IS THE INCOMPETENCY TO STAND TRIAL A VALID ARGUMENT FOR THE DEFENSE TO PRODUCE? EXPLAIN YOUR...

IS THE INCOMPETENCY TO STAND TRIAL A VALID ARGUMENT FOR THE DEFENSE TO PRODUCE? EXPLAIN YOUR POSITION.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Note: This response is in UK English, please paste the response to MS Word and you should be able to spot discrepancies easily. You may elaborate the answer based on personal views or your classwork if necessary.

(Answer) When one is on trial, it would entail things such as producing witnesses, being a witness if necessary, stating under oath, making serious claims and accusations, producing evidence against the defense etc. Let us assume that the person who would be doing all of this, isn’t of a sound mind. Perhaps, that person might suffer from a cognitive disorder like psychosis, anxiety or other such issues.

Being in an impaired mental and emotional state would greatly affect the validity of their statements and evidence as it would not be as objective anymore. Furthermore, an improper cognitive state could even cause the person to commit perjury, producing false leads or other serious offenses. Under all these possible circumstances, the defendant would be completely justified to claim incompetency as a valid argument. In other words, one has to be of a sound mind in order to responsibly accommodate the gravitas of the seriousness of the legal system.

Hayet Jeridi answered 3 months ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Explain the difference between a valid argument and a sound argument, and give an example of...

Explain the difference between a valid argument and a sound argument, and give an example of each.

Clearly and briefly articulate and explain in your own words 1 argument used in defense of...

Clearly and briefly articulate and explain in your own words 1 argument used in defense of an active stabilization policy.

Suppose the economy is in a recession. Which of the following is a valid argument for...

Suppose the economy is in a recession. Which of the following is a valid argument for using expansionary fiscal policy, instead of monetary policy? Select one: a. Fiscal policy is more effective than monetary policy in a deep recession b. Fiscal policy is slower than monetary policy c. Fiscal policymakers are subject to more political influence, so some of their spending tends to be wasteful. d. Government spending could lead to lower growth through the crowding-out effect

1) What does it mean to say that an argument is valid?

Summarize the argument that was used by both Alcoa and DuPont in their defense as they...

Summarize the argument that was used by both Alcoa and DuPont in their defense as they were tried in court for violation of antitrust laws.

Are we addicted to our smartphone? Show your argument clearly by giving at least valid reasons...

Are we addicted to our smartphone? Show your argument clearly by giving at least valid reasons supported by examples and evidence. Write at least 250 words but no more than 500 words. When you write, make sure your writing: • addresses all parts of the task • presents a clear position of your argument • presents main ideas • arranges information and ideas coherently • uses cohesive devices effectively • use referencing clearly or appropriately • uses paragraphing logically •...

Construct your own valid DEDUCTIVE arguments by applying the FIVE argument forms (rules) on the worksheet...

Construct your own valid DEDUCTIVE arguments by applying the FIVE argument forms (rules) on the worksheet below. You will need to insert your own example for each rule, following the form of the argument. A TRANSLATION KEY MUST BE PROVIDED FOR EACH EXERCISE (see above for an example). FORMS/RULES: Modus Ponens 1) If p, then q. 2) p. ------------------- 3) Thus, q. Modus Tollens 1) If p, then q. 2) Not q. ------------------- 3) Thus, not p. Hypothetical Syllogism 1)...

5. Explain why the infant-industry argument is valid. 6. Explain one reason why the U.S. dollar...

5. Explain why the infant-industry argument is valid. 6. Explain one reason why the U.S. dollar has higher value than the Indian Ruppies in the international exchange rate marketplace. 7. write out one major difference between a country's balance of trade(BOT) and Balance of Payment (bop). 8. Explain the reason why loans to a country are entered on the Credit Side of that country's Balance of Payment account. 9. Why does the supply of a country's currency increase if/when the...

Introduction to logic: Translate each argument using the letters provided and prove the argument valid using...

Introduction to logic: Translate each argument using the letters provided and prove the argument valid using all eight rules of implication. Sam will finish his taxes and Donna pay her property taxes or Sam will finish his taxes and Henry will go to the DMV. If Sam finishes his taxes, then his errands will be done and he will be stress-free for a time. Therefore, Sam will finish his taxes and he will be stress-free for a time. (S, D,...

1. Define validity and soundness. 2. Explain why a valid argument can never have all true...

1. Define validity and soundness. 2. Explain why a valid argument can never have all true premises and a false conclusion. 3. Are invalid arguments weak? Explain your answer.

Subjects