Question

In: Mechanical Engineering

Engineer Doe is employed on a full-time basis by a radio broadcast equipment manufacturer as a...

Engineer Doe is employed on a full-time basis by a radio broadcast equipment manufacturer as a sales representative. In addition, Doe performs consulting engineering services to organizations in the radio broadcast field, including analysis of their technical problems and, when required, recommendation of certain radio broadcast equipment as may be needed. Doe’s engineering reports to his clients are prepared in form for filing with the appropriate governmental body having jurisdiction over radio broadcast facilities. In some cases Doe’s engineering reports recommend the use of broadcast equipment manufactured by his employer.

Can Doe ethically provide consulting services as described?

What NSPE Code of Ethics references might apply to this case?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Facts:

Engineer Doe is employed on a full-time basis by a radio broadcast equipment manufacturer as a sales representative. In addition, Doe performs consulting engineering services to organizations in the radio broadcast field, including analysis of their technical problems and, when required, recommendation of certain radio broadcast equipment as may be needed. Doe's engineering reports to his clients are prepared in form for filing with the appropriate governmental body having jurisdiction over radio broadcast facilities. In some cases Doe's engineering reports recommend the use of broadcast equipment manufactured by his employer.

Question:

May Doe ethically provide consulting services as described?

References:

  • Code 8
  • "The Engineer will endeavor to avoid a conflict of interest with his employer or client, but when unavoidable, the Engineer shall fully disclose the circumstances to his employer or client."
  • Code 8(a)
  • "The Engineer will inform his client or employer of any business connections, interests, or circumstances which may be deemed as influencing his judgment or the quality of his services to his client or employer."
  • Code 12(c)
  • "An Engineer in sales or industrial employ is entitled to make engineering comparisons of his products with products by other suppliers."

Discussion:

As we previously noted in Case 72-9, and reaffirmed in Case 74-4, a primary duty under Code 8is "to prevent the conflict of interest from arising." We also recognized in those cases, as we do now, that it is not always possible to avoid a conflict of interest and the decision on whether it is avoidable is "a subjective judgment...." In Case 74-4 the controlling factor was the time the conflict became apparent .

The word "avoid" in Code 8 is not an absolute bar in all cases in which there may be an active or apparent conflict of interest if all parties in interest are aware of all pertinent facts and relationships. As we said in Case 72-9, "To become involved in a conflict of interest is not unethical, per se, as the code clearly indicates. However, it may be unethical depending on the circumstances."

The controlling element in this case is the extent to which Doe's recommendations for equipment manufactured by his employer are justified by the best interests of his client. It would be too easy to merely conclude that Doe may not recommend the equipment manufactured by his employer in all circumstances. If he truly believed and documented that such equipment was in the best interest of his client he would be ethically and duty bound to so advise.

However, the facts do not tell us whether Doe advises his client in each case of his connection with the manufacturer of the equipment in order that the client may then determine if Doe's recommendation is influenced by his relationship with the manufacturer. It is clear that Code 8 requires disclosure of that relationship to both his employer and his client. Code 8(a) reinforces this duty in its reference to disclosure of any business connections, interests or circumstances which may influence the judgment of the engineer. Such disclosure must be made at the earliest time that a conflict of interest becomes apparent and it is desirable that the disclosure be in writing.

We assume the governmental body is interested primarily in the technical adequacy of the proposed equipment without regard to the source of supply; consequently, we perceive no requirement in the code to impose an obligation on Doe to inform the governmental body of his relationship with the manufacturer of the equipment.

It should be further noted that Code 12(c) provides the further basis for Doe's conduct by its authorization for him to make engineering comparisons of the products he sells with the products of other suppliers. It is not indicated if Doe's reports do provide such equipment comparisons, but we believe that in appropriate circumstances where the equipment in question may be available from more than one source, his reports should indicate the alternative sources and a technical evaluation of the several products as factually as possible. The client will then be in as fair a position as possible to evaluate the merits of the competing products.

It would be preferable, of course, if the client could rely upon the technical judgment and recommendations of an engineer without any financial interests in the equipment of any manufacturer, but we realize that under some circumstances the client may wish to retain the services of an engineer with an apparent conflict of interest. In the latter instance the client must have full knowledge of all the circumstances; otherwise the client has been defrauded.

Conclusion:

Doe may ethically provide consulting services as described only if there is full disclosure of all the facts and circumstances to his client.


Related Solutions

The data contained in <professional> are the number of males employed full time in a professional...
The data contained in <professional> are the number of males employed full time in a professional occupation in Australia from August quarter 1996 to August quarter 2008. Time period Male full-time employed professionals ('000) Aug-96 645.6 Nov-96 675 Feb-97 661.2 May-97 659.9 Aug-97 675.2 Nov-97 700.5 Feb-98 710.7 May-98 697.8 Aug-98 711.1 Nov-98 733.6 Feb-99 751 May-99 730.4 Aug-99 704.2 Nov-99 725.7 Feb-00 735.2 May-00 743.7 Aug-00 742.7 Nov-00 746.4 Feb-01 762.7 May-01 760.5 Aug-01 765.8 Nov-01 752.7 Feb-02 759.6...
Phil is a self employed plumber and his wife, Lauren, is a full-time employee for the...
Phil is a self employed plumber and his wife, Lauren, is a full-time employee for the University. Lauren has health insurance from a qualified plan provided by the University, but Phil has chosen to purchase his own health insurance rather than participate in Lauren's plan. Besides paying $5,400 for his health insurance premiums, Phil also pays the following expenses associated with his plumbing business: Plumbing tools and supplies $1,300 Rent on Phil's plumbing shop 6,250 Transportation between Phil's shop and...
1. Scott is a self-employed plumber and his wife, Emily, is a full-time employee for a...
1. Scott is a self-employed plumber and his wife, Emily, is a full-time employee for a University. Emily has health insurance from a qualified plan provided by the University, but Scott has chosen to purchase his own health insurance rather than participate in Emily's plan. Besides paying $5,590 for his health insurance premiums, Scott also pays the following expenses associated with his plumbing business: Plumbing tools and supplies       $1,490​ Rent on Scott's plumbing shop   6,440​ Transportation between Scott's shop and various...
Simpson, age 45, is a single individual who is employed full time by Duff Corporation. This...
Simpson, age 45, is a single individual who is employed full time by Duff Corporation. This year Simpson reports AGI of $40,000 and has incurred the following medical expenses: Dentist charges $ 1,315 Physician's charges 2,015 Optical charges 745 Cost of eyeglasses 450 Hospital charges 2,290 Prescription drugs 220 Over-the-counter drugs 795 Medical insurance premiums (not through an exchange) 860 a. Calculate the amount of medical expenses that will be included with Simpson’s itemized deductions after any applicable limitations. b....
Montreal Ltd. is a manufacturer of custom equipment and applies overhead to jobs on the basis...
Montreal Ltd. is a manufacturer of custom equipment and applies overhead to jobs on the basis of direct Required: labour hours. Montreal Ltd. estimated $840,000 overhead costs and 10,000 direct labour hours for the year. c. Calculate the work in process inventory on January 31, 2015: Montreal Ltd. had 2 jobs in work in process inventory on January 1, 2015. The company started 2 more jobs during January. The following data was provided for January: d. Calculate the finished goods...
destiny is a self employed cosmetic sales person and her husband, larry works full time as...
destiny is a self employed cosmetic sales person and her husband, larry works full time as a truck driver for a trucking company. destiny paid 600 for cosmetic supplies and larry paid 3725 cor property taxes on their home in el paso. which of the following is a true statement? A. the supplies are deductible for AGI while the property taxes are an itemized deduction B. Both expenditures are itemezied deductions C. the supplies are an itemized deduction but the...
Simpson, age 45, is a single individual who is employed full-time by Duff Corporation. This year...
Simpson, age 45, is a single individual who is employed full-time by Duff Corporation. This year Simpson reports AGI of $69,600 and has incurred the following medical expenses: Dentist charges $ 1,430 Physician charges 2,220 Optical charges 560 Cost of eyeglasses 670 Hospital charges 3,300 Prescription drugs 695 Over-the-counter drugs 800 Medical insurance premiums (not through an exchange) 945 a. Calculate the amount of medical expenses that will be included with Simpson's itemized deductions after any applicable limitations. b. Suppose...
9.55 The U.S. Department of Education reports that 40% of full-time college students are employed while...
9.55 The U.S. Department of Education reports that 40% of full-time college students are employed while attending college. (Data extracted from The Condition of Education 2012,ncesed.gov/pubs2012/2012045.pdf.) A recent survey of 60 full-time students at a university found that 25 were employed. A) Use the five-step p-value approach to hypothesis testing and a 0.05 level of significance to determine whether the proportion of full-time students at the university is different from the national norm of 0.4 B) Assume that the study...
Melanie is employed full-time as an accountant for a national hardware chain. She also has recently...
Melanie is employed full-time as an accountant for a national hardware chain. She also has recently started a private consulting practice, which provides tax advice and financial planning to the general public. For this purpose, she maintains an office in her home. Expenses relating to her home for 2017 are as follows: Real property taxes $6,000 Interest on home mortgage 7,200 Operating expenses of home 1,500 Melanie's residence cost $364,000 (excluding land) and has living space of 2,000 square feet,...
A report claims that 46​% of​ full-time college students are employed while attending college. A recent...
A report claims that 46​% of​ full-time college students are employed while attending college. A recent survey of 60 ​full-time students at a state university found that 28 were employed. Use the​ five-step p-value approach to hypothesis testing and a 0.05 level of significance to determine whether the proportion of​ full-time students at this state university is different from the national norm of 0.46. find the t statistic find the p value find the critical value
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT