Question

In: Operations Management

1.Which, if any, of the following scenarios would support an employee’s claim of dis- crimination on...

1.Which, if any, of the following scenarios would support an employee’s claim of dis- crimination on the basis of national origin?

a. Applicant with a speech impediment is unable to pronounce the letter “r.” The

applicant therefore often has difficulty being understood when speaking and is

denied a position.

b. The owner of a manufacturing facility staffed completely by Mexicans refuses employment to a white American manager because the owner is concerned that the Mexicans will only consent to supervision by and receive direction from another Mexican.

c. An Indian restaurant seeks to fill a server position. The advertisement requests applications from qualified individuals of Indian descent to add to the authenticity of the restaurant. In the past, the restaurant found that its business declined when it used Caucasian servers because the atmosphere of the restaurant suffered. An Italian

applies for the position and is denied employment.

d. A company advertises for Japanese-trained managers, because the employer has found that they are more likely to remain at the company for an extended time, to be loyal and devoted to the firm, and to react well to direction and criticism. An American applies for the position and is denied employment in favor of an equally qualified Japanese-trained applicant, who happens to also be Japanese.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Based on Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 , an employer cannot discriminate against employees based on the national origin of the employee.The law requires one to present the following prima facie elements:

(1) the employee is a member of a protected class,

(2) that he is qualified for the relevant position,

(3) that there was an adverse employment action, and

(4) that some evidence of record supports the inference of improper motivation.

Case A: As per law, "An employer may not base an employment decision on an employee's foreign accent, unless the accent seriously interferes with the employee's job performance." Thus if this condition interferes or affects business adversely, one can be denied employment and hence may not be covered under the discrimination basis national origin clause.

Case B: Refusing to hire someone because customers or co-workers may be "uncomfortable" with that person's national origin is just as illegal as refusing to hire that person because of religion or national origin in the first place.

Case C:  If an employer states the necessity of employing a certain category because it being essential for the business, then it is not covered under discrimination basis national origin. For example, if a movie script demands the Afro-American character, one cannot contest it. Similarly, if the theme of the restaurant demands an Indian, the employer has the right to reject employment to a Caucasian/Italian server.

Case D: This is a direct case of discrimination based on national origin. A company cannot deny employment because it believes that people of one particular origin perform better , loyal or devote better to the company


Related Solutions

1.Which of the following scenarios would it be appropriate to use a normal approximation for the...
1.Which of the following scenarios would it be appropriate to use a normal approximation for the sampling distribution of the sample proportion? Select one: a.) A researcher wishes to find the probability that more than 60% of a sample of undergraduate students from UNC will be female. She samples the first 42 students that walk into the gym on Monday morning. The population proportion of undergraduate females at UNC is known to be 60.1%. b.)A researcher wishes to find the...
Which of the following scenarios would it be appropriate to use a normal approximation for the...
Which of the following scenarios would it be appropriate to use a normal approximation for the sampling distribution of the sample proportion? Select one: A researcher wishes to find the probability that more than 60% of a sample of undergraduate students from UNC will be female. She samples the first 42 students that walk into the gym on Monday morning. The population proportion of undergraduate females at UNC is known to be 60.1%. A researcher wishes to find the probability...
Review the three scenarios below. Look for which, if any, of these scenarios presents an example...
Review the three scenarios below. Look for which, if any, of these scenarios presents an example of post-investment holdup. Your firm conducted a search for a new chief financial officer and hired a highly qualified candidate with a yearly salary of $250,000. After six months, the person left to join another firm. Your firm has an exclusive contract to assemble automobile seats for a number of luxury models. Almost 100% of the materials are imported and, of those, over 50%...
Instructions Review the three scenarios below. Look for which, if any, of these scenarios presents an...
Instructions Review the three scenarios below. Look for which, if any, of these scenarios presents an example of post-investment holdup. Your firm conducted a search for a new chief financial officer and hired a highly qualified candidate with a yearly salary of $250,000. After six months, the person left to join another firm. Your firm has an exclusive contract to assemble automobile seats for a number of luxury models. Almost 100% of the materials are imported and, of those, over...
Review the three scenarios below. Look for which, if any, of these scenarios presents an example...
Review the three scenarios below. Look for which, if any, of these scenarios presents an example of post-investment holdup. Your firm conducted a search for a new chief financial officer and hired a highly qualified candidate with a yearly salary of $250,000. After six months, the person left to join another firm. Your firm has an exclusive contract to assemble automobile seats for a number of luxury models. Almost 100% of the materials are imported and, of those, over 50%...
Question: Which preventive, detective, and/or corrective controls would best mitigate the following threats? An employee’s laptop...
Question: Which preventive, detective, and/or corrective controls would best mitigate the following threats? An employee’s laptop was stolen at the airport. The laptop contained personal information about the company’s customers that could potentially be used to commit identity theft. A salesperson successfully logged into the payroll system by guessing the payroll supervisor’s password. A criminal remotely accessed a sensitive database using the authentication credentials (user ID and strong password) of an IT manager. At the time the attack occurred, the...
Question 3 In the following scenarios please indicate which of the following tests would be most...
Question 3 In the following scenarios please indicate which of the following tests would be most appropriate to use in each of the described situations: (A) Proportion test (B) 1-sample Z-test (C) 1-sample t-test (D) 2-sample t-test (E) paired t-test (F) Test of correlation (G) χ2-goodness of fit test (H) χ2 test of homogeneity (I) χ2 test of independence A steel beam manufacturer wants to know if a new process has improved the average strength of its product. They take...
2.3. Each of the following scenarios presents a claim by a researcher. Assume that the sample...
2.3. Each of the following scenarios presents a claim by a researcher. Assume that the sample sizes in each case was in the range of 20 to 25 observations per sample in each case. Answer the following for each scenario: (i) state the appropriate null (HO) and alternate hypothesis (HA) in symbolic form (e.g. Hx : Meanleft = Meanright); (ii) indicate whether it is a 1or 2-tailed test, and if a 1-tailed tests which tail is the area of rejection...
For which of the following scenarios would it be appropriate to use a one-sample z-test? A....
For which of the following scenarios would it be appropriate to use a one-sample z-test? A. Comparing the average weight of newborns in Hospital A to the average weight of newborns in Hospital B B. Comparing the political affiliation of ASU students against the political affiliation of all college students C. Comparing the number of packs of cigarettes smoked per day by residents of urban areas with the number of cigarettes smoked per day by all persons in the USA...
In each of the following scenarios, a scientist has attempted to support the hypothesis that phosphorus...
In each of the following scenarios, a scientist has attempted to support the hypothesis that phosphorus fertilization increases production of chlorophyll by the photosynthetic organisms in freshwater lakes. For each, state whether or not you would accept the conclusions and explain specifically why you would or wouldn't accept them. a. The scientist fertilizes one lake with phosphorus and takes 12 water samples 1 month later to determine the amount of chlorophyll in the lake. The scientist also takes 12 samples...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT