You have been recently assigned as the manager for the audit of Layton Co, a software...

You have been recently assigned as the manager for the audit of Layton Co, a software engineering company whose securities are publicly traded. You are filling in for your colleague, Luke Paolo, who has taken a sick leave at short notice.

The company's audit for the financial year ended 30 June 20Y0 is nearing completion and its draft financial statements recognize a profit before tax of $65.4 million and total assets of $27.9 million.

You are in the midst of reviewing the audit working papers and have come across the following comments from the audit senior, a part-qualified accountant:

It is a relief to have you on the team. I was starting to get anxious that our working papers would not have been reviewed in time for the clearance meeting with Layton Co's management next week. The audit junior and I have tried our level best to complete all of the procedures outlined in the audit programme but it was difficult to do so considering that Luke had already taken ill at the commencement of the audit and there was no one supervise our work. The only guidance provided by Luke during a short briefing meeting with him was to 'refer to the prior year's audit file' should we have doubts on how to proceed with the audit.

There is an issue that I wanted to run by you. During the year, Layton Co introduced a share-based payment scheme in which it granted its senior executives share appreciation rights (SARs). This area was not highlighted as being high risk during the audit planning meeting. The SARs were granted at the beginning of the financial year and their fair value as at that date was determined by an independent valuation firm. A copy of the valuation report is on file and judging by a quick search I did online, I can safely say that they are competent in doing their job as their website seems to be professionally designed.

The fair value of the SARS at the grant date was amortized over a five-year vesting period, resulting in the recognition of a straight line expense of $235,000 and a corresponding credit entry to equity reserves has been in the financial statements during the year. The amounts appear to have been appropriately recognized in the financial statements and given their immateriality, I believe that no disclosures in the notes to the financial statements are necessary in respect of the share-based scheme.'

Required:

Comment on the quality control and other professional issues that have arisen during the planning and performance of the audit of Layton Co for the financial year ended 30 June 20Y0.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Quality control and other issues arisen during the planning and performance of audit:

^ While planning activitiesthe auditor shall establish an overall audit strategy considering - nature timing and extent of resources necssary to perform the engagement - in this situation engagement team should have verified the avaliability of Mr. Luke who was previously in favour with engagement.

^ Analytical procedures need to be applied for the risky areas

^ Engagement team need to determine the materiality level for the risk ascertained through the risk assessment procedures.

^ Involvement of experts are required when the auditor dont have sufficient knowledge about the particular matter - in this engagement team didnot obtain expert opinion and moreover it didnot obtained the evidence about fair valuation, but confirmed only by checking their website design which is not relevant and not considered as sufficient and appropiate audit evidence.

^ While obtaining the experts opinion auditor should consider their competence,capability and objectivity and whether the work of such individual is adequate for auditors purpose.

^ Disclosure are required to be done by management in the financial statements with respect to SAR of employees, where the auditor judgement is not appropiate for not disclosing considering its materiality.

^ Disclosure may be given with respect to the agreement between employees, terms and conditions, No. of SAR, exercise price, fair value, valuation method for measuring the fair value, the impact on statement of profit and loss and on balance sheet for such SAR's.

ekkarill92 answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

You are audit senior at Bernstein and Griffiths and have been assigned to the audit of...

You are audit senior at Bernstein and Griffiths and have been assigned to the audit of Stockman Ltd (Stockman) for the current year. Stockman manufactures, wholesales and retails Australian outback clothing for sale both in Australia and overseas. During the planning stage of the audit, you have identified the following three key internal controls over the functioning of Stockman’s online inventory management system: Internal control 1 – the system will not allow a customer to place an order for an...

3. Planning a Performance Audit - You have been assigned to a performance audit of a...

3. Planning a Performance Audit - You have been assigned to a performance audit of a local government, focused on compliance with requirements for state grant funds. Assume that you are just beginning to plan your audit. Considering guidance in the GAO’s Yellow Book, summarize some of the most important steps you should take in this Planning phase of your audit.

You have recently been hired by Layton Motors, Inc. (LMI), in its relatively new treasury management...

You have recently been hired by Layton Motors, Inc. (LMI), in its relatively new treasury management department. LMI was founded eight years ago by Rachel Layton. Rachel found a method to manufacture a cheaper battery that will hold a larger charge, giving a car powered by the battery a range of 700 miles before requiring a recharge. The cars manufactured by LMI are midsized and carry a price that allows the company to compete with other mainstream auto manufacturers. The...

As the Manager of the Bronxville location of the Metropolitan Clinic, you have been assigned to...

As the Manager of the Bronxville location of the Metropolitan Clinic, you have been assigned to complete the 2017 operating expense budget. This clinic provides primary care to patients of all ages. It has contracts in place with all of the major payers as well as all of the Medicaid Managed Care providers currently licensed in NY State. In preparing your budget for next year you have been given several assumptions, as follows: Salaries, benefits and taxes will increase by...

Assume you are a project manager at JCDecaux and have been assigned to work with the...

Assume you are a project manager at JCDecaux and have been assigned to work with the city of Lyon to implement this physical, organizational, and social change. What are the practical and philosophical implications of this work?

Auditing the Revenue Process You have been assigned to the first audit of the Black Clover...

Auditing the Revenue Process You have been assigned to the first audit of the Black Clover company for the year ending March 31, 2019. Accounts receivable were confirmed on December 31, 2018, and at that date, the receivables consisted of approximately 200 accounts with balances totaling $956,750. Fifty of these accounts, with balances totaling $650,725, were selected for confirmation. All but 10 of the confirmation requests have been returned; 24 were returned without any exceptions, 6 had minor diﬀerences that...

You and your colleagues have been assigned to the audit of a private company, Rose Pty...

You and your colleagues have been assigned to the audit of a private company, Rose Pty Limited, which operates a plant nursery with a turnover of $6 million a year. The total number of full-time employees working for the company is 16, together with between five to seven casual employees as and when required on weekends. The company is run by a husband and wife team who are the directors and shareholders and a full-time accounts clerk, Sofia, who is...

You have been assigned to the audit or Grain Crops Ltd (Grain Crops), a company that...

You have been assigned to the audit or Grain Crops Ltd (Grain Crops), a company that produces wheat, flour, yeast and other baker products. As with many other businesses, Grain Crops has been finding it extremely difficult to recruit and retain skilled factory staff. As a result, Grain Crops decided that staff in the most difficult-to-retain award categories will be rewarded with annual bonuses. These are calculated using a relatively complex formula that takes into account the employee’s length of...

You have been assigned to work as a project manager on a very important project that...

You have been assigned to work as a project manager on a very important project that requires significant funding. There are several options to consider. Being new to the organisation, you have very limited knowledge of the organisational dynamics, industry and funding preferences. As a project manager, what do you think your duties are on this project? Name a few essential steps and activities you will need to do to effectively perform your job.

You are the audit manager assigned to the audit of MNO Corporation. MNO imports goods from...

You are the audit manager assigned to the audit of MNO Corporation. MNO imports goods from around the world and sells the goods to small and midsize retailers. This is the first year of the audit. Andy has recently graduated and has joined your firm as a junior accountant. He has been assigned to the inventory section for the interim audit and is eager to do a good job. Andy uses the model documentation used by your firm. His notes...

Subjects