Question

In: Operations Management

You are being consulted as a young forensic investigator. Here are the facts: Your client, Mr....

You are being consulted as a young forensic investigator. Here are the facts:

Your client, Mr. Clean, comes to you with the following true story.

  • Mr. Clean owned with a partner, Mr. Dirty, a coin-operated laundry. Mr. Dirty recently passed away and his family discovered over $1,000,000 worth of coins in Mr.Dirty's two-bedroom apartment. Mr. Clean is astounded to hear this and immediately goes back to the business to check some business statistics that he heretofore never bothered checking and discovered that indeed for the past 20 years of their partnership a material amount of income was missing each week.
  • Mr. Clean assumes that Mr. Dirty's $1.0 million plus of coins and the statistics of missing money at the business is no coincidence...Mr. Dirty's coins were stolen from the business by Mr. Dirty.
  • The problem - how to prove this to be the truth? How to prove that Mr. Dirty did it? In order for Mr. Clean to have a claim on his insurance policy and on Mr. Dirty's estate, some amount of proof is needed.

Try to propose answers to the following questions:

  1. What sort of statistics at the business did Mr. Clean look at to see that money was missing every week?
  2. What steps could you undertake to prove that Mr. Dirty stole the money? In other words, what types of evidence could you develop that points the finger at Mr. Dirty in a way that would convince most people that Mr. Dirty did steal the money from the business.  REMEMBER: CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE IS OFTEN HOW FRAUD IS PROVEN.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The biggest argument here is that Mr. Dirty had $1.0 Million in coins in his two bedroom apartment. This is huge money to have in coins, and a person can only have such amount of money in coins if he is working at a place where coins is the only mode of payment.

This is justifiable as Mr. Dirty and Mr. Clean were running a coin-operated laundry. So if the Ledger books and financial statements for the laundry show $1.0 Million money unaccountable or unequal split, there is a possibility that Mr.Dirty took the laundry's money in an illegitimate manner.

Also if the account books don't show a discrepancy, then Mr. Clean would have to track the money generated by laundry through the machines, as every individual machine has its own status of how many times each machine has been run. If the machine records and the money on papers do not match than also it could turn in favour of Mr. Clean.

Thus, this circumstantial evidence would be enough to keep things in favour of Mr.Clean.


Related Solutions

Determine whether or not you believe the forensic processes taken by an investigator on a Macintosh...
Determine whether or not you believe the forensic processes taken by an investigator on a Macintosh system is different from that on a Windows or Linux system. Determine which type of system you would prefer to utilize if you were leading an investigation. Additionally, decide whether or not the specifics of the investigation would have a determination on your choice and why or why not.
you are a Digital Forensic investigator who has been hired by the attorney for the convicted...
you are a Digital Forensic investigator who has been hired by the attorney for the convicted party. The attorney tells you that the case is under appeal based on the argument that the 'con artist' was coerced to confess. The attorney also gives you a cellphone belonging to his party and asks you to run a thorough examination of the mobile device to extract any data that may be important to this case. Detail the steps you would take in...
Being a personal finance counselor, Your very first client is a young couple who want to...
Being a personal finance counselor, Your very first client is a young couple who want to put their financial business in order and develop a plan for their retirement and future family needs. Both the husband and the wife are 31 years old and in stable employment. They want to retire together at the age of 67. They want you to help them in their financial planning by answering a series of questions, as follows: Why is the fundamental reason...
You are a CPA being paid to prepare a tax return for a client. Your client...
You are a CPA being paid to prepare a tax return for a client. Your client has a maid that cleans their house twice a week, and is paid about $3,000 per year. You notice your client has not been reporting, withholding, or paying any taxes on the wages of this household employee. When you bring this issue up to your client, they are quick to reply that the maid is a part-time employee and not subject to the “nanny...
You have been assigned to care for Mr. Alvarez, a 74-year-old client being treated for a...
You have been assigned to care for Mr. Alvarez, a 74-year-old client being treated for a urinary tract infection. He suffered a cerebrovascular accident (stroke) 6 months ago and has had difficulty ambulating and attending to his own needs because of right-sided weakness. He is thin for height, incontinent of foul smelling urine, and has non-blanchable erythema on his coccyx and peritoneal area. He is alert and oriented to person, place, and time. He has decreased sensation on his entire...
   Question 3 Mr A Mathews, a client of your firm, has provided you with the...
   Question 3 Mr A Mathews, a client of your firm, has provided you with the following bank statement and bank account details in respect of the month ended 31 December 2016. STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT - YOUR BANK LTD Statement date - 31 December 2016. Account No 123456 Date              Particulars           Debit     Credit    Balance 01-Dec-16 Balance forward 61,526 Cr 01-Dec-16 Cheque 1233 5,000 56,526 Cr 01-Dec-16 Lodgement 6,000 62,526 Cr 03-Dec-16 Cheque 1234 6,600 55,926 Cr 05-Dec-16...
At your job as a genetic counselor, your client is a distraught young woman. She explains...
At your job as a genetic counselor, your client is a distraught young woman. She explains to you that her mother has blood type A, her father has blood type AB, and she has blood type O. She has been told that this is not genetically possible. Your initial suspicion in this case is that there was infidelity (i.e. her father is not really her father), but the young woman refuses to accept this explanation. For her sake, you agree...
You are asked to write a memo to your client, Mr. Carter regarding his tax question....
You are asked to write a memo to your client, Mr. Carter regarding his tax question. ● Your paper should not be more than 2-3 pages, double spaced ● The format should be as follows: ○ Restate the issue / question (first paragraph) ○ Explain the facts in relation to your research (middle paragraphs) ■ Cite a primary or authoritative material at least once ■ Refer the the tax form the information would be reported on ■ Include calculations and...
Forensic Accounting Question you have been retained to assist a client with the following situation. the...
Forensic Accounting Question you have been retained to assist a client with the following situation. the client believes that there is something wrong and he wants you to evaluate his business and its exposure to theft and fraud. in less than 250 words, describe 10 things you would do to respond to the client's concerns
Here are some SALT-related facts regarding your 2019 tax year: You paid $9,000 in state income...
Here are some SALT-related facts regarding your 2019 tax year: You paid $9,000 in state income taxes by way of payroll withholding by your employer. Now (in 2020) that you’ve just filed your 2019 state return it turns out that you owed only $7,500; you’ll get a refund soon. The IRS sales tax deduction table [see textbook Exhibit 8-3] says that your 2019 deduction for sales taxes is $4,000. However, you saved every re-ceipt for everything you bought during 2019...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT