Under what circumstances will the net benefit-cost ratio give you a different recommendation about the choice...

Under what circumstances will the net benefit-cost ratio give you a different recommendation about the choice of projects as compared to the recommendation you get using the net present value criterion?

Expert Solution

In general Practice, NPV and benefit cost ratio provides the same results but in the situation of capital rationing when there is limitation of available funds, and investment opportunities are more, then the best possible projects with capital limit are selected. So in case of Capital rationing and specially in case of indivisible projects, benefit cost ratio and NPV give contradictory results, because project with highest NPV would be left out if available funds are less than the required fund for project. So in case of capital rationing and indivisible project NPV and benefit cost ratio will offer inconsistent results. In this situation, profitability index gives results inconsistent with the maximization of shareholder wealth and it should not be used. Indeed, the concept of capital rationing gives results inconsistent with the maximization of shareholder wealth. It is hard to believe that a firm with positive NPV projects can not go out.

jeff jeffy answered 2 years ago

Under what circumstances might it be more appropriate to use the net asset value method? Give...

Under what circumstances might it be more appropriate to use the net asset value method? Give one example.

Policy A has a higher-cost effectiveness ratio than policy B. a. Under what circumstances (if any)...

Policy A has a higher-cost effectiveness ratio than policy B. a. Under what circumstances (if any) would you recommend implementation of policy A? Explain. b. Under what circumstances (if any) would you recommend implementation of policy B? Explain. c. Under what circumstances (if any) would you recommend implementation of both policies? Explain. d. Under what circumstances (if any) would you recommend implementation of neither policy? Explain.

between net present value rule used in cost benefit analysis and benefit-ratio used in cost-effectiveness analysis....

between net present value rule used in cost benefit analysis and benefit-ratio used in cost-effectiveness analysis. Why do most economists choose net present value rule? fix ：“benefit ratio ” is “benefit-cost ratio”

Is sampling always necessary? Discuss under what circumstances it is necessary and under what circumstances it...

Is sampling always necessary? Discuss under what circumstances it is necessary and under what circumstances it would not be.

Benefit-Cost Analysis Given Parameters: Scenario One Benefit-Cost Ratio: 1.11 Scenario Two Benefit-Cost Ratio: 0.52 Did your...

Benefit-Cost Analysis Given Parameters: Scenario One Benefit-Cost Ratio: 1.11 Scenario Two Benefit-Cost Ratio: 0.52 Did your benefit-cost analysis reach the same or different conclusions in the two scenarios analyzed? If different conclusions, why? Assume that the proposal in fact “passed” the analysis with a benefit-cost ratio greater than 1. Does this imply that the proposed project is the optimal or best use for the $8.55 million to be invested in resource conservation? Explain. In conducting benefit-cost analyses, do you think...

Explain under what circumstances a net operating loss of a partnership can be carried over and...

Explain under what circumstances a net operating loss of a partnership can be carried over and applied against income of a partner even after the 20-year carryover period provided for net operating loss carryovers has expired.

In 300 words, Under what circumstances would it be appropriate for a firm to use different...

In 300 words, Under what circumstances would it be appropriate for a firm to use different costs of capital for its different operating divisions? If the overall firm WACC were used as a hurdle rate for all divisions, would the riskier divisions or the more conservative divisions tend to get most of the investment projects? Why? If you were to try to estimate the appropriate cost of capital for different divisions, what problems might you encounter? What are the two...

How does a court order to discharge debts benefit the debtor? Under what circumstances do courts...

How does a court order to discharge debts benefit the debtor? Under what circumstances do courts grant a discharge?

Hi, Can you please solve this correctly? With interest at 10%, what is the benefit-cost ratio...

Hi, Can you please solve this correctly? With interest at 10%, what is the benefit-cost ratio for this government project? Initial Cost $205454 Additional costs at the end of year 1 and year 2 $34758/year Benefits at end of year 1 and year 2 $0/year Annual benefits at end of year 3 through year 10 $103447/year Enter your answer as follow: 12.34

Under what circumstances would you make public criticisms about your fellow employees or place of employment?...

Under what circumstances would you make public criticisms about your fellow employees or place of employment? What is your justification?

Question