Question

In: Statistics and Probability

Explain in full how you will use a dummy variable regression to test for a structural...

Explain in full how you will use a dummy variable regression to test for a structural break. Also discuss the advantages of using a dummy variable regression over the Chow test when testing for structural break in data.

Solutions

Expert Solution

I will explain you with a small example , go through the below content carefully.

How do we find out that a structural change has in fact occurred? To answer this question, we consider the GDP of Ethiopia (measured on constant 2010 US$) over the period of 1981 to 2015. Like many other countries in the world, Ethiopia has adopted the policy of regulated globalization during the early nineties of the last century. So, our aim is to whether the GDP of Ethiopia has undergone any structural changes following the major policy shift due to adoption of globalization policy. To answer this question, we have two options in statistical and econometric research. The most important classes of tests on structural change are the tests from the generalized fluctuation test framework on the one hand and tests based on F statistic on the other. The first class includes in particular the CUSUM and MOSUM tests and the fluctuation test, while the Chow and the supF test belong to the latter. A topic that gained more interest rather recently is to monitor structural change, i.e., to start after a history phase (without structural changes) to analyze new observations and to be able to detect a structural change as soon after its occurrence as possible.

Let us divide the whole study period in two sub-periods

1. pre-globalization (1981 – 1991)
2. post-globalization (1992-2015)

The regression for the whole period assumes that there is no difference between the two time periods and, therefore, estimates the GDP growth rate for the entire time period. In other words, this regression assumes that the intercept, as well as the slope coefficient, remains the same over the entire period; that is, there is no structural change. If this is, in fact, the situation, then

The first two regression lines assume that the regression parameters are different in two sub-period periods, that is, there is structural instability either because of changes in slope parameters or intercept parameters.

Solution by Chow:

To apply Chow test to visualize the structural changes empirically, the following assumptions are required:

i. The error terms for the two sub-period regressions are normally distributed with the same variance;
ii. The two error terms are independently distributed.
iii. The break-point at which the structural stability to be examined should be known apriori.

The Chow test examines the following set of hypotheses:

Steps in Chow test

Step 1: Estimate third regression assuming that there is no parameter instability, and obtain the Residual Sum Squares


So, in present case k=2, as there are two parameters (intercept term and slope coefficient).

We call this Restricted Residual Sum Squares as it assumes the restriction of structural stability, that is, β01=β02=β0   and   β11=β12=β1β01=β02=β0   and   β11=β12=β1

Step 2: Estimate the first and second regressions assuming that there is parameter instability and obtain the respective Residual Sum Squares as

Step 3: As the two sets of samples supposed to be independent, we can add "RSS_1" and "RSS_2" and the resultant Residual Sum Squares may be called the Unrestricted Residual Sum of Squares, that is,

Under the assumption of true null hypothesis, this follows F-distribution.

Now if this F-test is significant, we can reject the null hypothesis of no structural instability and conclude that the fluctuations is the GGP is high enough to believe that it leads to structural instability in the GDP growth path.

Advantages of using a dummy variable regression over the Chow test when testing for structural break in data.

The benefit of this approach is that we do not lose any degrees of freedom through a loss of observations.the benefit of this approach is that we do not lose any degrees of freedom through a loss of observations.

If there is evidence of a structural break, it may mean we need to split the data into 2 samples and run separate regressions


Related Solutions

In this problem, you will create and use a dummy variable and the regression procedure to...
In this problem, you will create and use a dummy variable and the regression procedure to test the hypothesis of independence of two variables. The data in tab 17 (Waiting time) in DS6 represent the time spent waiting in the ER prior to being seen for two groups of patients. One group of patients had true emergencies; the second group had conditions requiring urgent medical attention. Using these data, do the following: 1. Rearrange the data so they can be...
1. Describe how one can test for structural breaks using (i) the dummy variable method and...
1. Describe how one can test for structural breaks using (i) the dummy variable method and (ii) the Chow test.
1-what is the dummy variable and what is the purpose of included in regression model ?...
1-what is the dummy variable and what is the purpose of included in regression model ? 2- explaining the meaning of adjust r square? 3-if adjust r square computed. would it be higher , equal of lower than value of r square?
How do you interpret coefficients if the dependent variable is a dummy variable? (e.g. what would...
How do you interpret coefficients if the dependent variable is a dummy variable? (e.g. what would the coefficients for "income," "years of education," or "height" mean if the dependent variable was the dummy variable, "Famous?"? 2. Suppose you applied a scalar to a variable. Then you used both the original variable and the scaled variable as explanatory variables. What would happen and why?
Explain why you choose multiple regression with dummy variables but not linear trend model and why...
Explain why you choose multiple regression with dummy variables but not linear trend model and why do you believe this technique is appropriate to forecast your data?
A regression analysis of college faculty salaries included several predictors, including a dummy variable for gender...
A regression analysis of college faculty salaries included several predictors, including a dummy variable for gender (male = 1) and a dummy variable for race (nonwhite = 1). Assume gender takes on the values male and female, and race takes on the values nonwhite and white. For annual income measured in thousands of dollars, the estimated coefficients were 0.76 for gender and 0.62 for race. At particular settings of the other predictors, the estimated mean salary for white females was...
b) Use a multiple regression model with dummy variables as follows to develop an equation to...
b) Use a multiple regression model with dummy variables as follows to develop an equation to account for seasonal effects in the data: Qtr1 = 1 if Quarter 1, 0 otherwise; Qtr2 = 1 if Quarter 2, 0 otherwise; Qtr3 = 1 if Quarter 3, 0 otherwise. If required, round your answers to three decimal places. For subtractive or negative numbers use a minus sign even if there is a + sign before the blank (Example: -300). If the constant...
Regression model: Population=f(GDP,GNI,PPI,policy) How to collect data for dummy variable( policy )and determine its influence on...
Regression model: Population=f(GDP,GNI,PPI,policy) How to collect data for dummy variable( policy )and determine its influence on population?
What is a dummy variable? If we use one on the right-hand side of the equation...
What is a dummy variable? If we use one on the right-hand side of the equation in a multivariate analysis, what are the implications for interpreting the constant?  What is multicollinearity? How do we know if we have it in our models? How do we correct for it if we do?  What is hetereskedasticity? Should we really be concerned about it? Why or why not?
Give an example of omitted variable bias in a multiple linear regression model. Explain how you...
Give an example of omitted variable bias in a multiple linear regression model. Explain how you would figure out the probable direction of the bias even without collecting data on this omitted variable. [3 marks]
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT