Question

In: Economics

The aim of this case study is to illustrate the sometimes competing demands of effectiveness, efficiency...

The aim of this case study is to illustrate the sometimes competing demands of effectiveness, efficiency and equity. In particular, it should help you to:

Explain what is meant by key terms such as ‘LYG’, ‘QALY’ and ‘ICER’

Use these terms and the information they represent in a decision-making scenario

Compare and contrast the demands of effectiveness from different perspectives

Scenario You are a member of an area prescribing committee (APC) which is reviewing the treatment options for a cancer which is universally rapidly fatal (usually within months) if not treated. For the purposes of this cases study, please assume the following:

 There is good evidence supporting the effectiveness of three medicines (A, B and C) in improving health outcomes.

 The treatments are mutually exclusive: there is no evidence that patients are better off switching from one to another.

 Effectiveness does not depend on patient or disease characteristics.

 All costs fall within the first year of treatment.

 Costs vary only according to the drug selected, since staff time, etc. are fixed and are the same requirements for each treatment.

 The annual budget available for commissioning treatment is US$500,000.

 The incidence of this cancer in the area covered by your APC is 1,000 new cases each year.

The health economic data are summarized below:

Treatment

A

B

C

Life-Year Gained

A. 0.3

B. 0.6

C. 0.5

Health Utility Index (in each year)

A. 0.8

B. 0.6

C. 0.5

Cost (per patient) A (current practice)

A. $500

B. $1000

C. $800

Question 1: Given the available budget of $500,000 per year, how many people could be treated with each option? Please show your calculation and explain briefly about why the current practice is Treatment A. (20%)

Question 2: Measuring the cost-effectiveness by the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER), compared with the current practice, which treatment (B or C) is more cost-effective for a hospital use? Please show your calculation and explain briefly. (20%)

Question 3: From a patient perspective, which treatment is the most effective by considering the quality of life? Please show your calculation and explain briefly. (20%)

Question 4: From a society perspective, which treatment generates the greatest health gains given the funds available? Please show your calculation and explain briefly. (20%)

Question 5: Which treatment would you recommend to the area prescribing committee (APC): A, B or C? Please discuss your choice from perspectives of equity, efficiency and effectiveness. (20%)

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer to Q.1

Annual Budget US$ 500,000

Treatment A : - Cost per patient = $ 500

No. of. people that can be treated = $500,000/ $500 = 1000 people

Treatment B :- Cost per patient = $ 1000

No.of. people that can be treated = $500,000/$1000 = 500 people

Treatment C :- Cost per patient = $ 800

No.of. people that can be treated = $500,000/$800 = 625 people.

The current practice is treatment A for the following reasons

(a) It covers all the patients within the budget available.

(b) Treatment A has the lowest cost/QALY per patient. QALY is the quality-adjusted life- year.QALY is arrived at by multiplying the Life Years gained (LGY) and the Health utility Index (HUI). For Treatment A QALY = 0.3 x 0.8=0.24.Therefore COST/QALY per patient = $500/0.24 which is the least among the 3 treatments.

Answer to Q.2

Incremental Cost Effectiveness Ratio (ICER) = (C1-C0)/(E1-E0) where C1 are the costs for the group which requires the new treatment or intervention and CO is costs for the group which is given the existing treatment or the control group. E1 and E0 are the health effects or the QALY for the respective groups

QALY for Treatment B is LYG x HUI = 0.6 x 0.6 =0.36

QALY for Treatment B = 0.5 x 0.5 = 0.25

ICER for Treatment B compared to A = (1000-500)/(0.36-0.24) = $ 4166.67

ICER for Treatment C compared to A = (800-500)/(0.25-0.24) = $ 30,000

Hence Treatment B is more effective when compared to Treatment C from a cost effective perspective.

Answer to Q.3

Considering the quality of life from a patient perpective as measured by QALY, Treatment B is the most effective, which scores 0.36 as compared to 0.24 for Treatment B and 0.25 for Treatment C

Answer to Q.4

From a society perspective Treatment A generates the greatest health gains.

No.of people treated multiplied by the QALY index

Treatment A = 1000 x 0.24 = 240

Treatment B = 500 x 0.36 = 180

Treatment C = 625 x 0.25 =156.25

Answer to Q.5

I would recommend Treatment A to the Area Prescribing committee (APC) , as it is the best option available given the budget constraints and is the best option from the perspective of equity, efficiency and effectiveness given the constraints.


Related Solutions

Case study: Deciding what is effective from different perspectives The aim of this case study is...
Case study: Deciding what is effective from different perspectives The aim of this case study is to illustrate the sometimes competing demands of effectiveness, efficiency and equity. In particular, it should help you to: Explain what is meant by key terms such as ‘LYG’, ‘QALY’ and ‘ICER’ Use these terms and the information they represent in a decision-making scenario ?        Compare and contrast the demands of effectiveness from different perspectives Scenario You are a member of an area prescribing...
List examples how you would compare efficiency and effectiveness. Illustrate how you would show high efficiency...
List examples how you would compare efficiency and effectiveness. Illustrate how you would show high efficiency and high effectiveness.
From the case study and discussion preparation study, evaluate the effectiveness of laws on smoking in...
From the case study and discussion preparation study, evaluate the effectiveness of laws on smoking in your home state. Determine if your state’s standpoint on smokerfree bars is adequate, in your opinion. Provide support for your rationale.   
Review the case study " The merger of Two Competing Hospitals" . The merger phenomenon has...
Review the case study " The merger of Two Competing Hospitals" . The merger phenomenon has been widely observed in the hospital, pharmaceutical and airline in the past decade. If you are the healthcare consultant facilitating the merger between Portor Regional Medical Center (PRMC) and Banner Regional Medical Center (BRMC), what three strategic issues that you would focus on and offer guidance. Include appropriate rationale for your choices and discuss how you would address them to the satisfaction of the...
The aim of risk assessment in auditing standards is to improve the quantity and effectiveness of...
The aim of risk assessment in auditing standards is to improve the quantity and effectiveness of audits by substantially changing the audit practice” (Ramos, 2009). Statements on auditing standards nos. 104-111 provide increased rigor to the audit process in a number of key areas, including the assessments of inherent and control risks and the linking of these risk assessments to further audit procedures. Please explain in at least 2 paraghraphs and INCLUDE references. Thank you!
EVALUATING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF REVENUE MOBILIZATION STRATEGIES OF MMDAs IN GHANA. A CASE STUDY OF THE...
EVALUATING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF REVENUE MOBILIZATION STRATEGIES OF MMDAs IN GHANA. A CASE STUDY OF THE TALENSI DISTRICT ASSEMBLY.
Evaluate the relevance or irrelevance to efficiency and effectiveness
Evaluate the relevance or irrelevance to efficiency and effectiveness
In the case study of John Endler on Poecilia reticulata where he demonstrated the effectiveness of...
In the case study of John Endler on Poecilia reticulata where he demonstrated the effectiveness of natural selection on wild guppies. What is the relationship between sexual selection and natural selection (predators) in guppies? Explain how they are linked together* (detail explanation please in clear hand writing )
Case study: Keeping Your Eye on the Ball We sometimes read a newspaper or magazine or...
Case study: Keeping Your Eye on the Ball We sometimes read a newspaper or magazine or listen to a news report and hear about the downfall of U.S. manufacturing and how many people are losing their jobs in manufacturing plants. It sounds depressing but the question is, “Has the United States really fallen that far behind other countries in manufacturing capability?” The answer is no, and this video is meant to highlight just one example of a successful manufacturing company....
What is efficiency, effectiveness and equity in public administration?
What is efficiency, effectiveness and equity in public administration?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT