Question

In: Finance

1. Provide two conditions under which a set of projects might be characterized as mutually exclusive....

1. Provide two conditions under which a set of projects might be characterized as mutually exclusive.

2. Under what circumstances might the IRR and NPV approaches produce conflicting results?

Solutions

Expert Solution

1. Provide two conditions under which a set of projects might be characterized as mutually exclusive.

A set of projects are considered mutually exclusive when if one project is taken the other project cannot be taken.

  • Resource constraint: There is no capital to invest in both the projects
  • The two projects are of similar type. Taking one project makes the other project redundant.

2. IRR and NPV approaches produce conflicting results when the projects are mutually exclusive and the size of investments differ significantly in two projects.

Example: Project 1: Initial investment is $10,000. One year cash flow is $20,000

IRR = 100%

NPV at 10% discount rate = -10,000 + 20,000/1.1 = $8,181.8181818182

Project 2: Initial investment is $1,000,000. One year cash flow is $1,250,000

IRR = 25%

NPV at 10% discount rate = -1,000,000 + 1,250,000/1.1 = $136,363.636363636

If we go by IRR rule we would accept project 1 because its IRR (100%) is greater than the IRR of project 2 (25%)

But, the dollar amount we would make is only $8,181.8181818182 from project 1.

Therefore, whenever IRR rule and NPV rule conflicts, we should always go with NPV rule. NPV rule is superior to any other rule


Related Solutions

The Box Company was confronted with the two mutually exclusive investment projects, A and B, which...
The Box Company was confronted with the two mutually exclusive investment projects, A and B, which have the following after-tax cash flows: Cash Flows, per Year ($) Project                                0                1                         2                   3                          4 A                                   (12,000)        5,000               5,000              5,000                5,000 B                                   (12,000)            Nil                     Nil                    Nil            25,000 Based on these cash flows: (a) Calculate each project’s NPV and IRR. (Assume that the firm’s cost of capital after taxes is 10 percent.) (b) Suggest to the management as to which project to...
A company is evaluating two mutually exclusive projects in which to invest. Project A needs an...
A company is evaluating two mutually exclusive projects in which to invest. Project A needs an investment of $300,000 and will deliver $160,000 in annual profits during its 8 years life. Project B needs an investment of $400,000 and will deliver $210,000 in annual profits during its 6 years life. Considering a Study Period of 6 years, and that project A can be sold for $200,000 at the end of the 6th year (because it will still have 2 years...
A firm is considering two mutually exclusive projects, A and B. The projects are different in...
A firm is considering two mutually exclusive projects, A and B. The projects are different in that they have different returns depending on general economic conditions. The firm forecasts that return on the market, and the returns on each project, along with their associated probabilities will be given by the following table. You can assume a 5% risk free rate and a 6% market risk premium. Assume the CAPM holds. Compare the expected returns to the cost of capital for...
IRRlMutually exclusive projects   Bell Manufacturing is attempting to choose the better of two mutually exclusive projects...
IRRlMutually exclusive projects   Bell Manufacturing is attempting to choose the better of two mutually exclusive projects for expanding the​ firm'swarehouse capacity. The relevant cash flows for the projects are shown in the following​ table: Initial investment        $500,000         $320,000 Year                 1          $130,000         $130,000 2          $120,000         $120,000 3          $130,000         $105,000 4          $200,000         $90,000 5          $250,000         $40,000 The​ firm's cost of capital is 17​%. a.  Calculate the IRR for each of the projects. Assess the acceptability of each project on the basis of the IRRs. b.  Which project is​ preferred?
​(Mutually exclusive projects and NPV​) You have been assigned the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive...
​(Mutually exclusive projects and NPV​) You have been assigned the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive projects with the following projected cash​ flows: If the appropriate discount rate on these projects is 11 ​percent, which would be chosen and​ why? What is the NPV of project​ A? ​$ nothing ​ (Round to the nearest​ cent.) What is the NPV of project​ B? ​$ ​(Round to the nearest​ cent.) Which project would be chosen and​ why? ​(Select the best choice​.) A....
​(Mutually exclusive projects and NPV​) You have been assigned the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive...
​(Mutually exclusive projects and NPV​) You have been assigned the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive projects with the following projected cash​ flows: YEAR PROJECT A CASH FLOW PROJECT B CASH FLOW    0 −​$110,000 −​$110,000    1        30,000               0    2        30,000               0    3        30,000               0    4        30,000               0    5        30,000      220,000 ​(Click on the icon located on the​ top-right corner of the data table above in order to copy its contents into a spreadsheet.​) If the appropriate discount rate on these...
IRRlong dash—Mutually exclusive projects Bell Manufacturing is attempting to choose the better of two mutually exclusive...
IRRlong dash—Mutually exclusive projects Bell Manufacturing is attempting to choose the better of two mutually exclusive projects for expanding the firm's warehouse capacity. The relevant cash flows for the projects are shown in the following table: LOADING... . The firm's cost of capital is 1313 %. a. Calculate the IRR for each of the projects. Assess the acceptability of each project on the basis of the IRRs. b. Which project is preferred? Project X Project Y Initial investment ​(CF 0CF0​)...
​(Mutually exclusive projects and NPV​) You have been assigned the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive...
​(Mutually exclusive projects and NPV​) You have been assigned the task of evaluating two mutually exclusive projects with the following projected cash​ flows: YEAR   PROJECT A CASH FLOW   PROJECT B CASH FLOW 0 -105,000 -105,000 1 40,000 0 2 40,000 0 3 40,000 0 4 40,000 0 5 40,000 240,000 If the appropriate discount rate on these projects is 8 ​percent, which would be chosen and​ why? What is the NPV of project​ A? What is the NPV of project...
The following 3 mutually exclusive projects are under consideration. Use Incremental IRR to determine which project...
The following 3 mutually exclusive projects are under consideration. Use Incremental IRR to determine which project should be undertaken if MARR = 18%. year Proj. A Projc. B Proj. C 0 $-500,000 $-350,000 $-700,000 1 $200,000 $100,000 $300,000 2 $200,000 $150,000 $300,000 3 $250,000 $200,000 $300,000 4 $250,000 $250,000 $300,000
Considering two mutually exclusive projects. The crossover rate between these two projects is ___ percent and...
Considering two mutually exclusive projects. The crossover rate between these two projects is ___ percent and Project ___ should be accepted if the required return is less than the crossover rate. Year Project A Project B 0 −$27,000 −$27,000 1 10,000 18,100 2 10,000 8,000 3 18,000 10,120 11.75%; A 11.75%; B 17.19%; B 18.64%; A 17.19%; A
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT