Question

In: Physics

(a) Why does the heat equation imply infinite propagation speed? (b) This is clearly nonphysical. Nevertheless...

(a) Why does the heat equation imply infinite propagation speed?

(b) This is clearly nonphysical. Nevertheless the heat equation is widely used. Why is the infinite propagation speed not a problem?

Solutions

Expert Solution

b): While an infinite speed of propagation is very non physical,
it can be rationalized by claiming that to a reasonable degree of approximation, the value of
u is zero outside a bounded set so for practical purposes, the speed of propagation is
finite.
The two properties of instantaneous smoothing of the data and infinite speed of
propagation are characteristic of solutions of the heat equation and could be referred to as
”diffusionlike evolution” . These properties are, in fact, characteristic of solutions of a
large class of partial differential equations called parabolic equations. It is generally the
case that properties that pertain to solutions of the heat equation are true for solutions to all
parabolic equations.


Related Solutions

The general equation for propagation of uncertainty for independent variables is given in Appendix B-1 of...
The general equation for propagation of uncertainty for independent variables is given in Appendix B-1 of the text (equation B-1). Consider the function F = 5x3 + 4xy, where x = 2.00 ± 0.01 and y = 3.00 ± 0.02, and x and y are independent variables. Calculate F including its uncertainty. Calculate the uncertainty in F using equation B-1 by deriving the equations for the partial derivatives and then evaluating the derivatives for the values of x and y...
Why does the definition of a pure public good imply that its benefits are not subject...
Why does the definition of a pure public good imply that its benefits are not subject to congestion?
WHAT IS CONVERGENCE BETWEEN COUNTRIES? WHY DOES THE STANDARD SOLOW MODEL IMPLY CONVERGENCE? WHAT DOES IS...
WHAT IS CONVERGENCE BETWEEN COUNTRIES? WHY DOES THE STANDARD SOLOW MODEL IMPLY CONVERGENCE? WHAT DOES IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CONDITINSL SND INCONDITIONSL CONVERGENCE?
In the novel how the markets fail by John Cassidy, Why does efficient markets imply that...
In the novel how the markets fail by John Cassidy, Why does efficient markets imply that stock returns will follow a normal distribution?
3. Frequency and wavelength are both in your equation for speed. Why is it that, when...
3. Frequency and wavelength are both in your equation for speed. Why is it that, when you changed the frequency, you did not change the speed of the wave?
1. Define the ff: A. Heat- B. Heat capacity- 2. Why is it desirable to have...
1. Define the ff: A. Heat- B. Heat capacity- 2. Why is it desirable to have the water a few degrees colder than room temperature when the initial temperature is taken? 3. Why is the mass of the outer shell of the calorimeter and the insulating ring not included in taking data for Calorimetry? 6. Why should the hot metal be dry before it is introduced into the cold water? 837 calories of heat are required to heat 100.00 grams...
2. The Drake Equation: (a) What, exactly, does the Drake Equation estimate? (b) If you are...
2. The Drake Equation: (a) What, exactly, does the Drake Equation estimate? (b) If you are like Frank Drake or Carl Sagan, you are an optimist who believes that the development of life, intelligence, and technological civilizations are not "vanishingly small", but are typical. That is, that what happened on earth is not rare. Explain them why Drake and Sagan would say that "N=L" is a good approximation to the Drake Equation.  
why does full employment imply an unemployment rate greater than zero? discuss your answer in the...
why does full employment imply an unemployment rate greater than zero? discuss your answer in the teems of the types of unemployment
Why does tension not appear in the universal wave equation?
Why does tension not appear in the universal wave equation?
what does native immigrant complementarity imply about the wage impacts of immigration? Why might complementarities arise?
what does native immigrant complementarity imply about the wage impacts of immigration? Why might complementarities arise?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT