There are various investment decision rules, which financial managers may select. Choose one of the alternatives...

There are various investment decision rules, which financial managers may select. Choose one of the alternatives to the NPV, and compare and contrast one of the selected alternatives with NPV (payback period, discounted payback period, IRR or profitability index.

Expert Solution

NPV:

Present value of cashoutflow-Present value of cashinflows ------discounted at suitable discount rate

Payback period:

Payback period is used for calculating the amount of time it is required to get back the initial invested amount. ie: it calculate the time period by which a project reaches its break even point. Shorter payback period is more attractive and longer payback period means projects are a red flag.

Payback period= (p - n)÷p + nx

where p=cashflow at which first cumulative value occurs ; n=cumulative cashflow at last negative value of cumulative cashflow occurs ; nx=no of years in which last negative value of cumulative cashflow occurs.

eg:

Years	0	1	2	3	4
Investment	-100000
Cashflows		20000	50000	30000	10000

From the table the payback period= 3 years ; ie in 3 years the initial investment of 100000 will be recovered by the project.

Comparison:

Comparing to npv which is the net present value which is the difference between present value of cash inflows and present value of cash outflows;

The payback period method doesnt consider the time value of the cashinflows. unlike npv
The payback method fails to consider cash inflows after the payback year. ie; as in the example the value of the cashflow in year 4(10000) is not accounted for in payback period. Whereas npv rule consider all the possible cashflows.
One of the similarity between both the method is npv and payback period assess a project in terms of financial terms which ignores the future potential to its investment .

jeff jeffy answered 1 year ago

a) Saha have two investment alternatives from which he need to choose one. If the current...

a) Saha have two investment alternatives from which he need to choose one. If the current market interest rate is 8%, which alternative would saha choose and why? Alternative 1: Receive $ 280 semi-annually for the next 12 years Alternative 2: Receive $ 12000 lumpsum at the end of 12 years b) During the four years of saha's University life, saha have received the following amounts of money at the end of each year for outstanding performance from the university...

Which of the following statements is true? Managers may choose to retain an unprofitable product line...

Which of the following statements is true? Managers may choose to retain an unprofitable product line if the line helps sell other products. A danger in allocating traceable fixed costs is that such allocations can make a product line look less profitable than it really is. Product lines that do not cover all costs, including common fixed costs, should be dropped. Allocating common fixed costs among product lines is necessary to determine which product lines are profitable. 3 points ...

Which of the following is not an advantage of incorporation? Select one: a. There may be...

Which of the following is not an advantage of incorporation? Select one: a. There may be tax advantages b. Shareholders can veto decisions of directors. c. Shareholders owe no duty to the corporation. d. Shares are easily transferred. e. Shareholders are not liable for debts of the corporation. Which of the following is false with respect to methods of carrying on a business? Select one: a. A ‘society’ must be for a non-profit purpose. b. Unlimited liability means that an...

Your supervisor is on the company’s capital investment decision team that is to decide on alternatives...

Your supervisor is on the company’s capital investment decision team that is to decide on alternatives for the acquisition of a new computer system for the company. The supervisor says, “The book value of the existing computer system for the firm that we are considering replacing is nothing but an accounting amount and as such is irrelevant in the capital expenditure analysis.” Does this reasoning make sense? Why or why not?

. Describe, with examples, each of the various decision rules under uncertainty that we studied in...

. Describe, with examples, each of the various decision rules under uncertainty that we studied in class (e.g. maximin, leximin, etc). Why do some of these rules require utility to be cardinal? Which rule would you follow in making your own decisions and why?. Describe, with examples, each of the various decision rules under uncertainty that we studied in class (e.g. maximin, leximin, etc). Why do some of these rules require utility to be cardinal? Which rule would you follow...

When NPV and IRR rules result in a conflicting decision regarding acceptance of a project managers...

When NPV and IRR rules result in a conflicting decision regarding acceptance of a project managers could use the MIRR. It assumes reinvestment of projects' cash flows at the WACC, so it produces results consistent with NPV method. Let's try to find the MIRR for the project with the following cash flows: Initial cost of -800 at time zero, CF1 = 400, CF 2 = 570, CF3 = -130. Here we have two negative cash flows and two positive cash...

Which of the following statements best describes alternatives to short-term financing policies? Select one: a. A...

Which of the following statements best describes alternatives to short-term financing policies? Select one: a. A firm following an aggressive financing policy would finance all its permanent NOWC with long-term capital. b. If a company receives trade credit under terms 2/10, net 30, this implies the company has 10 days of free trade credit. c. A conservative financing policy is one in which the firm finances all of its fixed assets with long-term capital and part of its permanent net...

Which two of the following five statements are correct? Select two alternatives: One potential problem with...

Which two of the following five statements are correct? Select two alternatives: One potential problem with the IRR rule is that one can find several IRRs or that no IRR can be found for a specific stream of cash flows. The payback rule is reliable because it considers the time value of money and depends on the cost of capital. For the IRR rule it is possible that there exists no discount rate that will set the NPV equal to...

Which ONE of the following is NOT a financial management decision? Maintaining a satisfactory financial situation....

Which ONE of the following is NOT a financial management decision? Maintaining a satisfactory financial situation. Setting the organizational purpose. Sources of financial resources Uses of financial resources.

select any topic related to financial accounting that interests you. You may also choose a topic...

select any topic related to financial accounting that interests you. You may also choose a topic you are familiar with professionally or one that is intereresting to you . Examples include partnerships vs. corporations, accounting for inventory valuation, types of legal business entities, accounting for accounts receivable and uncollectible accounts, fair value accounting, IFRS, Sarbanes Oxley, ethics in accounting, the history and purpose of the cash flow statement, accounting for long-term liabiliites, comparative evaluation of different depreciation methods, are just...

Question