Question

In: Operations Management

Case study Susan Chumley has worked at Suspenders Ltd for six months and has been appointed...

Case study

Susan Chumley has worked at Suspenders Ltd for six months and has been appointed a team leader. In the time she has been there, out of the eight members of her team who were there when she joined three have left and one is on long-term sick after having a breakdown. She has to attend meetings of other team leaders and supervisors. At one of the meetings she was told that certain suppliers were to be given ‘special payments’ providing certain delivery and quality targets were met. These were to be paid directly to named individuals and arrangements would be made to pay them in cash. In the records these were to be described as ‘advisory fees’. Susan and her colleagues were told only to deal with these named individuals and no one else.

After work her friend Maureen asked Susan if she would like some electrical goods that had been ‘damaged’ in the stores. Maureen revealed that stores staff regularly siphoned off consumer electrical goods and sold them cheaply to staff – suppliers simply replaced any damaged goods and didn’t ask for them to be returned so this practice was simple and effective. Maureen had bought a 42-inch plasma television for £100 from one of the stores staff. Susan declined.

At home Susan’s daughter asked her if she could have some paper and pens for school. Susan said she would bring home a packet of paper and a box of pens the next day from the stationery store. Next day Susan finished her work, messaged a friend in Cyprus on Facebook and bought some new outfits for work from some online shopping websites. She then went home, remembering to take with her the pens and paper her daughter wanted.

Discussion Questions

Marks

  1. How has the behavior of the staff been influenced by the ethical behavior of the company?
  2. What are the ethical issues in Susan’s behavior? Is her behavior acceptable or excusable in any way?
  3. How should management deal with incidences of such behavior by staff?
  4. What processes and procedures could be put in place to reduce incidences of this type of behavior by staff and what should management do to make them effective

3

3

2

1

Presentation, clarity and layout of the submitted assignment

1

Total Marks

10

Solutions

Expert Solution

1) Clearly the staff has been behaving unethically and has been influenced by unethical behaviour from management. The management decision to pay supplier special payments when the payments are already contracted under purchase order for timely delivery and quality requirements is clearly unethical. Also classifying such payments as advisory fees amount to financial fraud. Therefore, unethical practices have been happening from the top level and this has influenced negatively the behaviour of junior level management and staff.

2)The ethical issue in Susan's behaviour are the use of pen's and paper or stationery items for personal purpose. These are property of the company and hence cannot be used for personal use. Also, Susan knew about unethical practices in the company and has not raised these issues in meetings nor raised any alarms about declining ethical behaviours. She is also a participant to such unethical behaviour although on low-value terms. Her behaviour is not excusable nor acceptable as this can lead to more unethical behaviour which may lead to major costs for the company.

3)Management should take stern action against such behaviours especially the executives involved in payment benefits for suppliers should be fired and so should Maureen and other staff involved in siphoning electrical goods. Susan should be given a warning and it should be explicitly stated that stationaries should not be taken for home use.

4) The management should put in an auditing practice to audit inventories in place. Also, scrap and rejected materials should be discarded as soon as possible either sold for resale or scrap. Proper inventory data should be maintained and regular or surprise audits should be carried out. Random checking should be done by security and CCTV should be placed in the factory premises. Management must review the audit processes and procedures from time to time and should hold the individual managers responsible in case of mismatches.


Related Solutions

Case study This case study is about Zama Brooks Ltd, a company that has been known...
Case study This case study is about Zama Brooks Ltd, a company that has been known to have bad results for the past three years. Our company has been trying to carry out an analysis to undermine whether acquisition of controlling shares in Zama Brooks Ltd will yield fruits. You are the financial director in the company interested in obtaining controlling shares in Zama Brooks Ltd and management at the company are so eager to produce good results. Management has...
CASE STUDY /big 4 Consultants has been appointed by a leading group in hotel industry to...
CASE STUDY /big 4 Consultants has been appointed by a leading group in hotel industry to prepare feasibility report for opening a five-star hotel in Ras al Khaima. The group had been most successful one in the hotel industry and had always kept its eyes open for new opportunities. In view of the very fast industrial growth in the city of Ras al Khaima, the city had attracted the attention of the group. It is historically known as Julfar, is...
A new accountant has been appointed to the firm of Catherine Ltd, which is a reporting...
A new accountant has been appointed to the firm of Catherine Ltd, which is a reporting entity that prepares general purpose financial statements according to the AASB standards. This company owns a large number of depreciable assets. Upon analyzing the entity’s current depreciation policy, which is based on straight line depreciation method the accountant realized that financial statements prepared by the entity do not show the true and fair view of company’s financial position. He, with the approval of the...
Case study You have just been appointed to be a U.S. Foreign Service Officer (FSO), employed...
Case study You have just been appointed to be a U.S. Foreign Service Officer (FSO), employed by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). Your first assignment is working overseas in an embassy where you may give out millions of dollars in foreign aid loans to an important nation. This nation has two types of loans from the United States government. Type I loans for $2,000,000,000 and Type II loans for $34,000,000,000. Type I loans are listed by country...
CASE STUDY FINANCIAL VIABILITY INDICATORS Kulula Ltd has been incorporated as an investment advisory company. The...
CASE STUDY FINANCIAL VIABILITY INDICATORS Kulula Ltd has been incorporated as an investment advisory company. The company sources for consulting services in investment appraisal and company valuation. You have recently joined the company as an investment analyst. You have been assigned to conduct an investment appraisal of two projects that a client is considering investing in. The two projects are tomato growing using drip irrigation and the second project is keeping layers for egg production. The initial investment required for...
What is the monitoring and Evaluation and diagnosis of this case study Susan is a 1...
What is the monitoring and Evaluation and diagnosis of this case study Susan is a 1 year old baby presenting with the complaints of loose stools since 3 days.on physical examination she is not well appeared according to chronological age. I want long answer
Case Study Budgeting XY Ltd plans to sell the following: Months Product A (units) June 1200...
Case Study Budgeting XY Ltd plans to sell the following: Months Product A (units) June 1200 July 1800 August 2800 September 3200 October 3200 Stock of finished goods at 1 June was 240 units and the company’s stockholding policy for the finished goods stock at the end of each month to represent 20% of the following month’s sales requirement. Each unit of product A uses two units of a component X1. On 1 June there were expected to be 264...
For the last six months, Jill has been with A&A Accounting, a multi-billion dollar entity. A&A...
For the last six months, Jill has been with A&A Accounting, a multi-billion dollar entity. A&A has a high-level person responsible for their ethics compliance program who requires all personnel to view 20 hours of compliance videos. While on a flight to another city, Jill happened to sit behind A&A’s ethics officer and overheard the following: “Yes, Bill, we do have a pretty good compliance program, but it’s really just window dressing. Because of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines we have...
Peter has been working with Marcus for six months to implement his individualised plan. Marcus has...
Peter has been working with Marcus for six months to implement his individualised plan. Marcus has an intellectual disability that impairs his ability to communicate and to understand complex concepts. Marcus’ father acts as his advocate. Marcus has a goal to learn to prepare a meal for himself. Marcus has not made much progress towards achieving this goal. Marcus’ parents tell Peter that Marcus does not like the support worker who is supporting him, as he gets impatient when Marcus...
Case Study: Greenly Insurance Company Greenly has worked hard over the past year and has increased...
Case Study: Greenly Insurance Company Greenly has worked hard over the past year and has increased their marketing efforts to reach certain “untapped” demographics. Greenly has determined that it has been able to retain its Generation Y customers, who have established their own households. Greenly’s new survey of former customers has revealed that it is losing its Baby Boomer customers who like to shop for coverage based on price. One of the reasons most often cited for leaving is the...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT