Question

In: Physics

Could any form of matter teleportation every really happen? If so, what form would it take?...

Could any form of matter teleportation every really happen?

If so, what form would it take? Some science-fiction talks about literally sending the atoms from one location to another; others talk of creating a duplicate and destroying the original.

Question originally added here.

Update: there are a couple of comments asking me to specify what I mean by teleportation. I'm talking about stuff of Star Trek - taking an object or person and transporting them almost instantly across great distances (thousands of KMs) by:

  1. breaking them up at the atomic (or smaller) level
  2. transporting those atomic components (or the information, "recipe" to recreate) and
  3. (re-)assembling at the new location.

Solutions

Expert Solution

I don't think it's possible in the way you mean it:

Option 1

Decompose, move, rebuild

Decomposition is possible as long as we can consider the matter classical. If any quantum state is relevant, it will be automatically destroyed in the process of measuring the state of each atom in order to be able to rebuild later. This will lead to a large increase in entropy (which is relevant in the last step).

The movement of a stream of atoms is possible, but not simple at all, especially if you need to focus it in a spot. The energy required, though is probably very similar to the energy required to transport the matter classically.

Rebuilding is possible (given enough technology, that is), but it would be enormously expensive in terms of energy because of the need of reversing the increase of entropy in the first step, locally.

All in all, it's probably possible, but much more expensive in terms of energy than simply moving the body, so it's not clear to me how useful it would be.

Also, were the matter being transported a living being, there are a number of ethical questions involved: would the person rebuilt be still the same person as the one killed by the first step of the process?

Option 2

Use quantum teleportation

This, as far as I know, requires a quantum entanglement between the mass and a perfect copy of the mass. Although this is probably possible for simple systems, I am not really sure it represents the kind of teleportation you are looking for. It's a teleportation of quantum states, not of matter.

Option 3

Abuse Quantum Mechanics

This is far off, and there's nothing suggesting that it's possible, but if we found a way of interfering radically with the probabilities of quantum mechanical measurements, we could leverage the indeterminacy in the body's position to make it move. It really depends on us understanding better how the wave function actually collapses.

Option 4

Abuse General Relativity

This is also far off, but if we were to open a stable wormhole between two positions then it should be possible to step from one place to another instantly. This merely requires using currently unknown forms of exotic matter to generate the holes, because all the wormholes that we know of, in GR, are actually of really small diameter and also apparently a not very healthy place to be because of extreme gravity, radiation and so on.


Related Solutions

I'm trying to understand what would really happen when large quantities (e.g., 10g) of anti-matter collide...
I'm trying to understand what would really happen when large quantities (e.g., 10g) of anti-matter collide with matter. The normal response is that they'd annihilate each other and generate an expanding sphere of gamma ray photons. However, thinking about it in more detail, what I see is that the anti-electrons annihilate first against the electrons. Let's assume the energy release in that case is not sufficient to noticeably change the momentum of the projectile. Then the nuclei penetrate the electron-annihilation...
What would happen if the spindle fibers did not form during mitosis?
What would happen if the spindle fibers did not form during mitosis?
What would happen if the government set a ceiling on the price of gas? What could...
What would happen if the government set a ceiling on the price of gas? What could change in supply and demand, would you end up better off since the price is low, or would you end up without any gas because there is a shortage? Would it be feasible to think that doing so would lead to black markets?
What would happen if the follicle could not produce Theca cells? 1) Ovulation would not occur....
What would happen if the follicle could not produce Theca cells? 1) Ovulation would not occur. 2) Granulosa cells would not be able to produce androstenedione. 3) FSH would no longer be able to signal to granulosa cells. 4) All of the above. Which of the following is TRUE? 1) Fatty acids released in response to increased levels of glucagon can be used as an alternative fuel source for muscles. 2) Cell membranes are very permeable to glucose, making it...
Why would a company really care about maintaining an ethical work environment? What might happen in...
Why would a company really care about maintaining an ethical work environment? What might happen in a company if there is an ethics breach?
Possible Duplicate: Why does every thing spin? So why would the Earth, or any planet for...
Possible Duplicate: Why does every thing spin? So why would the Earth, or any planet for that matter, rotate along an axis? I know of no force which could come into play here, so i assume it just started off with an initial rotation. But where did this rotational energy come from? And are there any known planets which do not rotate? Assuming no force accounts for earth's rotation, would it be true that the angular velocity of the earth...
If using a cotransporter for movement of two molecules, what would happen if one molecule could...
If using a cotransporter for movement of two molecules, what would happen if one molecule could no longer bind to the transporter?
The “equilibrium” in hydrostatic equilibruim can be understood by imagining what would happen if we could...
The “equilibrium” in hydrostatic equilibruim can be understood by imagining what would happen if we could somehow squeeze the Sun (add an outer layer to increase mass). Choose the correct sequence of events if we could right now add mass to the Sun: a) The core would heat up, leading to higher nuclear reaction rates, higher core pressures, and expansion of the core. b) The Sun would shrink to become a brown dwarf, with higher nuclear reations rates and lower...
Can hyperinflation happen in the United States? If so, what would be the likely scenario playing...
Can hyperinflation happen in the United States? If so, what would be the likely scenario playing out first before hyperinflation takes off?
What would happen to the activity of cdc2 kinase if the cdc25 phosphatase were mutated so...
What would happen to the activity of cdc2 kinase if the cdc25 phosphatase were mutated so that it was permanently inactivated?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT