Question

In: Finance

Evaluate and provide two (2) main reasons with evidence which cause the failure/success of the merger...

Evaluate and provide two (2) main reasons with evidence which cause the failure/success of the merger and acquisition.

by using this article "Bristol-Myers Squibb’s $74 billion acquisition of Celgene would combine two troubled companies"

Solutions

Expert Solution

POSSIBLE REASONS FOR FAILURE OF MERGER (bristol myers and celgene)

1. SHAREHOLDER CONSENT

Many investors could be unhappy because this deal values Celgene below where it was trading between 2015 and 2018. But it's not Celgene investors who are balking. Instead, it's Bristol-Myers Squibb shareholders rallying for this merger to fall apart.

The biggest opponent is Boston-based Wellington, a money manager with $1 trillion in assets under management and a 7.7% stake in Bristol-Myers Squibb. In a statement, Wellington said it opposes the tie-up because:

  • The transaction asks BMY shareholders to accept too much risk, and the terms offer BMY shares to CELG shareholders at a price well below implied asset value;
  • Execution success could be more difficult to achieve than depicted by company management; and
  • Alternative paths to create value for BMY shareholders could be more attractive.

Wellington's not alone. Bristol-Myers' fifth-largest shareholder, Dodge & Cox, isn't pleased, either, according to Reuters. Also, Starboard Value, an activist investor, plans to vote its 1 million shares against the merger when votes are tallied on April 12. Not only does Starboard Value believe the merger is "ill advised," it's advocating for Bristol-Myers Squibb to scuttle the deal and put itself up for sale instead. In a letter to Bristol-Myers' board and investors, it went as far as to suggest that the merger was "hastily construed' to potentially thwart advances from a suitor.

2. DEAL VALUATION

If more Bristol-Myers shareholders side with Wellington, then this merger could fall apart. If it does, then Celgene's shares could tumble and Bristol-Myers shares could rise on hopes it will wind up becoming an acquisition target.

Any dip in Celgene shares, however, could be short-lived. Celgene has a slate of market-moving news coming, including its refiling of ozanimod for approval and results from its liso-cel and bb2121 trials.

If the deal does go off without a hitch, then it wouldn't necessarily be bad news. Celgene's currently trading about 13% below the buyout price based on Bristol-Myers' current share price, and that doesn't include the potential $9 per share payout from the CVR. For this reason, a good argument can be made for owning Celgene regardless of how Bristol-Myers' investors vote in April.


Related Solutions

2. Provide some evidence (data) of success and some evidence of failure of our national sustainability...
2. Provide some evidence (data) of success and some evidence of failure of our national sustainability public policy (use food, or water, or air, or solid waste or energy as an example…. not all of them). What is your general conclusion? Do we need more rules? More enforcement? More awareness? More money? More responsible consumers? More responsible producers? retailers? Suppose you can’t do all of that at once (you can’t !), which path would you pick first? Explain.
1) Repositioning up: identify one example and analyze the reasons for success or failure 2) Repositioning...
1) Repositioning up: identify one example and analyze the reasons for success or failure 2) Repositioning down: identify one example and analyze the reasons for success or failure 3) Lateral repositioning: identify one example each of a success and a failure and analyze the reasons for the same
Location is a critical success factor in the success or failure of a restaurant. Which component...
Location is a critical success factor in the success or failure of a restaurant. Which component of the team domains is this most closely associated with? a. Ability to Execute b. Mission, Aspirations, and Risk c. None of the options provided d. Connectedness
Problem / Situation Possible cause(s) Intervention or recommendation Clinical evidence of impeding respiratory failure Clinical Evidence...
Problem / Situation Possible cause(s) Intervention or recommendation Clinical evidence of impeding respiratory failure Clinical Evidence of inadequate airway protection Difficult intubation Excessive ETT cuff leak despite air being added to the pilot balloon Intubation indicated in the presence of facial or mandibular trauma or pathology Oral ETT in place but the need for long term ventilation exists Trach tube in place but patient with good upper airway control whishes to talk Need to maintain an airway without an indication...
Which of the following is not considered direct evidence of anticompetitive effects in merger analysis? a....
Which of the following is not considered direct evidence of anticompetitive effects in merger analysis? a. natural experiments and actual effects from consummated mergers b. elimination of a maverick firm c. evidence of head-to-head competition d. critical loss analysis
Pick five main reasons that caused the financial collapse of 2008 supporting it with the evidence...
Pick five main reasons that caused the financial collapse of 2008 supporting it with the evidence described in the documentary and outside sources. Please ensure to provide the analysis using both domestic and international examples, as described in the documentary. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQzEWeGJLP0
 Write down the two main reasons for analysing the model?=?+??+?12  What is ?2 and...
 Write down the two main reasons for analysing the model?=?+??+?12  What is ?2 and why is it important? What does it show us?  Why do we need normality in our data and how can we test for it?  What is heteroskedasticity and why do we need to detect and correct for it when it is present in our model? How do we test for it?  What is autocorrelation, which assumption of the linear model does...
For each of the following, evaluate if it is a good argument. Provide reasons for why...
For each of the following, evaluate if it is a good argument. Provide reasons for why or why not. 16. Tax. Jane is doing an income tax return. There are two different methods of determining some revenues. If method A is used her taxable income will be $50,000. If method B is used, her taxable income will be $56,000. Jane thinks that she better chooses method A. 17. Taxi driver. King is a taxi driver working for a yellow cab...
If there is direct evidence of anticompetitive merger effects such as eliminating a head-to-head rival, which...
If there is direct evidence of anticompetitive merger effects such as eliminating a head-to-head rival, which step of the merger guidelines becomes less important? a. determining if merger-related efficiencies outweigh anticompetitive harm b. designing a divestiture remedy to restore competition lost by the merger c. defining relevant markets d. determining if one of the firms is going bankrupt
List and explain some of other major reasons for economic plan failure in Pakistan. Which reasons...
List and explain some of other major reasons for economic plan failure in Pakistan. Which reasons do you think are the most important and why?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT