Question

Assume that you are the sole ethicist on the hospital’s ethics committee. You have been asked by a chair to provide an ananlysis and a recommendation as to how to deal with the situation from an ethical stance.

a) First, thought, you must find out what the legal position is. Summarize this in the beginning of the memo to the chair, I.C. Clearly M.D

b) Next, identify the significant information that is missing and why having this information could influence your analysis.Then, make a recommendation. Explain your reasoning.

c) What would you need to know to make a better recommendation in this case ?

Read the case below:-

A>B is an 17 +9 yrs old patient in a psychiatric hospital in a state that has a ban on abortions after 20 weeks.

She is 12 weeks pregnant. The father is unknown. Her mother, who is her legal guardian wants her to have an abortion. A.B refuses saying its against my principles. Neither A.B nor her mother could care for her child so, if she carried it to term, it would be placed in a foster home. This is all the information available at this time. Religious consideration is not an issue

Answer 1

A) First, thought, you must find out what the legal position is. Summarize this in the beginning of the memo to the chair, I.C. Clearly M.D

Answer:- A guardian may disclose separately classifying analytic, handling and upkeep info without the agreement of the individual who is the topic of the info to family memberships of the separate or to another individual with whom the discrete is supposed to have a nearby personal association, if the data is assumed in over-all rapports and anxieties the attendance, place, disorder, analysis, development and forecast of the individual of the day on which the info is revealed and the revelation is not conflicting to the rapid appeal of the discrete.

B) Next, identify the significant information that is missing and why having this information could influence your analysis.Then, make a recommendation. Explain your reasoning.

Answer:- To any individual if the custodian trusts, on sensible estates, that the revelation will prevent or minimalize a forthcoming hazard to the health or security of any individual. If that individual absences the mental volume to deliver agreement and, in the estimation of the curator, revelation is in the best welfares of the discrete.

C) What would you need to know to make a better recommendation in this case ?

Answer:- In agreement with this course, a youngster or childhood who has not officially requested a health care specialized to keep their data in sureness, may have their conduct or care revealed to their parent or protector. Though, if the child / minor does request for a rapid appeal of discretion, the health care provider must reflect this demand. Additionally, the health care provider can reveal info if she senses that the young individual is at danger or cannot make a suitable choice for her conduct and management.