Question

In: Economics

Imagine two physicians who practice their profession in cities with identical demand for their services. Their...

Imagine two physicians who practice their profession in cities with identical demand for their services. Their marginal costs of providing medical services are also identical. During their medical school years, however, there was a difference between them. While Physician A received a full scholarship to attend medical school, Physician B had to pay full tuition. According to economic theory, should physician B charge a lower price than physician A for her services, the same price, or a higher price? Justify your answer.

Solutions

Expert Solution

The cost of schooling for physician B is more than the cost incurred by the other physician. If both the physicians were operating in the same city, then if the fees they charged were different, patients would go to the doctor who is charging less. In such a situation physician B should be charging similar to physician A.

Even if both of them were operating in different cities, they would most likely be operating in a market with other doctors and price cannot be set based on their individualistic expectations but based on the going market price. So it is not possible to charge more because his cost of education is more.


Related Solutions

There are two cities, San Fran and Eugene, and 100 identical workers who can choose to live in either city.
There are two cities, San Fran and Eugene, and 100 identical workers who can choose to live in either city. Suppose the indirect utility of living in either city is given by: Vj=Wj -Rj where Wj is the wage of living in either city j and Rj is the rent in city j. Wages in Eugene are $200 and wages in San F. are $400. Rents in Eugene, Re are given by: Re = 30 + Le, where Le is...
Assume that there is a two-period market with 100 identical customers who demand one unit of...
Assume that there is a two-period market with 100 identical customers who demand one unit of the good per period. Each is willing to pay up to a maximum price of $10. In the first time period there is one firm that acts as a monopolist and has a constant marginal cost equal to 5. In the second period the incumbent faces the possible entry of another firm. The potential entrant’s marginal cost is unknown to the incumbent firm. However,...
Two factories located in different cities, owned by the same organization (ABC Corp), produce the identical...
Two factories located in different cities, owned by the same organization (ABC Corp), produce the identical product. The product they make is a specialized all-terrain vehicle. In 2002, based on productivity data from a random sample of workers, management felt the average labor productivity of the two plants could be improved. So, both plants underwent identical process improvements through 2003. In 2004, the worker productivity was gauged for both plants using the same set of workers. Factory A Before Factory...
Suppose there are two firms, Firm 1 and Firm 2, who produce identical goods. Together, they face the following market demand.
  Suppose there are two firms, Firm 1 and Firm 2, who produce identical goods. Together, they face the following market demand. Q=140-P Assume both firms have a marginal cost of 20, so MC=20. a. Monopoly: If the two firms could collude and act like a monopoly, what is the total quantity produced and what is the price? b. Bertrand Competition with Identical Goods: Now assume that the firms simultaneously choose their price. What is the quantity produced and at...
A test was conducted for two overnight mail delivery services. Two samples of identical deliveries were...
A test was conducted for two overnight mail delivery services. Two samples of identical deliveries were set up so that both delivery services were notified of the need for a delivery at the same time. The hours required to make each delivery follow. Do the data shown suggest a difference in the delivery times for the two services? Use a .05 level of significance for the test. Delivery Service 1 Service 2 1 24.5 28.0 2 26.0 25.5 3 28.0...
Suppose there are N firms who produce an identical product and face the demand curve P...
Suppose there are N firms who produce an identical product and face the demand curve P = 170 – 3Q, where P is the price of the good (in dollars) and Q is the total quantity supplied by the firms. The marginal cost of production per firm is $20; there are no fixed costs. If there is only one firm in the market (a monopolist), what is this firm's optimal output? If there are four firms in the market (N=4),...
Suppose there are two firms that produce an identical product. The demand curve for their product...
Suppose there are two firms that produce an identical product. The demand curve for their product is represented by P=60-2Q, where Q is the total quantity produced by the two firms. The marginal cost of production is zero and there are no fixed costs. A. Refer to Scenario: Oligopoly. Suppose both firms choose their individual quantities q1 (firm 1) and q2 (firm 2) simultaneously and independently (so Q = q1 + q2). What is the unique Nash equilibrium price? B....
Two companies (A and B) are duopolists that produce identical products. Demand for the products is...
Two companies (A and B) are duopolists that produce identical products. Demand for the products is given by the following demand function: P = 1,000 - QA - QB where QA and QB are the quantities sold by the respective firms and P is the selling price. Total cost functions for the two companies are: TCA = 50,000 + 200QA + .5QA2 TCB = 20,000 + 400QB + QB2 Assume that the firms form a cartel to maximize total industry...
Two companies (A and B) are duopolists that produce identical products. Demand for the products is...
Two companies (A and B) are duopolists that produce identical products. Demand for the products is given by the following demand function:           P = 10,000 - QA - QB where QA and QB are the quantities sold by the respective firms and P is the selling price. Total cost functions for the two companies are:           TCA = 500,000 + 200QA + .5QA2          TCB = 200,000 + 400QB + QB2 a) Assume that the two firms act independently...
Suppose that market demand is given by ? = 180 − ?/3. The two identical firms...
Suppose that market demand is given by ? = 180 − ?/3. The two identical firms in the market both have marginal costs of 20. Draw the reaction curves on a graph and find the Cournot equilibrium price and quantities.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT