Question

In: Operations Management

Scenario 2 Joe and Kim Khan have worked out their differences—sort of (see Case in Chapter...

Scenario 2

Joe and Kim Khan have worked out their differences—sort of (see Case in Chapter 9). While Kim no longer takes pot shots at Joe for his lack of experience, Kim and Joe have clearly different perspectives on how to perform their jobs, serve customers, and treat employees. Jim Talent continues to encourage Joe to work with Kim to address their relationship issues. This will be particularly important because Joe and Kim will need to present a united front in an upcoming negotiation they’ll be having with representatives from Do or Dye Tools (see Case in Chapter 12).

Among the recent issues that have created concerns are the following:

1. Store policy regarding returns. The standard store policy is a 30-day “no questions asked” policy. After 30 days, store policy is generally to give store credit. Kim routinely promises customers who purchase tools full money-back guarantees, regardless of how much time has passed. Customers then refer to Kim’s representations when they come to the customer service desk that Joe manages, making claims for money back for tools returned beyond 30 days. Kim thinks that Joe and his team do not understand the need to work around company policy at times in the interest of “putting the customer first.” Joe and Kim must come to agreement on what “putting the customer first” and honoring store policy mean, and whether these two concepts are compatible or mutually exclusive.

2. Philosophical disagreement over “handshake” deals. Kim tends to make informal handshake deals with vendors. Kim did this with Do or Dye Tool’s former representative, Axel Rod, regarding the sale of its Super-Deluxe 15-90 Power-Matic Reversible Drill/Screwdriver set and accompanying package sets of drill bits and screwdriver heads (see Case in Chapter 12). This deal has angered Vic Vendor, Do or Dye’s current representative, and could result in Do or Dye severing its business relationship with More Power. Although Kim may have rational reasons for doing this, Joe believes that such actions reflect poor business practice. Before meeting with Do or Dye, Joe and Kim must agree on how they will represent More Power and the level of formality or informality that is appropriate when negotiating.

3. Treatment of employees. Kim’s actions create a “spillover” effect on Joe’s customer service desk team because they must manage the customer service issues that Kim’s actions generate. When Kim’s actions appear to run contrary to store service policy, some of Joe’s employees have attempted to address any misunderstandings with Kim directly. Kim’s response has been gruff, dismissive, and defensive. Kim makes clear that these actions will continue in the interest of serving customers without apology for the impacts on Joe’s team. Kim clearly has little tolerance for what appear to be arbitrary procedures that interfere with good customer service. Joe’s employees complain about Kim’s gruff manner and express concerns about being caught between a rock and a hard place: They will either get in trouble for running afoul of store policy by honoring Kim’s representations to customers or incur the wrath of Khan and customers by holding customers to store policy despite Kim’s representations to the contrary. Joe and Kim must come to agreement about how to work with Joe’s employees, how to avoid situations that put employees in this bind, and how to serve customers in a consistent manner.

Students will work in teams to prepare a collaborative case analysis on the Negotiations for Life case (text page 202). Each team will be assigned either Scenario 1 or Scenario 2 by the professor. Teams will discuss their assessments in their team Discussion areas and prepare an analysis and recommendation in a collaborative report in the form of a paper. See MGMT570: Guidelines for Case Analysis located in Files.

The length of paper should be three to four pages, not including the cover page and references. APA style is required for in-text citation and references.

Solutions

Expert Solution

As per narration, there is no discussion about manner in which the selected representatives for Joe and Jim or Kim should engage themselves in the integrative negotiations. They feel uncertain and unsure about the actions to be / not to be taken, so unsuccessful under the circumstances. Challenge is to adopt a unified approach for the customers as well as among the employees.

Yes, members from each of the two teams representing Joe and Jim/Kim should discuss the outcome of negotiation as compared/ to their own objectives/goals to be achieved during preparation discussions. There is nothing in the text that may be termed as "worked well". The representatives of Joe complaints against Jim/Kim.

The last paragraph in the given text has highlighted conflicts between two teams & failure on their part to resolve the issue. Therefore most of questions/issues raised have negative answers. They did not work toward achieving mutual gains.


