Question

In: Statistics and Probability

consider the following research situation: A group of researchers is interested in study the effects of...

consider the following research situation:

A group of researchers is interested in study the effects of caffeine on memory. They plan to use a sample of 25 adults, with the intention of generalizing the findings to the larger population. One of the researchers is concerned, however, because their sample appears to differ from the population in regards to a characteristic that he believes could hinder the generalization of the caffeine and memory study results.

This characteristic is cortisol level. A confidence interval has been constructed for the average cortisol level of the population: 10 - 15 mcg/dL. The average cortisol level for the sample is 17 mcg/dL.

The concerned researcher argues that because the sample's average cortisol level is not within the confidence interval for the population mean, that the sample is not representative of the population and should not be used for the study. The other researchers in the group argue that the difference doesn't matter, and the fact that the sample is relatively small makes it even less important.

1) Considering the research topic and purpose, and what confidence intervals represent, do you believe you should agree with the concerned researcher? Explain why or why not. Is there anything that the research team could do differently to address this potential problem?

Solutions

Expert Solution


Related Solutions

Research Designs Researchers were interested in learning the effects of trans fats on levels of cholesterol...
Research Designs Researchers were interested in learning the effects of trans fats on levels of cholesterol in the blood. Two different research designs were constructed. Part I: Between-Groups Design In the between-groups design, researchers were interested in whether cholesterol levels would differ depending on diet. Twenty participants were randomly assigned to one of two different groups. Group A was assigned a diet rich in fruits and vegetables and with no trans fats. Group B participants were asked to follow their...
A group of researchers is interested in middle school students and their willingness to appear to...
A group of researchers is interested in middle school students and their willingness to appear to stand out. A random sample of 260 middle school students is gathered, and the researchers ask them to wear bright orange shoes to school for a day. In the sample of 260 students, 192 were willing to wear the bright orange shoes. Estimate the overall proportion of middle school students that would be willing to wear bright orange shoes to school for the day....
Researchers were interested in learning the effects of trans fats on levels of cholesterol in the...
Researchers were interested in learning the effects of trans fats on levels of cholesterol in the blood. Two different research designs were constructed. Part I: Between-Groups Design In the between-groups design, researchers were interested in whether cholesterol levels would differ depending on diet. Twenty participants were randomly assigned to one of two different groups. Group A was assigned a diet rich in fruits and vegetables and with no trans fats. Group B participants were asked to follow their normal diets,...
Suppose researchers interested in the effects of adolescent exposure to mold in a household is associated...
Suppose researchers interested in the effects of adolescent exposure to mold in a household is associated with asthma. Researchers collected information about a sample of children living in homes determined to have a significant amount of potential mold exposure and determined that 154 out of the 213 children had asthma. After a sample of 428 households with not a sufficient amount of mold exposure, only 108 children were found to have asthma. A) Conduct a statistical test to determine if...
Problems 12 through 14 refer to the following research study: Researchers conducted a medical study to...
Problems 12 through 14 refer to the following research study: Researchers conducted a medical study to find out if treating a sinus infection with an antibiotic reduced the length of the sinus infection. The study included 241 patients who were diagnosed with a sinus infection. There were 113 patients randomly assigned to receive the antibiotic. The remaining patients received sugar pills. The patients were contacted regularly to find out when each patient stopped having sinus infection symptoms. The results of...
A group of researchers is interested in studying the factors that influence juvenile delinquency. They create...
A group of researchers is interested in studying the factors that influence juvenile delinquency. They create a survey for high school students in a local after-school program. The survey includes questions about age (in years), favorite sports, number of siblings, high school grade point average and the marital status of parents. List the variables in the survey and the level of measurement for each variable.
Researchers are interested in how environment and interaction effects influence intelligence. In a colony of laboratory...
Researchers are interested in how environment and interaction effects influence intelligence. In a colony of laboratory rats that are reared in an enriched environment (e.g. they have a varying number of toys, problem-solving activities, and food options) the variance in maze-solving time amongst individual rats is 5 min2. From this colony, they have also derived three inbred lines for low, medium and high intelligence. When individuals from these different inbred lines are reared together under strict uniform laboratory control conditions...
researchers were interested in the effects of cannibis and ecstacy on abstract thinking.Participants were given a...
researchers were interested in the effects of cannibis and ecstacy on abstract thinking.Participants were given a task that required them to solve problems/tasks using abstract thinking.Researchers also included a group of nonusers. Base on the scenario, identify the Idependent variable and the dependent variable. Is the IV a quasi or experimental?. what is the research question.
Consider the following studies: Study 1: A study was conducted to investigate the effects of alcohol...
Consider the following studies: Study 1: A study was conducted to investigate the effects of alcohol consumption on handeye co-ordination. 200 people were interviewed and their level of alcohol consumption over the previous five years was assessed and classified as either low, medium or high. Each person was then given a series of tasks resulting in a hand-eye co-ordination score. Study 2: A study was conducted to investigate the efficacy of a new iron tablet compared to a currently used...
5.35 Gaming and distracted eating, Part I: A group of researchers are interested in the possible...
5.35 Gaming and distracted eating, Part I: A group of researchers are interested in the possible effects of distracting stimuli during eating, such as an increase or decrease in the amount of food consumption. To test this hypothesis, they monitored food intake for a group of 44 patients who were randomized into two equal groups. The treatment group ate lunch while playing solitaire, and the control group ate lunch without any added distractions. Patients in the treatment group ate 52.1...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT