Question

In: Economics

When is war justified? And what may justifiably be done during the conduct of a war?

When is war justified? And what may justifiably be done during the conduct of a war?

Solutions

Expert Solution

A war wins only if it's waged for a legitimate cause, and that carries enough moral weight. The nation that wants to use military force must prove that there is a just cause to do so. The main reason is to correct a mistake. A battle waged to keep a wrong from occurring can also be called a just battle. In modern times battles to protect the innocent are generally considered just (which corresponds with the belief in some religious literature that defending an innocent is better than defending oneself).

Self-defence against an aggressor is the clearest example of a just cause. For instance, when an enemy has crossed your frontiers and invaded your country. So it doesn't take an actual invasion. The cases of self-defence below are not clearly just causes of war-whether or not they are depends on how serious a particular case is:
Prominent individual murder:-monarch or president
Attack on national honour: (e.g., flag burning, embassy attack)
Attack on State Religion
Financial assault:(Embargo or sanctions)
Assault on a friend or ally

Assisting a friendly nation, invaded.
Violations of human rights: Another common example is to remedy so serious a violation of human rights that force is the only sensible solution.
Punishing an act of aggression: Not everyone accepts this. Many people would say a punitive war will never be a fair war.


Related Solutions

Can war ever be justified? If so, under what conditions and with what restrictions? Compare the...
Can war ever be justified? If so, under what conditions and with what restrictions? Compare the views of Natural Law Theory, Utilitarianism, and Divine Command Theory. (400- 500 words)
Was the reaction of the Chinese Government justified compared to the reasons given for the War...
Was the reaction of the Chinese Government justified compared to the reasons given for the War against Drugs in the US. You must clearly identify the proximate events that led to the declaration of War on Drugs and which year.
What factors during the war of fighting for double victory in the workd war ll Era...
What factors during the war of fighting for double victory in the workd war ll Era promoted black solidarity? How did this bring about the sense of blacks becoming a nation within a nation? world war ll era olease answer in full details
When is a financing via budget deficits are justified?
When is a financing via budget deficits are justified?
During the Eisenhower presidency, the Interstate Highway Act was justified as a military defensive measure. What...
During the Eisenhower presidency, the Interstate Highway Act was justified as a military defensive measure. What were the long-term ramifications of this Act (think of the environment, the economy, transportation, demographics)? Was this a good or bad law? Discuss and defend
How justified is Agamemnon in his actions? How justified is Achilles in his rage? What does...
How justified is Agamemnon in his actions? How justified is Achilles in his rage? What does the exchange between Achilles and Agamemnon tell us about the nature of honor and respect in the ancient world?
When Bangladesh gained independence from Pakistan in 1971 after a brutal civil war that may have...
When Bangladesh gained independence from Pakistan in 1971 after a brutal civil war that may have left as many as 3 million dead, the U.S. National Security Adviser, Henry Kissinger, referred to the country as a “basket case.” Kissinger’s assessment was accurate enough. At the time, Bangladesh was one of the world’s poorest nations. Although most of the country is dominated by the fertile Ganges-Brahmaputra delta, a lack of other natural resources, coupled with poor infrastructure, political instability, and high...
How pervasive are ethical problems in corporate America? What can be done to enhance ethical conduct...
How pervasive are ethical problems in corporate America? What can be done to enhance ethical conduct at the executive level? Keep in mind the reporting structure of corporations and business today!
Define external whistle-blowing. What are three reasons when external whistle-blowing can be justified?
Define external whistle-blowing. What are three reasons when external whistle-blowing can be justified?
The just-war theory considers a war acceptable when it satisfies several stringent criteria: The war must...
The just-war theory considers a war acceptable when it satisfies several stringent criteria: The war must be fought for a just cause, the motives must be good, it must follow a call from a legitimate authority, and the use of force must be based on necessity (as a last resort). Central to notions of a just war are the principles of noncombatant immunity and proportionality. Noncombatants are those who will not be actively participating in combat and therefore do not...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT