Explain Thomas's famous "Unconscious violinist " thought experiment. what is this thought experiment supposed to show...

Explain Thomas's famous "Unconscious violinist " thought experiment. what is this thought experiment supposed to show about abortion?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Thomas puts forth a thought experiment known as unconscious violinist as a defense of abortion. The thought experiment is as follows - Finding yourself kidnapped and your circulatory system been plugged to an unconscious violinist, who suffers from fatal kidney problem, leaves the person with two choices. Despite being well aware of the fact that disconnecting the plugs can make the violinist die and only you can save him by staying connected to him for 9 months, does not affect your right to choose from the two options. Its your right on your life and body to disconnect the plug. The violinist does not have any right on you. If you stay connected, it would only be out of kindness and his right to life is not linked to that of yours. Unplugging does not violate violinist's right to life, but it just deprives him of your body, on which he has no right.

Thomas uses this thought experiment and explains that the fetus's right to life is not violated by abortion, but abortion deprives the use of women's body by the fetus. So abortion can kill the fetus but it does not violate the fetus's right to life but the women just chose not to get her body used, based on her own right. The woman has right on her body and the fetus has no right on the woman's body.

Hayet Jeridi answered 4 months ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Is the case of the famous violinist really analogous to a case of pregnancy caused by...

Is the case of the famous violinist really analogous to a case of pregnancy caused by rape? https://spot.colorado.edu/~heathwoo/Phil160,Fall02/thomson.htm

What is The Chinese Room thought experiment?

What is the differences between subconscious, unconscious and preconcious? Explain it with examples.

ASSESSMENT METHOD: How is the thought process or the unconscious accessed using alfred alder's theory?

Explain the reasoning behind Harlow’s decision to conduct his famous experiment on monkeys. Explain the experimental...

Explain the reasoning behind Harlow’s decision to conduct his famous experiment on monkeys. Explain the experimental setup, the findings, and his conclusions. In your opinion was his experiment worth the “cost”, in terms of the cost to the monkeys’ wellbeing as compared to the knowledge we gained from this research.

How does the following brief thought experiment fail to show that general relativity (GR) has a...

How does the following brief thought experiment fail to show that general relativity (GR) has a major problem in regards to black holes? The full thought experiment is in my blog post. The post claims that GR violates its own equivalence principle at the horizon of a black hole. The principle says that the laws of physics in any sufficiently small, freely falling frame are the same as they are in an inertial frame in an idealized, gravity-free universe. Here's...

I thought for this type of question I am supposed to make a chart with the...

I thought for this type of question I am supposed to make a chart with the inventory, purchases, sales, etc., but instead, these questions are throwing me off for the little understanding I have on this new topic... Kayla Company uses the perpetual inventory system and the LIFO method. The following information is available for the month of June: June 1 Beginning inventory 200 units @ $5 12 Purchase on account 400 units @ $6 15 Sales on account 440...

1. A famous scientist, Mendel, conducted a genetic experiment with peas. On sample from this experiment...

1. A famous scientist, Mendel, conducted a genetic experiment with peas. On sample from this experiment consisted of 428 green peas and 152 yellow peas (There are no other colors) a. how many peas are there altogether b. calculate a 95% confidence interval for the percentage of yellow peas. write your answer in english c. find the margin of error

2 LM model: thought experiment: Use money market equilibrium to graphically show how LM curve shift...

2 LM model: thought experiment: Use money market equilibrium to graphically show how LM curve shift in following cases: (1) the Fed decide to sell government bonds this year; (2) the public’s inflation expection rises because one of the Fed officials told the media that the Fed will increase the money supply significantly next year in 2019. (3) real GDP increases because technology improves.

Explain whether, and how, the experience machine thought experiment poses a challenge to hedonism. How do...

Explain whether, and how, the experience machine thought experiment poses a challenge to hedonism. How do Utilitarians respond to this challenge?

Subjects