Question

In: Advanced Math

In terms of menu navigation define Breadth and Depth

In terms of menu navigation define Breadth and Depth

Solutions

Expert Solution

During the last 5 years a controversy has been brewing concerning the breadth vs. depth in menu design for Web sites. Which is best? A site that is broad and shallow, presenting a lot of choices to the user right away, but only requiring a few layers? Or is it best to have narrow and deep, which means presenting only a few choices at a time, but requiring many layers in? As is usually the case, the answer turns out not to be so simple. In this issue of the newsletter we explore the variables that are emerging as important in the debate.

The history of breadth vs. depth

In the March 1999 issue of this newsletter, Bob Bailey concluded that breadth was better than depth. He reported on two studies that also surveyed past literature and concluded that it was better to have lots of categories in Web menus at the highest level and therefore reduce the number of clicks needed to get to the end point. (Zaphiris and Mtei,1998; Larson and Czerwinski, 1998).

Earlier studies by Snowberry, Parkinson & Sission (1983) demonstrated that in addition to performance and preference declines, navigational error rates increased significantly as hypertext depth increased. This study further demonstrated the value of categorical grouping in shallow structures, showing that participants had an easier time finding resources in a 64 item list that was functionally organized than in a list with random presentation.

Follow-up studies (Kiger, 1984; Jacko & Slavendy 1996; Zaphiris and Mtei 1997) continued to demonstrate that:

  • users found resources faster in broader, shallow sites than in narrow deep ones, and
  • users understood broader, shallow sites better than they understood narrow deep ones.

However, these studies also began to demonstrate that although shallowness is a unique and defining parameter for success in learning hierarchies, sites can also be tooshallow.

More variables surface

Recent research suggests that there is more to it. When we focus specifically on people browsing the Internet we change the question slightly. Instead of just asking "Which menu structure is best?" we really need to ask, "Which menu structures helps users quickly derive a conceptual model of the site hierarchy?" Creating an accurate representation of the structure and organization of the site results in a more successful and efficient navigation through the resource.

Several factors are thought to influence users' success in learning and traversing information hierarchies. These do include the breadth/depth of hierarchy, but additional critical factors are: the transparency of the category and sub-category labels, qualities of information scent, relative size of categories, and the shape of the hierarchy.


Related Solutions

What is supply chain management? Describe the breadth and depth of the field? What are the...
What is supply chain management? Describe the breadth and depth of the field? What are the objectives in terms of good management of supply chains? What are the functional pieces of supply chain management in the broadest sense? What are the flows involved? What are the relationships involved? Think about being asked this question on an interview
List four variables that help to define a menu. What role does a menu play in...
List four variables that help to define a menu. What role does a menu play in relation to a business’s brand? List the two primary tools that help to define a market. What type of information does each one provides? If a chef wants to create a menu that exceeds his staff’s ability, why can’t he just hire new staff? How does a kitchen’s space and work flow impact a menu? Who are the typical stakeholders who contribute to the...
Discuss the importance of data collection in terms of patient navigation services. Please give at least...
Discuss the importance of data collection in terms of patient navigation services. Please give at least 3 reasons why data is key when having a quality navigation program and/or services.
Define the concept of menu costs and explain its relationship with the assumption of monetary neutrality
Define the concept of menu costs and explain its relationship with the assumption of monetary neutrality
Define the following terms. Drag the terms on the left to the appropriate blanks on the...
Define the following terms. Drag the terms on the left to the appropriate blanks on the right to complete the sentences. ResetHelp heritability QTL monozygotic twins correlation polygenes additive alleles dizygotic twins 1.   is a statistic that varies from -1 to +1 and describes the extent to which variation in one trait is associated with variation in another. 2.   is a measure of the degree to which the phenotypic variation of a given trait is due to genetic factors. 3.   are situations in...
Define the following terms. Drag the terms on the left to the appropriate blanks on the...
Define the following terms. Drag the terms on the left to the appropriate blanks on the right to complete the sentences. ResetHelp heritability QTL monozygotic twins correlation polygenes additive alleles dizygotic twins 1.   is a statistic that varies from -1 to +1 and describes the extent to which variation in one trait is associated with variation in another. 2.   is a measure of the degree to which the phenotypic variation of a given trait is due to genetic factors. 3.   are situations in...
Define the following terms as they pertain to translation
Define the following terms as they pertain to translation (see diagram in back)  a. mRNA b. anticodon c. polysome d. ribosomal subunits e. rRNA f. Start and stop codons g. tRNA 
A. Define the following terms:                   -Correlation                   -Ca
A. Define the following terms:                   -Correlation                   -Causation                   B. How do we know when 2 variables are correlated?                   C. Explain the following: “Correlation does not equal Causation”                   D. What requirements must be met to satisfy Causation?
For all of the following pairs of terms, define the two phrases/terms and then explain the...
For all of the following pairs of terms, define the two phrases/terms and then explain the relationship between them. 1. Comparative Statics, Equilibrium Analysis, and Constrained Optimization. 2. Perfect substitutes and Perfect Complements. 3. Diminishing Marginal rate of substitution and the Diminishing Marginal Utility. 4. Transitivity and Convexity. 5. Indifference curves and Utility functions. 6. Essential and Inessential Goods
For all of the following pairs of terms, define the two phrases/terms and then explain the...
For all of the following pairs of terms, define the two phrases/terms and then explain the relationship between them. Compensating variation and Equivalent variation. Returns to scale and Long run average cost. Marginal Cost and Marginal Product Marginal rate of technical substitution and Isoquant Cost function and Conditional factor demands
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT