Question

In: Psychology

Problem: On Monday morning when you enter your law office, you find Dr. Ben Heartache, the...

Problem:

On Monday morning when you enter your law office, you find Dr. Ben Heartache, the fastest scalpel in the West, waiting. He needs legal advice.

Two weeks earlier, Dr. Heartache explained, he emerged from the operating room after completing an exhausting three hour operation. He was immediately asked to go to the emergency room in order to assist with a diagnosis regarding an accident case. When the doctor arrived in the emergency room, he found an unconscious Professor Smith being attended to by his son, David

David was so upset it was difficult for the doctor to find out exactly what had taken place. Apparently, the professor and his son were out for a Sunday drive when his car was hit by a large truck. The doctor immediately concluded that the professor needed emergency brain surgery, and advised David that a request had already been made for a prominent brain surgeon from the State University to come and operate on his father. Unfortunately, the university medical facility was located 78 miles away, and the professor's condition was such that he might die before the

surgeon arrived.

David pleaded with Dr. Heartache. "I know you're exhausted, but I'm begging you. I'll give you $45,000 if you will operate on my father. Please, please, operate!" The doctor, moved by David's plea, decided to operate. Fighting back fatigue, Dr. Heartache performed valiantly. I certainly earned that fee, the doctor said to himself, as he emerged from the operating room.

The doctor truly put everything he had into the operation, but the injury was too great, and the professor died a few hours after the operation. When David learned what had happened, he fainted.

Two days later, Dr. Heartache received an angry letter from David. "Your incompetence was responsible for my father's death," he wrote. "Obviously, I'm not paying you a red cent.

Try and collect, and I'll make your life a living hell!"

Dr. Heartache feels that a valid contract entitling him to $45,000 was entered into by both parties. He feels that he has earned the fee, and would like to collect. How would you advise the doctor?

Solutions

Expert Solution

There can be few options which can be presented before the doctor

1. To consider the operation of Professor Smith as a moral duty :

By considering the operation as moral service can be a way of dealing with the situation , so in this way the monetary value will be very less . Serving the needy and patients is considered as one of the most important act to be performed by the doctor . Here the serving of the patients should be without thinking about the monetary reward . Now doctor can get out of the situation by considering his help to the professor as a service of kindness.

2. To act in a practical way by taking the contract money from David :

Being practical in this situation can be a solution where he let the time pass as David is at present emotionally driven by the loss of his father. So by understanding the denial by the David as a emotional outburst and dealing with the time can be a solution where doctor can ask for the contract money as the things gets normalized . The further denial can be taken in front of the court where presenting the necessary evidences can be a solution too


Related Solutions

On Monday morning, Andy and Brian enter an oral, unwritten contract for the sale of five...
On Monday morning, Andy and Brian enter an oral, unwritten contract for the sale of five acres of land in Delray Beach, Florida, at “$10,000 per acre.” On Tuesday morning, Andy demands that Brian pay him “$11,000 per acre” for the land. Brian refuses. Andy sues. Who should win, and why? In your answer, explain written/oral and implied/express contracts.
Murphy's Law: What Can Go Wrong, Will You come into the office in the morning to...
Murphy's Law: What Can Go Wrong, Will You come into the office in the morning to find a message from the executive sponsor of your project asking you to come see him urgently. The meeting begins with the usual pleasantries; "How's your family? How's the weather? How's the team doing? How's the project going? etc" but you can sense that something is amiss. The bomb drops..... Due to new urgent priorities, your project budget has been cut by 25% and...
Read the following scenario: Dr. Smith has a full morning of minor office surgeries scheduled for...
Read the following scenario: Dr. Smith has a full morning of minor office surgeries scheduled for today. Sarah, his nurse, has set up the room and prepared the patient. Prior to starting, Dr. Smith requests anesthetic without epinephrine due to the location of the surgical site. Searching the drawers and supply closet, Sarah reports, "We don't have any." Fortunately, Sarah was able to borrow a vial from the physician in an adjacent office suite. Investigation by the office manager reveals...
On arriving his office at Efficient Systems Inc.(ESI) early morning Monday, Mr. Laziross w Mr. Terribeel...
On arriving his office at Efficient Systems Inc.(ESI) early morning Monday, Mr. Laziross w Mr. Terribeel asked him why the company's cash balance was different from the checking Mr. Laziross listed the following items to explain the difference. 1 The bank statement for the checking account of ESI showed a balance of $14632.12 on S 2 Oustanding checks were $1,320.25 3 The September 30 cash receipts of $575 were not deposited in the bank until October 2. 4 One check...
Part I You are a volunteer in a California medical office of Dr. Williams. Dr. Williams...
Part I You are a volunteer in a California medical office of Dr. Williams. Dr. Williams specializes in rare neuromuscular and musculoskeletal disorders. You’re also a grad student and working with Dr. Williams has allowed you to gain first-hand experience with some of the material that you’re learning in your human physiology course. Today a group of high school students is coming for a tour and Dr. Williams has asked you to prepare some information about muscles to present to...
Part I You are a volunteer in a California medical office of Dr. Williams. Dr. Williams...
Part I You are a volunteer in a California medical office of Dr. Williams. Dr. Williams specializes in rare neuromuscular and musculoskeletal disorders. You’re also a grad student and working with Dr. Williams has allowed you to gain first-hand experience with some of the material that you’re learning in your human physiology course. Today a group of high school students is coming for a tour and Dr. Williams has asked you to prepare some information about muscles to present to...
On Monday morning you sell one June T-bond futures contract at 97:27, that is, for $97,843.75....
On Monday morning you sell one June T-bond futures contract at 97:27, that is, for $97,843.75. The contract's face value is $100,000. The initial margin requirement is $2,700, and the maintenance margin requirement is $2,000 per contract. Use the following price data to answer the following questions. Day Settle Monday $97,406.25 Tuesday $98,000.00 Wednesday $100,000.00 The cumulative rate of return on your investment after Wednesday is a ________. 2.6% loss 53.9% loss 79.9% loss 33% gain
History of Present Problem: Ben Potter is a 4-month-old male presented to the pediatrician’s office for...
History of Present Problem: Ben Potter is a 4-month-old male presented to the pediatrician’s office for a routine well-child exam. Ben is accompanied by his mother, Pamela, a 19-year-old single mother. Pamela appears visibly tired and reports that Ben has been getting up more frequently in the night, crying but refusing to eat. Pamela reports that over the past three weeks, Ben often refuses his formula feedings and reports episodes of gagging, arching his back, and frequent crying during and...
1.When looking at the law of demand, you will find that this is an inverse relationship...
1.When looking at the law of demand, you will find that this is an inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded. How do you relate the law of demand to a recent purchase that you have had to make? 2.When looking at prices, you will find that they are always changing in our economy. Why do you think this is important to evaluate for our economy?
Imagine you are a time traveller and you enter a small medieval village and find your...
Imagine you are a time traveller and you enter a small medieval village and find your way to the only inn. The innkeeper rents rooms for $10 a week, which you pay, as that is the exact amount of money you brought. The innkeeper promptly goes across the street and buys a new pair of shoes (which were just being finished) from the cobbler for $10. Later the same day, the cobbler purchases a new bridle and a set of...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT