Question

Write a 6-8 page, research-driven essay addressing one of the prompts listed below.

3) Stevenson believes that a system of justice without mercy is ultimately unjust. Consider to what extent you agree and/or disagree with this statement. What place does mercy have in a justice system? Thoroughly explain your answer and your reasoning, using evidence from Just Mercy and from your research to prove your argument. *Note: to adequately respond to this question, you should consider your personal definitions “of justice” and “mercy” – these terms can be interpreted differently by different people!

The focus should be that I dont think mercy should be given when a person deserves a severe punishment when they have done a crime that deserves it. I do believe that the system should be more balanced, fair, efficient and impartial.

BOOK: JUST MERCY BY BRYAN STEVENSON

Answer 1

Justice and Mercy are two different aspects. These can not exist together. If they are staying in vicinity of each other then it means that system is not working in a proper manner. Something is getting wrong. In such case, a person may become victim while other may be in extreme favour.

This is completely wrong and immoral too. There is a saying also that we should hate crime but not the person. When we are in position of judging some incident then we must be impartial. We must consider the impact of decision on both the parties involved.

Suppose a person is there and he has murdered a person. Murderer is having a family with three kids. If we visualise the family conditions then we may become merciful. This feeling may affect our decision making ability.

It is important to ignore the unusual facts. We should consider the crime. One good judgement may send a moral signal to whole society. It may also prove to be helpful in avoiding any future anarchy. Wrong judgement not only affect the victim's family but its also spreads anarchy in society.

This depressing condition is not good for building a healthy society. Such conditions must be prevented. Morality, impartiality and transparency; are important aspects of a good judgement.