Related Solutions

Case study: Chapter 2- The Environment- Labour Relations textbook Armand, Bob, and Courtney worked as customer...
Case study: Chapter 2- The Environment- Labour Relations textbook Armand, Bob, and Courtney worked as customer service representatives at a company that managed a toll road. Employees at the company are represented by a union. All three employees worked at the front counter, and their duties included issuing transponders, receiving payments, receiving faxes to provide service to customers, and assisting in the company’s call center when call volumes were high. In order to do their jobs, the customer service representatives...
Need to see this on worked out, thanks You are considering investing $1,000 in a complete...
Need to see this on worked out, thanks You are considering investing $1,000 in a complete portfolio. The complete portfolio is composed of Treasury bills that pay 5% and a risky portfolio, P, constructed with two risky securities, X and Y. The optimal weights of X and Y in P are 60% and 40%, respectively. X has an expected rate of return of 14%, and Y has an expected rate of return of 10%. The dollar values of your positions...
Chapter 16 REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM Case Scenario 3: You, as a School Nurse, scheduled to have a...
Chapter 16 REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM Case Scenario 3: You, as a School Nurse, scheduled to have a session on sex education to a group of higher primary school students. One of the students asks the nurse the following differences in the reproductive organs of the males and females and their function. What would be your best answers to these questions? a. What are the primary sex organs males and females and their functions?    b. What are the hormones responsible for...
Chapter 14- Digestive System    Case Scenario 1: You have just eaten a sausage, egg, with...
Chapter 14- Digestive System    Case Scenario 1: You have just eaten a sausage, egg, with the bread sandwich for breakfast. a. Explain how a piece of bread as you chew for a few minutes expect to change its taste? Why? b. Explain the chemical changes that occur in the sandwich that you eat as it passes through the parts of the GI tract with relation to the processes of the digestive system.    c. Name all enzymes or secretions...
out of the following four: 1.Bubble sort 2. Insertion sort 3. Quicksort 4. Mergesort a. Which...
out of the following four: 1.Bubble sort 2. Insertion sort 3. Quicksort 4. Mergesort a. Which sorting methods perform best and worst for data sizes ≥ 25,000 when the input data is random? b. Which sorting methods perform best and worst for data sizes ≥ 25,000 when the input data is 90% sorted? c. Which sorting methods perform best and worst for data sizes ≥ 25,000 when the input data is reverse sorted? d. Which sorting methods perform best and...
out of the following four: 1.Bubble sort 2. Insertion sort 3. Quicksort 4. Mergesort a. Which...
out of the following four: 1.Bubble sort 2. Insertion sort 3. Quicksort 4. Mergesort a. Which sorting methods perform best and worst for data sizes ≥ 25,000 when the input data is random? b. Which sorting methods perform best and worst for data sizes ≥ 25,000 when the input data is 90% sorted? c. Which sorting methods perform best and worst for data sizes ≥ 25,000 when the input data is reverse sorted? d. Which sorting methods perform best and...
Case Study, Chapter 16, End-of-Life Care 1. Joe Clark, 79 years of age, is a male...
Case Study, Chapter 16, End-of-Life Care 1. Joe Clark, 79 years of age, is a male patient who is receiving hospice care for his terminal illnesses that include lung cancer and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). He developed bilateral pleural effusion (fluid that accumulates in the pleural space of each lung), which has compromised his lung expansion. He states that he is short of breath and feels anxious that the next breath will be his last. The patient is admitted...
Chapter 11 Cardiovascular system    1. Case Scenario An athlete on completeion of 400 mts relay...
Chapter 11 Cardiovascular system    1. Case Scenario An athlete on completeion of 400 mts relay run experiences a very rapid heart beat and then after sometimes experiences normal heat beat. a.Which system is responsible for increaing the heart rate? b.Which system is responsible for decreasing is heart rate? 2. Describe how the valves keep the blood moving in one direction?    3. Why is the pressure in the pulmonary circulation lower than in the systemic circulation?    4. Watch...
Now that you have worked through the rabbit Island case, you are ready to think of...
Now that you have worked through the rabbit Island case, you are ready to think of your own experiment to find out what microbe is causing a disease out break that could occur today. What data would you want to include? How would you control your variables?
Case Study 2 ( 10 Marks) GEEPAS is an electronic company that worked hard to establish...
Case Study 2 ( 10 Marks) GEEPAS is an electronic company that worked hard to establish a place for itself in the market. It serves more 85 countries across the globe. GEEPAS produce all kind of products ranging from entertainent products to kitchen appliances and tools. Mr. Anas is working as head of the marketing department for GEEPAS electronics. Of course, competing with other electronic brands like LG, Samsung and other electronic dominated companies is not an easy task at...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT