Question

In: Nursing

Is it ethical for the federal government to pay the costs of kidney dialysis for all...

Is it ethical for the federal government to pay the costs of kidney dialysis for all patients, regardless of age or income, as it now does, but not to pay the costs of other illnesses? Which would be more reasonable and more feasible: extending benefits to those who have other illnesses or withdrawing them from those who need kidney dialysis?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Kidney dialysis is a procedure in which machine removes the deoxygenated blood cleans it and circulate the oxygenated blood back to the body. This is the sole medical service Medicare pays for to the person regardless of the age. Its been the case since 1972. So every individual who require recieve dialysis even with end stage renal disease. That's a good thing bit it consumes a huge amount of medicare spending. Since there have been no change in the rule since 1972 medicare still handles the patient with kidney disease the same way and still so many people take dialysis in clinics rather than home which is much cheaper and a very few performs kidney transplant which is long lasting and healthier solution .While in-home dialysis is far cheaper and more comfortable, as it can be delivered while patients sleep, just 12 percent of patients receive the procedure in that type of setting.The law was meant to keep young and middle-aged people alive and productive. The kidney expert says many of the patients who take advantage of the law are old and have other medical problems, often suffering through dialysis as a replacement for their failed kidneys but not living long because the other chronic diseases kill them.

It should be better to extend benefits for those who have other illness withdrawing is not a great option as some people are really in need of dialysis.


Related Solutions

What ethical issues surround the use of kidney dialysis machines? What roles do you think social...
What ethical issues surround the use of kidney dialysis machines? What roles do you think social or economic factors play in decisions? Do the rich and poor have the same access? What criteria would you use to decide who would receive dialysis?
Research the internet to determine the pros and cons of kidney dialysis and kidney transplantation. Remember...
Research the internet to determine the pros and cons of kidney dialysis and kidney transplantation. Remember to review not only the cost of these procedures, typical insurance coverages, and both long and short term effects of both options. Determine the difficulties if the kidney donor is a live donor versus a kidney from someone who has passed and they had previously decided to or their family has decided to provide their organs for donation. Is there a benefit to doing...
Hemodialysis (also known as “dialysis”) is a common treatment for patients with kidney disease. In the...
Hemodialysis (also known as “dialysis”) is a common treatment for patients with kidney disease. In the United States, more than 468,000 patients are on dialysis (NIH, 2018). Since 1993, hospitalization rates related to the process of dialysis has risen between 47-87% (CDC, 2018). Many patients seek dialysis care at outpatient facilities that are not inspected as frequently as other healthcare facilities, like nursing homes and hospitals. For example, in California, kidney dialysis clinics are only inspected on average once every...
The level of various substances in the blood of kidney dialysis patients is of concern because...
The level of various substances in the blood of kidney dialysis patients is of concern because kidney failure and dialysis can lead to nutritional problems. A researcher performed blood tests on several dialysis patients on 6 consecutive clinic visits. One variable measured was the level of phosphate in the blood. Phosphate levels for an individual tend to vary normally over time. The data on one patient, in milligrams of phosphate per deciliter (mg/dl) of blood, are given below. 5.2 4.6...
Dialysis is a treatment for severe kidney disease, and it is becoming increasingly common. Please describe...
Dialysis is a treatment for severe kidney disease, and it is becoming increasingly common. Please describe this process, its benefits, and its risks. Your response should be a minimum of 100 words, with in-text citations and references
An 80 kg man who has poor kidney function, but not on dialysis, needs this much...
An 80 kg man who has poor kidney function, but not on dialysis, needs this much protein in his diet: A. 40-48 g protein/day B. 48-64 g protein/day C. 80-96 g protein/day D. 96-112 g protein/day The roles of CCK and Secretin produced by the duodenum in response to dietary protein includes all these, except: A. Stimulate pancreas to release digestive enzymes B. Stumulate gall bladder to release bile C. Stimulate faster stomach emptying Which of the following is NOT...
Jarrid Medical, Inc., is developing a compact machine for kidney dialysis, but the company's chief engineer,...
Jarrid Medical, Inc., is developing a compact machine for kidney dialysis, but the company's chief engineer, Mike Crowe, has trouble controlling the variability of how quickly the fluid moves through the device Medical employers require that the flow per hour be 4.25 liters, 98% of the time. Mr. Crowe, tests the prototype with the following results for each hourly flow test: 4.17 4.32 4.21 4.22 4.29 4.19 4.29 4.34 4.33 4.22 4.28 4.33 4.52 4.29 4.43 4.39 4.44 4.34 4.3...
Patients with chronic kidney failure may be treated by dialysis, in which a machine removes toxic...
Patients with chronic kidney failure may be treated by dialysis, in which a machine removes toxic wastes from the blood, a function normally performed by the kidneys. Kidney failure and dialysis can cause other changes, such as retention of phosphorus, that must be corrected by changes in diet. A study of the nutrition of dialysis patients measured the level of phosphorus in the blood of several patients on six occasions. Here are the data for one patient (in milligrams of...
a.he most common reasons for initiating dialysis in acute kidney injury include which of the following?...
a.he most common reasons for initiating dialysis in acute kidney injury include which of the following? Select all that apply. Select one or more: a. Volume overload b. Acidosis c. Hyperkalemia d. Hypokalemia b.The most common cause of acute kidney injury in critically ill patients is:    Select one: a. Medications.   b. Fluid overload.   c. Sepsis.   d. Hemodynamic instability.
1.Suppose that in the next federal budget, the government decides to eliminate all (government) purchases that...
1.Suppose that in the next federal budget, the government decides to eliminate all (government) purchases that are financed by borrowing because the politicians worry about a budget deficit. What is wrong with this argument? Briefly discuss using the loanable fund market.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT