Before Starting
- Review the APA citation and research strategies information in
our textbook.
Objectives
- apply academic research strategies
- critically evaluate sources for trustworthiness and
suitability
- apply APA project formatting
- gather a wide collection of potential resources to choose the
best from for the Persuasive Essay
Directions
Building from weekly work tasks in weeks 2 & 3, you will
create a formal Annotated Bibliography document to submit here. The
goal is to gather and critically evaluate a pool of potential
resources to use in your Persuasive Essay.
That essay will require you to use at least 3 sources in the
final draft. Here, you will be gathering twice that many to
evaluate, in order to pick the best ones to include in the paper
itself later on.
This Annotated Bibliography will include
- at least 6 sources, total
- of these sources, at least 4 must be academic, scholarly
sources.
- the other 2 are up to you, but might include primary sources
from your workplace (including personal interviews you conduct with
a coworker or manager), online videos, or non-academic web content
relevant to your persuasive essay topic
- APA citation formatting for the sources. Sources should be
listed in alphabetical order, by the first word of the citation
entry.
- Each source citation will be immediately followed by a
paragraph that briefly summarizes the source, and
critically evaluates it for your persuasive essay
needs. Apply the appropriate CRAAP test standards, from the
textbook, for each critical evaluation paragraph. (Not all the
CRAAP components will be necessary for each source–pick the ones
that are most relevant to reaching your conclusion about whether
it’s a reliable, useful source or not each time.)
- APA document formatting, including a separate title page. This
project will not include an essay or an abstract, however. Just the
title page and the References page
Grading Rubric
Annotated Bibliography Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts Citations Citations exactly follow APA
guidelines for bibliographic entries. They will need few to no
changes in order to be ready for use in the persuasive essay. 40.0
pts Citations closely follow APA guidelines. They will need some
changes before they are ready for the persuasive essay. 36.0 pts
Citations follow APA guidelines, but are missing key elements
and/or have elements out of order. They will need editing before
they are ready for the persuasive essay. 32.0 pts Citations do not
follow APA guidelines at all, though they do have some sense of
formatting. They will need to be heavily edited before they are
ready for the persuasive essay. 20.0 pts Citations are incomplete
or entirely missing. 0.0 pts 40.0 pts
Annotation Contents
|
Paragraphs following citations are richly detailed, giving a
clear summary of the source along with brief but thorough
explanations regarding the source’s trustworthiness and usefulness
to your research goals. Expertly edited and proofread content.
40.0 pts
|
Paragraphs following citations are detailed, giving a summary of
the source along with some explanations regarding the source’s
trustworthiness and usefulness to your research goals. Edited and
proofread content, perhaps with some minor errors.
36.0 pts
|
Paragraphs following citations are detailed but may be missing
one of the following: summary/ validity/ usefulness. Edited
content, though containing multiple errors.
32.0 pts
|
Paragraphs following citations are detailed but may be missing
one of the following: summary/ trustworthiness/ usefulness. Edited
content, though containing multiple errors.
20.0 pts
|
Paragraphs are extremely short or nonexistent.
0.0 pts
|
|
40.0 pts
|
Required Number & Kinds of Sources
|
Bibliography contains at least 6 sources; of these at least 4
are academic, scholarly sources from the TCC library academic
databases or the BoK.
10.0 pts
|
Bibliography contains at least 6 sources; of these at least 2
are academic, scholarly sources from the TCC library academic
databases or the BoK.
9.0 pts
|
Bibliography contains at least 6 sources, but none may be
academic, scholarly sources from the TCC library nor the BoK.
7.0 pts
|
Bibliography contains fewer than 5 sources.
5.0 pts
|
Bibliography contains fewer than 3 sources.
0.0 pts
|
|
10.0 pts
|
Formatting
|
Document is formatted exactly by APA guidelines. Citations are
alphabetized and use hanging indent. Includes APA title page.
10.0 pts
|
Document is formatted by APA guidelines, perhaps with one or two
minor errors. Citations are alphabetized and use hanging indent.
Includes APA title page.
9.0 pts
|
Document is formatted by APA guidelines, though with errors.
Citations may not be alphabetized, and/or do use hanging indent.
Includes APA title page but may be missing significant
information.
7.0 pts
|
Document is not formatted using APA guidelines. Citations are
not alphabetized, and do use hanging indent. May be missing APA
title page.
5.0 pts
|
No specific page formatting is used at all.
0.0 pts
|
|
10.0 pts
|