Question

In: Biology

What are the two hypotheses supporting low-carbohydrate-high-protein diets as an effective weight losing strategy?

What are the two hypotheses supporting low-carbohydrate-high-protein diets as an effective weight losing strategy?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Our body main fuel comes from carbohydrates, fat and protein in the form of calories. Glycogen is the main storage form of glucose in body muscle. Each gram of glycogen approximately requires 2 grams of water which will order to be deposited in the muscle tissue. Low carbohydrate intake actually results in the glycogen storage for the depletion of the muscle tissue.

In the absence of glycogen, the water is not at all needed and is basically excreted somehow in the urine. Therefore, the majority of early loss of the weight is due to high protein diets which are from the water loss. After returning to a balanced diet, the weight lost from water will return. This is basically because of the muscle tissue’s ability to store the glycogen and the also the associated water which is necessary for glycogen storage once carbohydrates are returned to the diet.

There are a number of popular diets that promise to be best for weight loss. Low carbohydrates diets are among some of the most common and yet highly debated. These diets can result in rapid weight loss, which for many is a definite advantage. This quick weight loss is the result of the bodies burning fat for energy instead of the typical glycogen from carbohydrates. This tends to be a short term form of weight loss that needs to be continued through further dieting in order to be keeping the initial weight off. Consuming fat and protein tends to Increase satiety being they take longer to digest compared to the quickly digested carbohydrates. This could be an advantage in a diet plan when one is trying to lose weight.

Some disadvantages of a low carbohydrate diet can be seen in the fact that the body needs carbohydrates for energy. After being on a diet that limits this energy source, one could begin to lack energy and feel lethargic, despite the amount of fat and protein that is being consumed. Additionally, higher fat foods tend to have increased levels of cholesterol, which can lead to head disease and other negative health effects. Also, when an essential food group is eliminated from the diet, the body could become depraved of certain vitamins and minerals leading to related health problems.

High protein diet: The protein content more than 30% is called as high-protein diet. The weight loss diets with high-protein Increase satiety, thermo genesis, decreases energy efficiency and maintains lean body mass. The weight loss diet should contain 20%-30% of the energy content from protein.

Most of the individuals are not harmful by high-protein diets, but consumption of protein from animals, which are rich in saturated and also cholesterol my lead to cardiovascular diseases. The high-protein diets may be risk for chronic kidney disease and the levels of proteinuria and serum creatinine should be evaluated before starting a high-protein diet.

If you are satisfied with my answer please rate it.


Related Solutions

HIGH PROTEIN/LOW CARBOHYDRATE DIET. One of the current diets that seems to produce substantial weight loss...
HIGH PROTEIN/LOW CARBOHYDRATE DIET. One of the current diets that seems to produce substantial weight loss in some persons is the high protein/low carbohydrate diet advocated by such authors as Atkins in his book, Diet Revolution, and Eades and Eades in their book, Protein Power. Although many nutritionists are concerned about the side effects of these diets, others feel the potential risks are outweighed (no pun intended) by the weight loss. The following table gives the grams of fat, carbohydrates,...
High-protein, low-carbohydrate diets like the Atkins diet are often called ketogenic diets. What might be a...
High-protein, low-carbohydrate diets like the Atkins diet are often called ketogenic diets. What might be a good reason to go on a diet like this? What might be a good reason not to go on a diet like this?
Low-fat or low-carb? Are low-fat diets or low-carb diets more effective for weight loss? A sample...
Low-fat or low-carb? Are low-fat diets or low-carb diets more effective for weight loss? A sample of 77 subjects went on a low-carbohydrate diet for six months. At the end of that time, the sample mean weight loss was 4.7 kilograms with a sample standard deviation of 7.16 kilograms. A second sample of 79 subjects went on a low-fat diet. Their sample mean weight loss was 2.6 kilograms with a standard deviation of 5.90 kilograms. Can you conclude that the...
Are low-fat diets or low-carb diets more effective for weight loss? A sample of 70 subjects...
Are low-fat diets or low-carb diets more effective for weight loss? A sample of 70 subjects went on a low-carb At the end of that time, the sample mean weight loss was 10.5 pounds with a sample standard deviation of 7.09 pounds. A second sample of 76 went on a low-fat diet. Their sample mean weight loss was 18.0 with a standard deviation of 7.26. Can you conclude that their was no difference in the mean weight loss between the...
Are low-fat diets or low-carb diets more effective for weight loss? A simple random sample of...
Are low-fat diets or low-carb diets more effective for weight loss? A simple random sample of 85 adults went on a low-carbohydrate diet for 6 months. At the end of that time, the average weight loss was 4.8 kilograms with a standard deviation 6.04 kilograms. A second simple random sample of 77 adults went on a low-fat diet. Their average weightloss was 4 kilograms with a standard deviation of 5.08 kilograms. Can you conclude that the true mean weightloss differs...
Low-fat or low-carb? Are low-fat diets more effective for weight loss? A sample of 58 subjects...
Low-fat or low-carb? Are low-fat diets more effective for weight loss? A sample of 58 subjects went on a low-carbohydrate diet for six months. At the end of that time, the sample mean weight loss was 3.2 kilograms with a sample standard deviation of 5.42 kilograms. A second sample of 60 subjects went on a low-fat diet. Their sample mean weight loss was 2.4 kilograms with a standard deviation of 4.48 kilograms. Can you conclude that the mean weight loss...
Choose one of the three special diets: -low sodium -low sugar/low carbohydrate -low calcium 1. Develop...
Choose one of the three special diets: -low sodium -low sugar/low carbohydrate -low calcium 1. Develop an organized meal plan for ONE DAY for an individual following the special diet. 2. In complete sentences, explain what disease might require the individual to follow the particular diet.
A doctor wishes to determine which of two diets is more effective in reducing weight. A...
A doctor wishes to determine which of two diets is more effective in reducing weight. A sample of 20 obese adults who are interested in losing weight is randomly divided into groups of 10. After 6 weeks the weight loss of each participant was recorded. The mean for diet 1 is 8 pounds with a standard deviation of 3.23 pounds. The mean for diet 2 is 11 pounds with a standard deviation of 6.78 pounds. Does the data justify the...
Thoroughly discuss the current trend toward very low carbohydrate diets. Evaluate the safety and effectiveness of...
Thoroughly discuss the current trend toward very low carbohydrate diets. Evaluate the safety and effectiveness of severely decreasing carbohydrate intake for weight management or other reasons. State your thoughts and reasons, citing evidence supporting your position.
Many fad diets claim we should eliminate dietary carbohydrate in order to lose weight. The truth...
Many fad diets claim we should eliminate dietary carbohydrate in order to lose weight. The truth is that calories from all sources need to be managed for weight control. For this discussion, read the following article in full: Magee, Elaine, MPH, RD: Good Carbs, Bad Carbs: Why do Carbohydrates Matter To You? OR copy and paste this link into your browser: http://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/features/carbohydrates#2 Answer the following questions in your own words, based on what you learned from the article and the...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT