Question

In: Economics

Governmental Taking of Private Property Certain religious organizations propose to build a private independent middle school...

Governmental Taking of Private Property

Certain religious organizations propose to build a private independent middle

school in a run-down neighborhood in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The religious

organizations asked the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Philadelphia to acquire

specific land for the project and sell it to them for a nominal price. The land included a

house on North Eighth Street owned by Mary Smith, whose daughter Veronica lived

there with her family. The Authority offered Smith $12,000 for the house and initiated a

taking of the property. Smith filed a suit in state court against the Authority, admitting

that the house was a “substandard structure in a blighted area,” but arguing that the

taking was unconstitutional because its beneficiary was private. The Authority asserted

that the taking would serve a public purpose---education.

On what basis can the

government take private property? What is the significance of Smith’s argument

(i.e., private beneficiary) and the Authority’s argument (i.e., it will serve a public

purpose)?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Introduction:-

For the economic development of a country, education serves as a broad tool which countries have used over the years, to deal with the specific problems of unemployment, low income and joblessness in the economy.

Most developing countries across the globe have spent huge amounts of money on educating their young generations and helping them in every way possible to gain knowledge which increases the productivity of the labor force within a country and helps it in achieving higher growth rates. Countries like India, China and others have rapidly been able to grow because of this basic achievement of education expenditure which causes the middle class to grow beyond their existing capacity and changes the skills of the workforce in the long run respectively.

Acquiring of Private Property:-

To be able to build more schools, colleges and other institutional bodies in a state so that the education levels can be maintained and increased, acquiring of property is widely required and undertaken by the central and state governments in the United States and beyond, so that the required infrastructure can be created. This has been debated and contested in various courts as in the current case of Smith vs the Government.

Case Specifics:-

On what basis can the government take private property?

Across all countries, acquisition laws are in place, which helps governments to acquire private property subject to compensation which are decided by state government and central government laws.

In the case above, the government has clearly stipulated that the use of this land would be for increasing the education levels within the state and thus can be used as a measure to acquire the private property in possession of Smith at the moment.

However, considering the case, Smith can indeed appeal in court because of the religious use it might be subject to and the fact that the government is choosing to sell it away at a lesser price to a private party who would then run the school. Such cases are independently considered by the court for review usually.

Question:-What is the significance of Smith’s argument (i.e., private beneficiary) and the Authority’s argument (i.e., it will serve a public purpose)?

In the case, Smiths argument is clear. The property is being resold to a different group who would thus serve as the true owner and would be running the educational institution in place of the government acquiring the peace of land. The government thus, would only in the case be serving as a middle man who would transfer the property to another private party which can be considered as unconstitutional and void.

The Authority on its part would argue in favor of increasing the education of the area and imparting knowledge to a large section of the society thus justifying the acquisition on its part respectively.

In this case, the court would look into the details of the case, but most likely would favor Smith because of the nature of the acquisition not being for end to end government interests but could potentially serve a religious purpose also in the long run since the use of the land would pass hands.

Please feel free to ask your doubts in the comments section if any.


Related Solutions

Explain the impact of school, work/career and religious organizations have on Middle Adulthood.
Explain the impact of school, work/career and religious organizations have on Middle Adulthood.
Identify at least three private or non-governmental organizations playing a role in mental health and mental...
Identify at least three private or non-governmental organizations playing a role in mental health and mental disorder issues. How do these organizations work with governemnt programs? Briefly summaraize the purpose of these organizations.
A study reported that 28 percent of middle school students in a certain state participate in...
A study reported that 28 percent of middle school students in a certain state participate in community service activities. A teacher believes that the rate is greater than 28 percent for the middle school students in the teacher’s district. The teacher selected a random sample of middle school students from the district, and the percent of students in the sample who participated in community service activities was found to be 32 percent. Which of the following is the most appropriate...
True or False: All international organizations (IOs) are formed by private citizens independent of state actors....
True or False: All international organizations (IOs) are formed by private citizens independent of state actors. International organizations are important because they increasingly affect the lives of individuals everywhere by shaping the distribution of power and making policies that were previously left to states. Neoliberal institutionalists argue that international organizations (IOs) are a means of maintaining the balance of power in the international systems and IOs benefit only a few powerful states. Robert Pape argues that individuals and organizations that...
Independent-Samples t-Test This analysis is looking at the difference in reading scores between public- and private-school...
Independent-Samples t-Test This analysis is looking at the difference in reading scores between public- and private-school students. This data comes from publicly-available data on a sample of high school students in NY. Use the output tables included below to answer the following questions: a. What is the mean & standard deviation for public school reading scores? b. What is the mean & standard deviation for private school reading scores? c. Can we assume homogeneity of variance (Hint: Look at the...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT