Question

In: Accounting

Able bought a number of books from The Book Box Store Limited in a single mail...

Able bought a number of books from The Book Box Store Limited in a single mail order, and enclosed a cheque for $240 with the order, drawn on the Big City Bank. In the interval between mailing the order and the arrival of the products, Able noticed a number of the books (totaling $120) were available at a lower price at a local book store. On the day the books arrived, he visited the bank and was pleased to see that his cheque had not yet been cashed. He placed a stop payment order on the cheque, and in filling out the request slip, placed the words "goods unsatisfactory" in the box allotted for the reason for the request. Able sent back the part of the order that he had now bought more cheaply elsewhere, and assumed that The Book Box Store Limited. would send him a new invoice for $120. The Big City Bank failed to immediately enter the request into its computer system, and as a result, on the arrival of the cheque a day later, it paid Able's cheque out of his account in the normal manner. Able discovered this error in the course of using an automated cash machine a few days later, and asked the bank to correct the error. The bank put $240 back into Able’s account and told him that they would collect back the $240 that they had paid The Book Box Store Limited 's bank, The Business Bank. The Big City Bank returned the cheque in the clearing system, now marked "Payment Stopped," and demanded $240 from The Business Bank. The Business Bank refused the stopped cheque and would not make payment back, stating that by accepted banking convention, too much time had elapsed between acceptance by the Big City Bank and the return of the item. While this had been going on, The Book Box Store Limited had received the goods returned by Able and had mailed him a refund cheque for $120, for as far as they knew, they had been paid in full. Able was pleased. Clearly a computer error had sent him a $120 cheque rather than a $120 invoice, and he ignored the whole matter. Assume another week passes. Discuss the events that follow, and the positions of the parties, with respect to the law of negotiable instruments as it is written. In advising the banks, what would you suggest that they add to their standard form account operation agreements?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer:

Able’s cheque is a promise of payment only, in the sense that if honoured by his bank the holder will receive the money. When Able stopped payment on his cheque the debt remained unpaid. Under the Bills of Exchange Act, if payment is stopped, it is a dishonour of the cheque when it is presented for payment by the holder.

            However, in this case the cheque was honoured, and it was not until several days later that the Big City Bank realized that it had failed to comply with its stop payment order. Since the Act provides that notice of dishonour must be given not later than the next business day, it was too late for the Big City Bank to give notice of dishonour to the Business Bank and all prior endorsers were free of liability. The Big City Bank in this case could not look to Able for payment as it had failed to comply with his stop payment order.


Related Solutions

The manager of a music store has kept records of the number of CDs bought in...
The manager of a music store has kept records of the number of CDs bought in a single transaction by customers who make a purchase at the store. The accompanying table gives six possible outcomes and the estimated probability associated with each of these outcomes for the chance experiment that consists of observing the number of CDs purchased by a randomly selected customer at the store. Number of CDs purchased 1 2 3 4 5 6 or more Estimated probability...
ABC book store is selling business books, magazines and stationeries. The following transactions were occurred in...
ABC book store is selling business books, magazines and stationeries. The following transactions were occurred in February 2020 (GST inclusive). Feb.     6          Purchased books from Book Depository $880, terms 2/7, n/30.             7          Paid freight on February 6 purchase $44.             8          Sold inventory to customers $990, terms n/30. The inventory cost $600.             10        Returned $99 books to Book Depository.             13        Paid Book depository in full. Required Prepare the journal entries to record the transactions.
The following accounts are taken from the book of GGGG books as at 31 December 2019....
The following accounts are taken from the book of GGGG books as at 31 December 2019. Use the following information to prepare the trial balance as at 31 December 2019. RM Purchases          26,000 Sales          33,690 Capital        150,000 Cash in hand               52,000 Opening inventory            5,600 Debtors          70,910 Furniture 10,000 Creditors            1,900 Office equipment          16,000 Wages            1,780 Interest               230 Interest received            4,900 Rental          18,000 Machineries          30,000 Commission               190...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap for the year ended 31st March, 1999                                                                                                               GH¢ Opening Stocks: Raw materials                                                          785,000                             Work-In-Progress (WIP)                                        K216,000                               Finished Goods                                                     432,750 Purchases                                                                                            1,871,215 Sales                                                                                                    4,343,680 Return Outwards                                                                                52,100 Return Inwards                                                                                   18,350 Carriage Inwards                                                                                74,180 Discount Allowed                                                                               15,015 Discount Received                                                                              46,780 Plant and Machinery at cost                                                               1,850,000 Freehold Building at cost                                                                    1,610,000 Furniture and Fittings at cost                                                              318,000 Indirect Wages                                                                                   ...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap for the year ended 31st March, 1999                                                                                                               GH¢ Opening Stocks: Raw materials                                                          785,000                             Work-In-Progress (WIP)                                        K216,000                               Finished Goods                                                     432,750 Purchases                                                                                            1,871,215 Sales                                                                                                    4,343,680 Return Outwards                                                                                52,100 Return Inwards                                                                                   18,350 Carriage Inwards                                                                                74,180 Discount Allowed                                                                               15,015 Discount Received                                                                              46,780 Plant and Machinery at cost                                                               1,850,000 Freehold Building at cost                                                                    1,610,000 Furniture and Fittings at cost                                                              318,000 Indirect Wages                                                                                   ...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap for the year ended 31st March, 1999                                                                                                               GH¢ Opening Stocks: Raw materials                                                          785,000                             Work-In-Progress (WIP)                                        216,000                               Finished Goods                                                     432,750 Purchases                                                                                            1,871,215 Sales                                                                                                    4,343,680 Return Outwards                                                                                52,100 Return Inwards                                                                                   18,350 Carriage Inwards                                                                                74,180 Discount Allowed                                                                               15,015 Discount Received                                                                              46,780 Plant and Machinery at cost                                                               1,850,000 Freehold Building at cost                                                                    1,610,000 Furniture and Fittings at cost                                                              318,000 Indirect Wages                                                                                   ...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap for the year ended 31st March, 1999                                                                                                               GH¢ Opening Stocks: Raw materials                                                          785,000                             Work-In-Progress (WIP)                                        K216,000                               Finished Goods                                                     432,750 Purchases                                                                                            1,871,215 Sales                                                                                                    4,343,680 Return Outwards                                                                                52,100 Return Inwards                                                                                   18,350 Carriage Inwards                                                                                74,180 Discount Allowed                                                                               15,015 Discount Received                                                                              46,780 Plant and Machinery at cost                                                               1,850,000 Freehold Building at cost                                                                    1,610,000 Furniture and Fittings at cost                                                              318,000 Indirect Wages                                                                                   ...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap...
The following details were extracted from the books of Konongo Industries Limited a manufacturer of soap for the year ended 31st March, 1999                                                                                                               GH¢ Opening Stocks: Raw materials                                                          785,000                             Work-In-Progress (WIP)                                        K216,000                               Finished Goods                                                     432,750 Purchases                                                                                            1,871,215 Sales                                                                                                    4,343,680 Return Outwards                                                                                52,100 Return Inwards                                                                                   18,350 Carriage Inwards                                                                                74,180 Discount Allowed                                                                               15,015 Discount Received                                                                              46,780 Plant and Machinery at cost                                                               1,850,000 Freehold Building at cost                                                                    1,610,000 Furniture and Fittings at cost                                                              318,000 Indirect Wages                                                                                   ...
The following information is available from the books of Mokaya Manufacturing Company limited. Inventories on 1...
The following information is available from the books of Mokaya Manufacturing Company limited. Inventories on 1 January 2009                                                                              Shs Raw materials                                                   50,000 Work in Progress                                               76,000 Completed Product                                            84,000 Inventories on 31 December 2009 Raw materials                                                   60,000 Work in progress                                              64,000 Completed products                                          90,000 Purchases of raw materials                              560,000 Carriage inwards                                               14,000 Return of raw materials                                    26,000 Direct wages                                                   160,000 Salaries(40%factory,30% office,30%sales)        120,000 Rent (30% factory, 30% office, 40% warehouse) 80,000 Factory power                                                    30,000 Factory expenses                                               40,000 Administrative expenses                                 ...
The following information has been extracted from the books of M & M limited company, an...
The following information has been extracted from the books of M & M limited company, an entity that is listed on the Exchange market, for the year ending December 2019. CapitalComponent Contribution [$] Component       Cost(%) $2 Ordinary Shares 2 000 000 34 Retained Earnings 800 000 34 $1 Cumulative Preference Shares 1 400 000 32 Convertible       Loan Notes 800 000 25 Total Financing 5 000 000 The convertible loan notes were issued two years ago at a face value of...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT