and what sources might you look to resolve your ethical dilemma? Try to think of a situation not directly addressed by the Code which causes you to need to use one of the “decision trees.”
Read the following case study and answer the questions that follow. Professional and Ethical Conduct in...
Read the following case study and answer the questions that follow. Professional and Ethical Conduct in the Public Sector One of the basic values and principles governing public administration enshrined in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (Chapter 10) is that “a high standard of professional ethics must be promoted and maintained. Ethics is a process by which we clarify right and wrong and act on what we take to be right, that is, a set or...
How do you understand Professional Ethics and Benefits of ethical management of prodession?
How do you understand Professional Ethics and Benefits of ethical management of prodession?
Code of Ethics reflecting what should be your professional responsibilities and ethical conduct as an Information...
Code of Ethics reflecting what should be your professional responsibilities and ethical conduct as an Information technology student.
All public companies now have a Code of Ethical Conduct. In addition there are professional organizations...
All public companies now have a Code of Ethical Conduct. In addition there are professional organizations that assist in helping their members resolve ethical conflicts. Go to the Institute of Management Accountant’s website (http://www.imanet.org/docs/default-source/press_releases/ethics_prof_prac.pdf?sfvrsn=2) to view its Statement on Ethical Professional Practice. If you experience an ethical dilemma at your organization, would the recommendations presented in the “Resolution of Ethical Conflict” be helpful? Have you, or any you have known, been faced with an ethical dilemma at work? How has...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT