Question

In: Economics

The Constitution specifically mentions which three categories of people?

The Constitution specifically mentions which three categories of people?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The citizenship provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment may be seen as a repudiation of one of the more politically divisive cases of the nineteenth century. Under common law, free persons born within a state or nation were citizens thereof. In the Dred Scott case, however, Chief Justice Taney, writing for the Court, ruled that this rule did not apply to freed slaves. The Court held that United States citizenship was enjoyed by only two classes of people:

  • White persons born in the United States as descendants of “persons, who were at the time of the adoption of the Constitution recognised as citizens in the several States, [and who] became also citizens of this new political body,” the United States of America,
  • Those who, having been “born outside the dominions of the United States,” had migrated thereto and been naturalized therein.

Freed slaves fell into neither of these categories.

The Court further held that, although a state could confer state citizenship upon whomever it chose, it could not make the recipient of such status a citizen of the United States. Thus, the “Negro,” as an enslaved race, was ineligible to attain United States citizenship, either from a state or by virtue of birth in the United States. Even a free man descended from a Negro residing as a free man in one of the states at the date of ratification of the Constitution was held ineligible for citizenship. Congress subsequently repudiated this concept of citizenship, first in section 15 of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 and then in section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment. In doing so, Congress set aside the Dred Scott holding, and restored the traditional precepts of citizenship by birth.

Based on the first sentence of section 1, the Court has held that a child born in the United States of Chinese parents who were ineligible to be naturalized themselves is nevertheless a citizen of the United States entitled to all the rights and privileges of citizenship. The requirement that a person be “subject to the jurisdiction thereof,” however, excludes its application to children born of diplomatic representatives of a foreign state, children born of alien enemies in hostile occupation, or children of members of Indian tribes subject to tribal laws.

In addition, the citizenship of children born on vessels in United States territorial waters or on the high seas has generally been held by the lower courts to be determined by the citizenship of the parents. Citizens of the United States within the meaning of this Amendment must be natural and not artificial persons; a corporate body is not a citizen of the United States.


Related Solutions

a. What is a constitution? b. State any three (3) three features of a constitution. c....
a. What is a constitution? b. State any three (3) three features of a constitution. c. State three (3) disadvantages of case law. d. Explain the following legal doctrines: i. Stare decisis ii. Orbiter dicta.
How do atmospherics impact consumer behavior? And specifically which categories have what effect on consumers?
How do atmospherics impact consumer behavior? And specifically which categories have what effect on consumers?
identify the five categories of expressed powers established by the constitution for US presidents. Cite a...
identify the five categories of expressed powers established by the constitution for US presidents. Cite a specific example of a president having exercise each type of authority. Are there any additional powers presidents use that are not constitutionally established? What are they?
1. The purpose(s) of the U.S. The Constitution includes which of the following: a. create three...
1. The purpose(s) of the U.S. The Constitution includes which of the following: a. create three coequal branches of the federal government. b. delegate and enumerate the powers of each of the federal branches of government. C. provide procedural protections to businesses, citizens, and persons from government interference. d. All of the answer choices are correct. 2. The power of Congress to regulate commerce comes from……,,,, a. states' legislatures. the U.S. Constitution's Commerce Clause. b. the U.S. President's executive orders...
What four amendments to the Constitution are specifically related to criminal procedure? In what ways do...
What four amendments to the Constitution are specifically related to criminal procedure? In what ways do these amendments impact the courts?
In which three categories can process reengineering improve performance?
In which three categories can process reengineering improve performance?
The textbook mentions that people do not always notice all the details of prices, or anticipate...
The textbook mentions that people do not always notice all the details of prices, or anticipate what price they will end up paying for a good or service. How can firms use this lack of rationality to help them make more profit? Focus on identifying some real world example.
Social stratification ranks categories of people in a hierarchy. What are the ranking categories in India,...
Social stratification ranks categories of people in a hierarchy. What are the ranking categories in India, South Africa, United Kingdom, Japan, The former Soviety Union, and China? (pages 276-283 in 15th edition or pages 244-251 in 16th edition)
Which are the three specific related UAE laws enacted which deal specifically with disparate treatment by...
Which are the three specific related UAE laws enacted which deal specifically with disparate treatment by the employer. Where the domestic servant can assert that he or she has been a disparage treated employee and obtain a remedy? A)Name UAE Law 1 explain answer in three lines: B)Name UAE Law 2 explain answer in three lines: C)Name UAE Law 3 explain answer in three lines
Macionis, your textbook author, mentions in chapter 5 that there is now some evidence that people...
Macionis, your textbook author, mentions in chapter 5 that there is now some evidence that people can become "addicted" to social media and that social media can have some very negative effects on our lives. If you believe that your personal use of social media has had very important negative impacts on your life, so many negative impacts that you have given up the use of social media for some significant period of time, please describe those impacts in detail....
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT