Question

In: Economics

How does the legislative process differ in the Senate and the House? What if you served...

How does the legislative process differ in the Senate and the House? What if you served in Congress--would you favor the instructed-delegate model or the trustee model of representation? Why? ( 150 words minimum)

Solutions

Expert Solution

The United States Congress consists of two legislative bodies, the House of Representatives and the Senate. There are many similarities between these institutions. Representatives and Senators are directly elected by the public. Passing legislation requires the agreement of both the House and Senate.

House initiates all revenue bills and articles of impeachment. Whereas Senate gives "advice and consent" to allmajor treaties & other presidential appointments and also tries impeached officials

The House and Senate might have the option to agree by a trade of changes between the houses. Each house has one occasion to alter the alterations from the other house, so there can be Senate revisions to House changes to Senate corrections to a House bill. House revisions to Senate bills or changes are advantaged for thought on the Senate floor; Senate corrections to House bills or changes by and large are not advantaged for thought on the House floor. Practically speaking, the House frequently discards corrections between the houses under the conditions of a unique standard detailed by the Rules Committee. The Senate in some cases discards House corrections by consistent assent, yet the systems related with the trading of changes can get muddled.

Then again, the House and Senate can each differ to the situation of the other on a bill and at that point consent to make a meeting council to propose a bundle settlement of all their differences. Most conferees are drawn from the standing councils that had considered the bill at first. The House or Senate may cast a ballot to teach its conferees before they are selected, however such guidelines are not official.

Conferees by and large are allowed to haggle in the manners they pick, however in the end their arrangement must be affirmed by a greater part of the House conferees and a lion's share of the Senate conferees. The conferees are relied upon to address just the issues on which the House and Senate have oppose this idea. They likewise are relied upon to determine every contradiction inside the extent of the contrasts between the House and Senate positions. On the off chance that the conferees can't agree on a change, or if their understanding surpasses their position, they may report that revision as a correction in evident or specialized difference.

On the House and Senate floors, meeting reports are special and easy to refute, however they are most certainly not amendable. The Senate has a method to strike out bits of the meeting arrangement that are thought of, under Senate rules, to be "out of extension material" or "new coordinated spending arrangements." The House likewise has an exceptional method for casting a ballot to dismiss meeting report arrangements that would not have been relevant to the bill in the House. Subsequent to consenting to a gathering report, the House or Senate can discard any outstanding changes in contradiction. Just when the House and Senate have agreed on all arrangements of the bill would it be able to be selected for introduction to the President

While the House utilizes four schedules (Union, House, Private, Discharge), the Senate as it were utilizes two schedules (Legislative and Executive). The House's arrangement of unique days for thinking about particular kinds of measures (e.g., "Area Days") has no identical in the Senate. In settling on booking choices, the Speaker commonly counsels just with lion's share party pioneers what's more, chosen Representatives though the Senate Majority Leader consults extensively with minority party pioneers and intrigued Senators. The Speaker's double situation as head of the lion's share party also, the House's directing official gives him more position to oversee floor procedures than the Senate's directing official. While banter time is constantly limited in the House, person Congresspersons for the most part reserve the option to boundless discussion.

Most noncontroversial measures are affirmed by "suspension of the standards" in the House, and by consistent assent in the Senate. Floor thought of significant bills is by and large administered by "exceptional standards" in the House, and by "complex consistent assent arrangements" in the Senate. The House normally meets in the Committee of the Whole to think about significant enactment; no such board exists in the Senate. The House considers and corrects enactment in a more organized way (e.g., by area or title) than the Senate. Moreover, while pertinence of changes is needed in the House, it is commanded distinctly in four occasions in the Senate. Rollcall votes can be mentioned at practically any time in the Senate, yet simply subsequent to finishing a voice or division vote in the House.

Since the Senate regularly breaks as opposed to dismissing toward the day's end, Senate authoritative days can proceed for a few schedule days. Conversely, the House regularly dismisses toward the end of each administrative day

A trustee model refers to a situation where people in a particular constituency choose their representative in parliament. It is a model of representative. The people entrust the person they choose with the duty of making significant decisions on their behalf.

As such, the representative acts as the trustee of the people in all their matters at both the local and national scene. He/she has a significant measure of autonomy. The elected trustee has the duty of deliberating and making decisions for the greater interest of the people while still putting the national interest first

the delegate model of representation is understood as parallel to the trustee model of representation. While it gives the trustee all the rights and the powers to make the decisions on behalf of the people, delegation sees the representative as the mouthpiece of the people.

He has no right or power to decide on his own volition. As such, this, unlike the trustee model, is a representative democracy. In this model of representation, the people only elect the delegate to represent their constituencies in the parliament


Related Solutions

Party Politics Affect on Legislative Process How does party politics affect the legislative process? What branch...
Party Politics Affect on Legislative Process How does party politics affect the legislative process? What branch is the most powerful? how/why?
There are more representatives in the House than the Senate. What is one way this difference...
There are more representatives in the House than the Senate. What is one way this difference influences representation in the House? The members in the House of Representatives tend to be older. The members in the House of Representatives are more deliberative. The members in the House of Representatives act more like trustees. The members in the House of Representatives are more organized by party.
Why is the consumer decision making process important to retailing? How does this process differ in...
Why is the consumer decision making process important to retailing? How does this process differ in comparison to other industries?
what is the mechanism for making n-glycosidic bond into deoxy Thymadine? how does this process differ...
what is the mechanism for making n-glycosidic bond into deoxy Thymadine? how does this process differ from what can or does occur in solution?
How does the valuing of a real asset (such as a building) differ from the process...
How does the valuing of a real asset (such as a building) differ from the process of valuing a financial asset (such as a stock or bond)? Integrate Bible passages into the discussion that addresses the Christian worldview.
How does glass transition temperature relate to manufacturing process/ temperature? How does this manufacture then differ...
How does glass transition temperature relate to manufacturing process/ temperature? How does this manufacture then differ between crystalline vs. amorpohous structure? How does linear vs. nonlinear polymer effect the glass transition temperature?
what is the role of an executive and legislative branch in the budget process for a...
what is the role of an executive and legislative branch in the budget process for a correctional facility? What is the role of a prison director ? Please cite sources using scholarly journals or peer reviewed sources.
Defense Bugeting. What are some problems that appear with the house or senate armed services committee...
Defense Bugeting. What are some problems that appear with the house or senate armed services committee agenda? Thanks
2.How does the process of organizational purchasing (b2b) between entrepreneurs differ from the purchase process of...
2.How does the process of organizational purchasing (b2b) between entrepreneurs differ from the purchase process of the client or end user?
How do picornaviruses achieve cell entry and how does this process differ from that used by...
How do picornaviruses achieve cell entry and how does this process differ from that used by enveloped viruses? What checkpoints are involved in the process? What are the roles of the “canyon” and the pocket factor?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT