Question

In: Economics

One of Peter Singer’s arguments relies on a claim about when we are obligated to prevent...

One of Peter Singer’s arguments relies on a claim about when we are obligated to prevent bad things from happening to others. What is that claim?

If you can prevent something bad from happening, then you are morally obligated to prevent it, unless preventing it would require making a significant personal sacrifice

If you can prevent something bad from happening, then you are morally obligated to prevent it, unless preventing it would require violating someone’s moral rights

If you can prevent something bad from happening, then you are morally obligated to prevent it, provided you would not thereby be sacrificing something of comparable moral importance

If you can prevent something bad from happening, then you are morally obligated to prevent it, even if the costs to you would be greater than the benefits to others.

Which of the following claims does Peter Singer make about the “Bugatti” and “Inheritance” cases? Select all that apply.

There is no morally significant difference between what Bob does in Bugatti and what you do in Inheritance

The fact that the child in Bugatti is closer than the child in Inheritance makes what you do in Inheritance less wrong than what Bob does in Bugatti (but still seriously wrong)

The fact that many people are in a position to donate to charity but fail to do so makes what you do in Inheritance less wrong than what Bob does in Bugatti (but still seriously wrong)

If what Bob does in Bugatti is seriously wrong, then what you do in Inheritance is seriously wrong

Solutions

Expert Solution

sol:

Peter Singer, is a rationalistic philosopher. He teaches "practical ethics," which he describes as the application of philosophy rather than religious principles to practical problems based on metaphysical reasoning.

His theory is that hungry children will be more valuable to our surplus wealth than they are to us. A desperately poor person will be much happier with $200 that we don't need for survival, while it would only boost our happiness a little.

Singer argues that donating to charity' is neither benevolent nor compassionate where poverty in the world is concerned; it is no more than our responsibility and it would be wrong not to donate. He says we have a responsibility, simply because we can, to reduce suffering and death.

A common practise in the United States is giving to charity. It is not universal, however, as many individuals do not donate money. According to Singer, therefore, if individuals do not donate to charity to help end these sufferings, then it means that they are unethical. If they are willing to, people have an ethical duty to donate money.


Related Solutions

We when run a hypothesis test, we are looking to verify a claim about a population...
We when run a hypothesis test, we are looking to verify a claim about a population parameter. Why is it important that we have a statistical tool to allow us to do this? For example, suppose that you were the quality control officer for a CPU manufacturer. Your job is to ensure that the CPUs your company makes meet certain performance standards so that when they are installed in iPhones they function properly and the phone company can truthfully claim...
When we are making a claim, we must support that position with sufficient evidence. We can...
When we are making a claim, we must support that position with sufficient evidence. We can find that evidence in journals, articles, experiments, experiences, and more. What is the reason for having sufficient evidence? You want to sway the reader to see the topic from your point of view. In order to do this, you must have convincing, reliable, and credible evidence. Why should your evidence be convincing, reliable, and credible? What might happen if your evidence does not come...
What are we talking about when we talk about Population Health? Cite an example of a...
What are we talking about when we talk about Population Health? Cite an example of a population health initiative. Has it been successful? Why or why not?
Pick one of the following philosophers. Research their main ideas and arguments about ethics, and state...
Pick one of the following philosophers. Research their main ideas and arguments about ethics, and state a similarity or a difference between the ideas of the philosopher you've chosen and the readings from one of the modules we've done so far. Does the thinker you chose have ideas that are similar to any of the ideas of Kant's ethics, utilitarianism, virtue ethics, or natural law ethics? How so? Angela Davis Mohandas Gandhi Seyla Benhabib Malcolm X Emma Goldman Cornell West...
Why do some economists claim that we should not worry too much about inflation?
Why do some economists claim that we should not worry too much about inflation?
When we are discussing Two-Way ANOVAs, what do we mean when we talk about a mixed-model...
When we are discussing Two-Way ANOVAs, what do we mean when we talk about a mixed-model design? There is an advantage to doing a Two-Way ANOVA rather than two One-Way ANOVAs. What is it?
Is the claim that more innocent people die when we do not have capital punishment more...
Is the claim that more innocent people die when we do not have capital punishment more likely true or false?
When learning about depreciation and how to record it into the journal, we hear about an...
When learning about depreciation and how to record it into the journal, we hear about an account called accumulated depreciation and that it is a contra asset account. Please explain what this account is and what it means to be a contra asset account.
1. Create a hypothesis/claim about one or two proportions or means related to some of the...
1. Create a hypothesis/claim about one or two proportions or means related to some of the data available. You must use a different parameter than what you used in the interval estimates, so if you used a proportion for the interval, this part must involve a mean or means, and vice versa. Include a brief explanation of why you or someone else might be interested in testing your claim (make it meaningful). Then state the hypothesis both in words and...
a) Why do some economists claim that we should not worry too much about inflation? 2...
a) Why do some economists claim that we should not worry too much about inflation? 2 marks b) Other economists think that there are significant costs associated with inflation above 2-3%. What are they? Briefly discuss
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT