Question

In: Statistics and Probability

A clinical psychologist is interested in comparing the effectiveness of short term relaxation and cognitive-behavioral therapy...

A clinical psychologist is interested in comparing the effectiveness of short term relaxation and cognitive-behavioral therapy in treating mild depression.  An experiment is conducted in which 15 patients with mild depression are randomly selected and assigned 5 each to a relaxation therapy group, a cognitive/behavioral therapy group, and an attention placebo group.  Therapy is administered until the patient is judged no longer depressed or until 10 treatment sessions have elapsed.  The following data is obtained.  Scores are the number of sessions for each patient. Using an alpha of .05, test the hypothesis that there is a difference in effectiveness among these therapies.

Cognitive/Behavioral

Therapy

Relaxation
Therapy

Attention-Placebo
Group

5
6
6
4
7

6
8
7
9
7

  5
  8
  9
  7
  6

a) What is the appropriate test?

b) What is the Null Hypothesis? What is the Alternative Hypothesis? (include the means)

c) Using a = 0.05, Fcrit = _________.

d) Calculate

Solutions

Expert Solution

a)

We Can One way ANOVA test

b)

Ho: 1 = 2 = 3

Ha: At least one of the mean is different

C)

CALCULATION:

Number of Treatment, t = 3 n = 15

T1 (sum of Cognitive/Behavioral therapy) = 28, T2(Sum of Relaxation therapy) = 37, T3(Sum of Attention-Placebo group) = 35

G = Grand Total = 100

CF = Correction Factor = G2/N = 1002 / 15 = 666.67

= (5)2 + (6)2 + ......................+ (6)2 - 666.67

TSS = 29.33

SSTR = (1 / 5) * [(28)2 + (37)2 + (35)2] - 666*.67

SSTR = 8.93

SSE = TSS - SSTR

= 29.33 - 8.93

SSE = 20.40

MSSTR = SSTR/t-1 = 8.93 / 3-1 = 4.47

MSSE = SSE / n-t = 20.40 /15-3 = 1.70

F = MSSTR / MSSE = 4.47 / 1.70 = 2.63

Ftabulate = F,(t-1,n-t) = F0.05,(2,12) = 3.8853                            ..............Using F table

ANOVA TABLE:

Conclusion:

Test statistic < Critical value, i.e. 2.63 < 3.8853, That is Fail to Reject Ho at 5% level of significance.

Therefore, there is a difference in effectiveness among these therapies


Related Solutions

      You are a clinical psychologist is interested in comparing the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy,...
      You are a clinical psychologist is interested in comparing the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy, relaxation therapy, and no therapy (control group) for treating mild anxiety. An experiment is conducted in which 15 patients with mild anxiety were randomly assigned 5 each to the three groups. After 4 weeks, participants were given an anxiety questionnaire and their scores were recorded. The following data were analyzed. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Relaxation Therapy Group Control Group 5 6 7 6 8 10...
Example 16: A clinical psychologist compared the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) to the effectiveness...
Example 16: A clinical psychologist compared the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) to the effectiveness of family therapy (FT) for treating women with anorexia nervosa. The psychologist randomly selected 28 women with anorexia nervosa. 17 of the 28 women were randomly assigned to CBT and the other 11 women were randomly assigned to FT. Each women's weight prior to therapy was subtracted from her weight 3 months after therapy/ Thus the greater the weight difference, the more effective the...
A clinical psychologist has run a between-subjects experiment comparing two treatments for depression (cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT)...
A clinical psychologist has run a between-subjects experiment comparing two treatments for depression (cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and client-centered therapy (CCT) against a control condition. Subjects were randomly assigned to the experimental condition. After 12 weeks, the subject’s depression scores were measured using the CESD depression scale. The data are summarized as follows: Using the following data, perform a oneway analysis of variance using α=.05 Sample 1 cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT Sample 2 Client-centered therapy (CCT) Sample 3 Control Group M =...
Researchers are interested in testing the effectiveness of their new therapy technique (Explosive Therapy) by comparing...
Researchers are interested in testing the effectiveness of their new therapy technique (Explosive Therapy) by comparing it to a standard therapy technique (Cognitive Redecorating), a controversial newer treatment (Ludovico) and a no-treatment (wait list) control. Twelve clients are randomly assigned to the three groups. Blind raters evaluate the “mental health” using a validated instrument yielding scores from 0 to 10, where 0 indicates very poor mental health and 10 represents very good mental health. Perform an ANOVA on these data....
A school psychologist is interested in the effect a popular new cognitive therapy on anxiety. The...
A school psychologist is interested in the effect a popular new cognitive therapy on anxiety. The psychologist collects a sample of 13 students and gives them the cognitive therapy once a week for two months. Afterwards the students fill out an anxiety inventory in which their average score was 46.21. Normal individuals in the population have an anxiety inventory average of 49 with a standard deviation of 2.7. What can be concluded with α = 0.10? a) What is the...
Lovett Malta Martin Davis and Chloe 2007 evaluated the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy for treating...
Lovett Malta Martin Davis and Chloe 2007 evaluated the effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy for treating PTSD and related symptoms for survivors of the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center they use the protest post-test design to see if CVT was successful at reducing the symptoms of PTSD
1) Pretend you are a cognitive behavioral psychologist. What cognitive and behavioral techniques would you use...
1) Pretend you are a cognitive behavioral psychologist. What cognitive and behavioral techniques would you use to treat the following: -loneliness/fear of developing a friendship with others, -fear of losing weight despite morbid obesity, and -a not well acknowledged fear of sexual intimacy even though they have a strong desire for it. Please answer in detail. Thank you.
(Chapter 15) A psychologist conducts a two-factor study comparing the effectiveness of two different therapy techniques...
(Chapter 15) A psychologist conducts a two-factor study comparing the effectiveness of two different therapy techniques (factor A) for treating mild and severe phobias (factor B). The dependent variable is a measure of fear for each participant. If the study uses n= 9 participants in each of the five conditions, then identify the df values for each of the three F-Ratios.  Be sure to show all formulas with symbols (and plug in numbers), steps, processes and calculations for all steps and...
A cognitive psychologist is testing the theory that short-term memory is mediated by subvocal rehearsal. This...
A cognitive psychologist is testing the theory that short-term memory is mediated by subvocal rehearsal. This theory can be tested by reading aloud a string of letters to a participant, who must repeat the string correctly after a brief delay. If the theory is correct, there will be more errors when the list contains letters that sound alike (e.g., G and T) than when the list contains letters that look alike (e.g., P and R). Each participant gets both types...
What are the differences between cognitive therapy and behavioral therapy? Why is it important for counselors...
What are the differences between cognitive therapy and behavioral therapy? Why is it important for counselors to know the differences between these two therapies?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT