What is the major significance of the “Byrd Rule” to tax legislation?

Expert Solution

The Byrd Rule restricts what can be included in reconciliation legislation in the Senate. At its core, the rule prohibits provisions that are viewed as “extraneous” to the budget. The Byrd Rule therefore prevents a reconciliation bill from containing non-budgetary provisions that supporters might otherwise wish to have an easier path to passage.

Under the Byrd Rule, a provision is considered extraneous if it:

1)Does not produce a change in outlays or revenues
2)Increases the deficit beyond the “budget window”
3 )Makes changes to Social Security

It is because of the Byrd Rule that legislation to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act (ACA) has not included purely regulatory changes to insurance markets that the ACA ushered in; such provisions would violate the Byrd Rule’s prohibition of non-budgetary provisions. The Byrd Rule has also led Congress to pass legislation that “sunsets” or expires within 10 years, in order to avoid the prohibition against increasing deficits beyond the budget window. The 2001 tax cuts are an example of when the Byrd rule drove the inclusion of this type of sunset in legislation.

ekkarill92 answered 2 years ago

The Republicans are preparing to pass major legislation – the Tax Cut and Jobs Act –...

The Republicans are preparing to pass major legislation – the Tax Cut and Jobs Act – that they say will boost the growth rate for the U.S. economy from ~ 2 percent to ~4 percent. Republicans claim that the tax cuts will “pay for themselves” because all of that growth will mean higher tax revenue even as tax rates come down. Many economists argue that this is based on flawed “trickle-down” economics that comes from a belief in the Laffer...

What are the major positives that you see in the PPACA legislation? What are the major...

What are the major positives that you see in the PPACA legislation? What are the major negatives that you see in the PPACA legislation? Provide rationale for your answer.

What allowance in tax legislation is there for businesses that are managed on behalf of a...

What allowance in tax legislation is there for businesses that are managed on behalf of a trust? Discuss in 80 to 100 words.

What are tax preferences and tax expenditures? What are the major justifications for tax preferences? What...

What are tax preferences and tax expenditures? What are the major justifications for tax preferences? What are the economic consequences of tax preferences? How can tax expenditures be used to evaluate the desirability of tax preferences? Why do tax expenditures overestimate the gains in revenue that would come about from eliminating tax preferences? Explain how tax preferences distort prices and cause losses in market efficiency.

Note: This problem is for the 2019 tax year. Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are...

Note: This problem is for the 2019 tax year. Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are married taxpayers who file a joint return. Their Social Security numbers are 123-45-6784 and 111-11-1113, respectively. Alice's birthday is September 21, 1972, and Bruce's is June 27, 1971. They live at 473 Revere Avenue, Lowell, MA 01850. Alice is the office manager for Lowell Dental Clinic, 433 Broad Street, Lowell, MA 01850 (Employer Identification Number 98-7654321). Bruce is the manager of a Super Burgers...

PCAOB Rules Rule 3520—Auditor Independence Rule 3521—Contingent Fees Rule 3522—Tax Transactions Rule 3523—Tax Services for Persons...

PCAOB Rules Rule 3520—Auditor Independence Rule 3521—Contingent Fees Rule 3522—Tax Transactions Rule 3523—Tax Services for Persons in Financial Reporting Oversight Roles Rule 3526 establishes guidelines when an accounting firm should discuss with the audit committee of the client information with respect to any relationships between the firm and the entity that might bear on auditor independence. Under the rule, a registered public accounting firm must do the following: Page 252 Prior to accepting an initial engagement, pursuant to the standards...

Tax Legislation Discuss the implications of the tax cuts and jobs of 2017 in reference to...

Tax Legislation Discuss the implications of the tax cuts and jobs of 2017 in reference to individuals, corporations, estates and trust. Make a concerted effort to highlight the critical elements that constitutes this new legislation.

What is the tax significance of the face amount of a life insurance policy? A. The...

What is the tax significance of the face amount of a life insurance policy? A. The face amount of life insurance is excluded from the gross income of a beneficiary if the amount is paid upon the death of the insured and the beneficiary is any corporation. B. The face amount of life insurance is included in the gross income of a beneficiary if the amount is paid prior to death of the insured. If the amount paid exceeds the...

What are the major provisions of the privacy rule in the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability...

What are the major provisions of the privacy rule in the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996? Define and describe the components of the Obamacare legislation and how the law treats U.S. citizens of varying ages.

Please complete the 2019 federal income tax return for Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd. Alice...

Please complete the 2019 federal income tax return for Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd. Alice J. and Bruce M. Byrd are married taxpayers who file a joint return. Their Social Security numbers are 123-45-6784 and 111-11-1113, respectively. Alice’s birthday is September 21, 1971, and Bruce’s is June 27, 1970. They live at 473 Revere Avenue, Lowell, MA 01850. Alice is the office manager for Lowell Dental Clinic, 433 Broad Street, Lowell, MA 01850 (employer identification number 98-7654321). Bruce is...

Question