Question

In: Economics

The city of Delhi has some of the very worst air pollution in the world. One...

The city of Delhi has some of the very worst air pollution in the world. One key source of that air pollution are motor vehicles. The city is contemplating ways to reduce air pollution from motor vehicles. Suppose they know that the marginal benefits of abatement are equal to MB(a) = 154 -10a, which comes entirely from health benefits to the local population. There is no uncertainty about the benefits of abatement. But, the Delhi government is uncertain about costs. To reduce air pollution, they want to experiment with a new superclean motor fuel, but they don’t know if this will work with the existing vehicles. If it does not work with existing vehicles, then the total cost of abatement will be equal to TC = 2a² + 28a. But, if it does work, then this will be less expensive, so the total cost of abatement will be TC = 2a². Suppose there is a 50% chance that the new fuel works (so costs are lower), and a 50% chance that all the vehicles have to be retrofitted (so costs are higher). a) What is the expected marginal cost of abatement? (That is, take an average of the two possible marginal cost functions and write the corresponding function.) b) If the Delhi government were to create a tradable abatement permit system, where they mandated a certain level of abatement, what would be the quantity they should choose? (I.e., recognizing that they are uncertain, what is the best they can do. We mean here that they should choose as if the expected marginal cost curve is correct.) c) If the Delhi government were to create an abatement subsidy instead, what would be the optimal subsidy level? (I.e., recognizing that they are uncertain, what is the best they can do.)

Solutions

Expert Solution

a) Expected marginal cost of abatement = 50%(MC that it will work)+50%(MC it will not work).

Here, to find out expected Marginal cost(MC) we take a weighted average of two marginal cost function with weights equal to their corresponding probability of happening. We calculate it as follows

TC(that it will work) = 2a² + 28a

MC(that it will work) = 4a + 28 (differentiating with respect to a)

TC(that it will not work) =  2a²

MC(that it will not work) = 4a (again differentiating with respect to a)

Expected marginal cost of abatement = 0.5(4a+28)+0.5(4a)

b) If the Delhi government were to create a tradable abatement permit system then the level of abatement is chosen in such a way that marginal cost of abatement is equal to its marginal costs i.e.equilibrium quantity is such that MC=MR.Only this level of abatement is consistent with economic theory because if MC>MR, costs of abatement overweigh the benefits and if MC<MR the costs are less than the benefits, so level of abatement can be further increased till MC=MR. Also,since the government does not exactly know the MC, so we use expected MC of abatement.

MB(a) = 154-10a

Expected marginal cost of abatement = 0.5(4a+28)+0.5(4a)

Equating the two equations and solving,

154-10a = 0.5(4a+28)+0.5(4a)

154-10a = 2a+14+2a

154-14 = 14a

a = 10 = optimum level of abatement under tradable permit system.

c) An abatement subsidy is like negative tax which means that the government pays the individuals to not increase the level of pollution. Hence, the oppotunity cost of polluting is the foregone subsidy. So, the optimum abatement is still at 10. After this level of abatement marginal benefit from abatement will be : 154-10a = 154-100 = 54

So, the optimum level of subsidy that would be paid is 54.


Related Solutions

The health department of a large city has developed an air pollution index that measures the...
The health department of a large city has developed an air pollution index that measures the level of several air pollutants that cause respiratory distress in humans. The following table gives the pollution index (on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the worst) for 7 randomly selected summer days and the number of patients with acute respiratory problems admitted to the emergency rooms of the city’s hospitals. Air pollution index 4.5 6.7 8.2 5.0 4.6 6.1 3.0...
What is air pollution? What are some causes of it? What are some health consequences? What...
What is air pollution? What are some causes of it? What are some health consequences? What can be done to decrease it?
6. Air pollution problem. Consider an airshed in which there is one major contributor to air...
6. Air pollution problem. Consider an airshed in which there is one major contributor to air pollution--a cement-manufacturing plant whose annual production capacity is 2.500,000 barrels of cement. Figures are not available to determine whether the plant has been operating at capacity. Although the kilns are equipped with mechanical collectors for air pollution control, the plant still emits 2.0 lb of dust per barrel of cement produced. There are two types of electrostatic precipitators that can be installed to control...
The World trade Center in New York City on Tuesday, September 11, 2001—the worst terrorist incident...
The World trade Center in New York City on Tuesday, September 11, 2001—the worst terrorist incident in U.S. history. Explain why the terrorists were able to bring down the twin towers of the World Trade Center, with nearly 3,000 dead. However, but they were unable to bring down the U.S. financial system
Air pollution is one critical issue that the United States economy has been struggling to deal...
Air pollution is one critical issue that the United States economy has been struggling to deal with. A vehicle creates a lot of pollution that has negative externality effects in our economy. The Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFÉ) was designed to reduce American dependence on foreign oil by producing more fuel-efficient vehicles to help curb emissions. Should the government force car manufacturers to increase fuel efficiency standards, or should the government increase fuel taxes? When evaluating this question, discuss the...
Assume that a firm produces natural gas, but emits some air pollution as part of the...
Assume that a firm produces natural gas, but emits some air pollution as part of the process. The market functions for natural gas demand and supply, as well as the external damage that the air pollution causes, is shown below, where P is price in $/British Thermal Unit (BTU) and Q is quantities in BTUs : Demand: P = 1000 – 0.2Q Marginal Private Cost: P = 100 + 0.4Q Marginal External Cost: $500 Marginal Social Cost: P = 600...
Write some effective ways to control air pollution from petroleum and coal industries.
Write some effective ways to control air pollution from petroleum and coal industries.
Some companies and municipalities are switching to a four-day workweek to reduce traffic congestion, air pollution,...
Some companies and municipalities are switching to a four-day workweek to reduce traffic congestion, air pollution, and stressed employees. Compressing the workweek into four 10-hour days sounds pretty good to you. You would much prefer having Friday free to schedule medical appointments and take care of family business, in addition to leisurely three-day weekends. As a manager at Skin Essentials, a mineral-based skin care products and natural cosmetics company, you are convinced that the company’s 200 employees could switch to...
Why has pollution gotten worse in the world over the past 50 years?
Why has pollution gotten worse in the world over the past 50 years?
Los Angeles County has the worst urban air quality across all major metropolitan areas in the...
Los Angeles County has the worst urban air quality across all major metropolitan areas in the United States. Assume the California Air Resources Board is considering whether to set a uniform emission standard or a regionally-based emission standard, where one standard is set for Los Angeles County and another for the rest of the state. MSB, MSC, and MCE of abatement for the two regions have been estimated as follows: MSB (LA) = 500 - 0.75A MSC (rest) = 150...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT