In: Psychology
I am going to discuss a biological and psychological theory of
crime and to differentiate between the two perspectives,
highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each. The purpose
of this assignment is to critically assess the strengths and
weakness of various criminological theories. Crime is a phenomenon
of deviant behavior, representing a high risk to people, and
therefore punishable by law. In modern society, crime is considered
to be a socially dangerous act, prohibited by law under the threat
of punishment. Crime is the most dangerous kind of “a social
pathology” deviating from the norm, deviant behavior. Therefore,
the main backbone elements of crime are personality traits of a
potential criminal and the social conditions of life.
Biological theory
The first attempts to explain the term “crime” were of a
biological character. Scientists have searched for natural causes
due to the tendency of some people to crime. In 1870 an Italian
criminologist Cesare Lombroso concluded that some people were born
with criminal tendencies. In his point of view, criminal types can
be identified by their shape of skull. Lombroso did not deny the
fact that society could influence on the development of criminal
behavior, but believed that most perpetrators are biologically
degenerative. Subsequently, the idea of a biological predisposition
to crime has been subjected to criticism.
Lombroso’s general methodological position about the presence of a
special type such as “a criminal person” with the congenital
criminal traits and innate propensity to commit crimes. The fact
that the study of juvenile delinquency has become an integral part
of the work, which was presented Lombroso’s main theoretical
concept – once again confirms that it applies to juvenile
delinquency all the main provisions of the concept. It is important
to mention that British researchers have concluded that the
differences between criminals and criminals are practically absent,
and therefore such a phenomenon as a “criminal type” does not
exist.
Psychological theory
Psychological theory of crime, as well as biological one,
associates with criminal inclinations of a particular type of
personality. In the XX century some psychologists, based on Sigmund
Freud’s ideas, have suggested that a small percentage of people
develop “immoral”, or psychopathic personality. According to Freud,
most of our moral values come from the self-restraint, which we are
learnt from our early childhood. Due to the special nature of the
relationship with parents, some children do not produce the similar
self-restraint, and, accordingly, there is the lack of basic sense
of morality. Psychopaths can be described as a closed people
finding a big pleasure in violence.
Psychological theory of crime has, in contrast to biological one,
the rational core. However, they only can explain some aspects of
crime. Although a small minority of criminals do have the personal
characteristics that are different from the rest of the population,
but such features have not all violators of the law.