Question

In: Finance

How do bubbles confirm or disaffirm the EMH (efficient market hypothesis)?

How do bubbles confirm or disaffirm the EMH (efficient market hypothesis)?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) cannot explain economic bubbles because, strictly speaking, the EMH would argue that economic bubbles don't really exist. The hypothesis's reliance on assumptions about information and pricing is fundamentally at odds with the mispricing that drives economic bubbles.

Economic bubbles occur when asset prices rise far above their true economic value and then fall rapidly. The EMH states that asset prices reflect true economic value because information is shared among market participants and rapidly incorporated into the stock price.

Efficient Market Hypothesis and Bubbles

Whether bubbles are predictable is subject to debate. Behavioral finance, a field that attempts to identify and examine financial decision making, has uncovered several biases in investment decision making, both on an individual and market level. There are several reasons why a market and investors could act inefficiently and as a result, misinterpret a bubble as a bull market.

Market Information

All investors review information differently and could, therefore, apply different stock valuations. Also, some investors might exhibit inattentiveness to certain kinds of information. For example, stock prices take time to respond to new information and the investors who act quickly on the information could earn more profit than those who act on the information later.

Human Emotions

Stock prices can be affected by human error and emotional decision making. Herding behavior is when all market participants act in the same way to the information available. The herd instinct could be applied to the correction in the S&P 500 following information about the 2020 coronavirus outbreak. Although the fear could be justified, the fear of losing money prompted many traders and investors to sell equities leading to widespread declines in markets across the globe.

Human Bias

Confirmation bias can occur when investors only accept and research information that supports their view of the investment. If an investor is bullish on a stock, only articles and research that support the bullish view would be considered. As a result, the investor might miss or avoid pertinent information that might cause the stock's price to decline. These biases have been shown to exist, but determining the incidence and level of a particular bias at a particular time has its challenges.

CONCLUSION

Of course, it should be noted that the EMH doesn't demand that all market participants are right all the time. However, one of the theory's core tenets revolves around the idea of market efficiency. Given that market participants share the same information, the consensus price should accurately reflect an asset's fair value because those who are wrong transact with those who are right. Behavioral finance, on the other hand, argues that the consensus can be wrong.

Whether it is predictable or not, some have argued that the financial crisis represented a serious blow to the EMH because of the depth and magnitude of the mispricings that preceded it. However, proponents of efficient market hypothesis would likely disagree.


Related Solutions

How do you understand efficient market hypothesis(EMH), and why does it important?
How do you understand efficient market hypothesis(EMH), and why does it important?
"Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)" Please respond to the following: The book discusses the Efficient Market Hypothesis...
"Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)" Please respond to the following: The book discusses the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) and its three forms. The EMH has a lot to do with information and stock prices. How does information get into prices? How do we know if prices reflect all available information? What are abnormal returns? What does the EMH have to say about abnormal returns? Please provide one citation/reference for your initial posting that is not your textbook. Please do not use...
Please see the Do you think the “Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)” holds in the stock market?...
Please see the Do you think the “Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)” holds in the stock market? What kind of aspects of EMH does apply to the current market or not?
Discuss three or more versions of the Efficient market hypothesis (EMH)
Discuss three or more versions of the Efficient market hypothesis (EMH)
a) Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) states that the price of a security (such as a share)...
a) Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) states that the price of a security (such as a share) accurately reflects the information available. When information arrives, how fast will an information about a share be captured and reflected in the share price depends on the degree of competition among market investors. List and briefly explain, in your own words, two variations of information. (b) Modigliani and Miller (1958) outline the most authoritative work on the theory of capital structure in a perfect...
(a) Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) states that the price of a security (such as a share)...
(a) Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) states that the price of a security (such as a share) accurately reflects the information available. When information arrives, how fast will an information about a share be captured and reflected in the share price depends on the degree of competition among market investors. List and briefly explain, in your own words, two variations of information.
i. Explain the three forms of efficient markets as stated in the Efficient market hypothesis (EMH)....
i. Explain the three forms of efficient markets as stated in the Efficient market hypothesis (EMH). What type of investment strategies would work best if the markets are actually efficient? .ii.       Explain with suitable examples from the business world, the role of Corporate Governance in efficient working of a business. You may take reference from agency theory in drawing up your analysis.
define the concept of market efficiency and the efficient market hypothesis (EMH). Provide an argument that...
define the concept of market efficiency and the efficient market hypothesis (EMH). Provide an argument that either supports or refutes the application of EMH. Use research and examples of investors
Explain market efficiency define the concept of market efficiency and the efficient market hypothesis (EMH).
Explain market efficiency define the concept of market efficiency and the efficient market hypothesis (EMH). a. Provide an argument that either supports or refutes the application of EMH. Use research and examples of investors. i. Warren Buffet, Joel Tillinghast, Will Danoff – consistently do better than the market. ii. Consider the risk with investing based on the EMH premise versus the risk of ignoring EMH.
Critically appraise the relevance of Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) in the light of the advancements in...
Critically appraise the relevance of Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) in the light of the advancements in the field of Behavioral Finance.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT