Describe D'Holbach's argument for why we do not have free will, even though it might appear...

Describe D'Holbach's argument for why we do not have free will, even though it might appear to us that we do. Is he right? Explain your answer in 200 words.

Solutions

Expert Solution

D'Holbach suggests that there is only matter in this universe and this matter functions according to the physical law they are tied to. This would mean that all that operates in this world do not do so because they have decided to do so but because they are forced to do so, thus questioning freewill. He further elaborates that human beings as part of the matter function in the same way as they wouldn’t be able to alter the universe but would act as per the physical law that would be directed through the brain impulses. He rejects the notion of a supernatural entity or soul that guides human beings by stating the actions of the human being are the reactions to the already determined world in front of them. He brings out the importance of people as the prisoners of their own environment in which they are forced to act in a certain way whether they like it or not. According to him, since human being cannot escape the physical law, free will is only an illusion and no one can escape the physical law that keeps every matter in the universe in its control. This would mean that people would only learn to live as per the physical laws and not as per their free will.

Thank you for the question. Please rate if you like the answer.

Hayet Jeridi answered 5 months ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

We can show why we don’t have observable radial acceleration effects even though the Earth is...

We can show why we don’t have observable radial acceleration effects even though the Earth is spinning and we can com ment quickly on the tangential acceleration we experience. a) Specifically, show that Cleveland’s centripetal (i.e., radial) acceleration due to the earth’s rotation is negligible in comparison with the acceleration we feel due to gravity. Put your answe r in “gees” for a direct comparison. b) By the way, what is our angular acceleration in Cleveland? (Hoohah!) And therefore what...

It is important to recognize that even though a male might have adequate sperm production in...

It is important to recognize that even though a male might have adequate sperm production in the testes, depletion of the reserves in the cauda epididymis can occur rapidly. From a practical standpoint, how many females can a animal male service in a day? Explain your reasoning.

why can we disregard the concentration of sodium hydroxide in this experiment even though we are...

why can we disregard the concentration of sodium hydroxide in this experiment even though we are measuring thr rate of the reaction between NaOH and crystal violet?

Explain why a 2:1 current ratio might not be adequate for a company even though the...

Explain why a 2:1 current ratio might not be adequate for a company even though the rule of thumb states it is.

Write a one paragraph explanation about why Riemann sums are necessary even though we have FTC...

Write a one paragraph explanation about why Riemann sums are necessary even though we have FTC from calculus I to get the exact results of an integral.

Should we mount a massive effort to restore ecosystems that we have degraded even though this...

Should we mount a massive effort to restore ecosystems that we have degraded even though this will be quite costly? For this weeks environmental controversy we explore this question. Using the textbook, and any additional outside resources, answer the questions below. Write a 1-2 paragraph response to the questions posed to you. Remember to cite your sources using APA. Ecological restoration, which is discussed in your textbook, has a critical role in protecting and understanding the Earth's environments. Unfortunately, even...

Even though episiotomy procedures are declining, why might this medical procedure be performed before or during...

Even though episiotomy procedures are declining, why might this medical procedure be performed before or during childbirth? 2). Name and explain the function of the various hormones that regulate lactation. Where are they produced, and how would you summarize their function and their influence on lactation?

Why do firms in Oligopoly appear to be colluding even when it is known that they...

Why do firms in Oligopoly appear to be colluding even when it is known that they are not? Why is Game Theory uniquely suited for analyzing the Oligopoly market structure?

Do you believe we have free will, and why? If you don’t believe in free will,...

Do you believe we have free will, and why? If you don’t believe in free will, why not? And if you believe we have free will, are you then a “strong compatibilist” like Leibniz and Kant?

Even though there are cases of Down syndrome that are more severe than others, why do...

Even though there are cases of Down syndrome that are more severe than others, why do we treat all people born with Down syndrome as if they are the same as each other? Why is this question Important to you as a member of society? Detail the major developments in social science thinking that drive questions regarding the individual. Explain how finding the answer to the question might impact other around you. Detail the major developments in social science thinking...

Subjects