Question

In: Mechanical Engineering

Six Sigma intended to be deployed from the Top - Down, i.e. from Corporate Level down...

Six Sigma intended to be deployed from the Top - Down, i.e. from Corporate Level down to Process Level. Share your thoughts with regards to trying to deploy the strategy from the "Bottom - Up". That is to say, use projects at the lower levels in the organization to grow a Six Sigma strategy at a company. Consider the size of the company and the willingness of the company to accept change

Solutions

Expert Solution

There is a top-down approach, where a senior manager called a Senior Champion considers a company’s major business issues and objectives and proposes a series of strategic improvement projects. A Six Sigma Champion then takes this strategic vision and identifies processes, CTQs (Critical-to-Quality Characteristics), and specific opportunities for improvement.

The bottom-up approach is where production managers make suggestions for projects on their needs to achieve budget reductions, resolve specific quality problems, or improve process flow.

Which of these two approaches do the authors favor? Not surprisingly, given the word “Strategy” in the title of their book, they recommend the top-down approach. This is because the focus should be on Six Sigma projects that offer the greatest financial and customer-satisfaction leverage. Although the authors don’t explicitly say so, I believe part of the reason for that is practical, in that you want to get the best bang for your buck, especially if you are paying for the salary of the Black Belts and their training. But I can see where another reason is political. Whenever you decide to make a sweeping change in an organization, as is required with the Six Sigma Breakthrough Strategy, you are going to get some resistance from the “old guard”. This is not a reference to chronological age, but psychological flexibility. For some, a new way of doing things gets people out of their comfort zone, which by definition is not a comfortable place to be. But let’s say you are trying to implement a Six Sigma Breakthrough Strategy as a Senior Champion, and yet face resistance from senior managers.

When your first projects are those that are designed to create the greatest financial and customer-satisfaction improvements, those first results will also be political leverage to use in senior management circles to convince those who are skeptical of the Breakthrough Strategy. It gives people who are skeptical a way to save face by saying, “well, I was skeptical, but I can’t argue with the results.” It makes it a discussion about progress and principles, and not about personalities.

And that is yet another reason why a top-down approach is best. The reason why a bottom-up approach will not work is that, although production managers may identifypossible Six Sigma projects, it is up to the Six Sigma champion to choose which of those projects most align with the vision proposed by the Senior Champion.

That’s how you get the entire company working as a team, which is the fastest way for a Six Sigma Breakthrough Strategy to be implemented.


Related Solutions

What do you understand by Six Sigma? How is it different from say, 3 sigma or...
What do you understand by Six Sigma? How is it different from say, 3 sigma or 4 sigma?
For the discussion forum please relate your experience level, if any, regarding Six Sigma. If you...
For the discussion forum please relate your experience level, if any, regarding Six Sigma. If you have not had any Six Sigma experience, present a situation at your work or in school that could benefit from a Six Sigma program.
please describe a situation from a six sigma manufacturing environment where the better use of data...
please describe a situation from a six sigma manufacturing environment where the better use of data analytics would have significantly helped?
What do you expect from a company that implement a combination Lean management and Six Sigma?
What do you expect from a company that implement a combination Lean management and Six Sigma?
A ball rolls down from the top of an incline with a height of 5 m...
A ball rolls down from the top of an incline with a height of 5 m high without slipping. The ball has a diameter of 0.2m. What are the ball’s translational speeds a) at the center of the ball, b) at the contact point on the ground, and c) at the top of the ball when it arrives at the bottom? What values of "c" do you expect for hollow/solid balls? Will the hollow ball be faster?
A uniform marble rolls down a symmetric bowl, starting from rest at the top of the...
A uniform marble rolls down a symmetric bowl, starting from rest at the top of the left side. The top of each side is a distance h above the bottom of the bowl. (a) How far up the right side of the bowl will the marble go if the interior surface of the bowl is rough so that the marble rolls without slipping? (b) How high would the marble go if the bowl's surface were frictionless? (c) For which case...
a projectile is launched from ground level to the top of a cliff which is 95...
a projectile is launched from ground level to the top of a cliff which is 95 m away and 155 m high. If the projectile lands on top of the cliff 7.6 s after it is fired, what was its initial velocity? (Be careful what you assume).
Describe how effective corporate governance seeks to ensure ethical decision making by a firm’s top-level managers....
Describe how effective corporate governance seeks to ensure ethical decision making by a firm’s top-level managers. Please write in your own words. Min 250 to max 400 words.
Discuss the different levels of strategy from corporate level to the business unit level. Discuss why...
Discuss the different levels of strategy from corporate level to the business unit level. Discuss why there is potential for disconnect from the home office to the individual organization.
Problem 1: A Six Sigma Green Belt randomly selects two parts from a box containing 5...
Problem 1: A Six Sigma Green Belt randomly selects two parts from a box containing 5 defective and 15 nondefective parts. He discards the box if one or both parts are defective. Using what you’re learned in chapter 3, what is the probability that he will select: One defective part Two defective parts Reject the box
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT