Question

In: Operations Management

A NPPA your company filed describes a device for processing specialty foods. The examiner identifies a...

A NPPA your company filed describes a device for processing specialty foods. The examiner identifies a prior art reference that describes a similar device, but only described being used for simple foods; not for specialty foods that are significantly more complex. The examiner rejects the claims of the NPPA. What is the likely basis for the rejection? Be specific. What argument could be used, if applicable, to reverse the rejection?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The company had filed for patents for a device which was developed for processing specialty foods. The examiner of patent rights was able to identify a prior art reference, used for describing a similar device. Hence the examiner rejected the claims of the NPPA. The rejection would have been based on Sec 706.02 Rejection on Prior Act. As per this section, if the patent under consideration, has been filed by another inventor, then the entitlement of current patent is rejected as it is not a novel idea.

The company can put forward the argument that the prior-registered patent was described being used for simple foods. The scope of the coverage of the prior-registered patent is limited, only to simple foods, while the company is filing the patent in context of specialty foods. As there is considerable difference and no overlapping between simple and specialty foods, the current patent is novel in its concept and hence can be patented.


Related Solutions

HawthornHawthorn Foods processes bags of organic frozen fruits sold at specialty grocery store. The company allocates...
HawthornHawthorn Foods processes bags of organic frozen fruits sold at specialty grocery store. The company allocates manufacturing overhead based on direct labor hours. HawthornHawthorn has budgeted fixed manufacturing overhead for the year to be $ 629 comma 000$629,000. The predetermined fixed manufacturing overhead rate is $ 16.40$16.40 per direct labor​hour, while the standard variable manufacturing overhead rate is $ 0.50$0.50 per direct labor hour. The direct labor standard for each case is one minus quarterone−quarter ​(0.250.25​) of an hour. The...
Company produces and sells 90,000 boxes of specialty foods each year. Each box contains the same...
Company produces and sells 90,000 boxes of specialty foods each year. Each box contains the same assortment of food. The company has computed the following annual costs: Cost Item Total Costs Variable production costs $630,000 Fixed production costs 470,000 Variable selling costs 180,000 Fixed selling and administrative costs 170,000 Total costs $1,450,000 Mendenhall normally charges $ 30 per box. A new distributor has offered to purchase 9,000 boxes at a special price of $ 27 per box. Mendenhall will incur...
Company produces and sells 55 comma 00055,000 boxes of specialty foods each year. Each box contains...
Company produces and sells 55 comma 00055,000 boxes of specialty foods each year. Each box contains the same assortment of food. The company has computed the following annual​ costs: Cost Item Total Costs Variable production costs $330,000 Fixed production costs 520,000 Variable selling costs 165,000 Fixed selling and administrative costs 160,000 Total costs $1,175,000 GarrardGarrard normally charges $ 21$21 per box. A new distributor has offered to purchase 5 comma 5005,500 boxes at a special price of $ 17$17 per...
Option #1: Exotic Foods, Inc., Capital Budgeting Case Exotic Food Inc., a food processing company located...
Option #1: Exotic Foods, Inc., Capital Budgeting Case Exotic Food Inc., a food processing company located in Herndon, VA, is considering adding a new division to produce fresh ginger juice. Following the ongoing TV buzz about significant health benefits derived from ginger consumption, the managers believe this drink will be a hit. However, the CEO questions the profitability of the venture given the high costs involved. To address his concerns, you have been asked to evaluate the project using three...
1. As a biomedical engineer, your duty in a private medical device manufacturing company is to...
1. As a biomedical engineer, your duty in a private medical device manufacturing company is to develop, manufacture, and CE certified osteoinductive bone tissue engineering scaffold. Select one proper scaffold and scaffold manufacturing method that would allow manufacturing osteoinductive scaffold, and briefly explain. Define and explain two different adequate vasculogenesis strategies that you can apply to your scaffold. This scaffold will be implantable and permeable (long term). Define and explain the biocompatibility process for CE certification. What would be the...
Your company assembles five different models of a motor scooter that is sold in specialty stores...
Your company assembles five different models of a motor scooter that is sold in specialty stores in the United States. The company uses the same engine for all five models. You have been given the assignment of choosing a supplier for these engines for the coming year. Due to the size of your warehouse and other administrative restrictions, you must order the engines in lot sizes of 1,240 units. Because of the unique characteristics of the engine, special tooling is...
1) Provide one full APA page of text (minimum) that identifies your company, it's primary products,...
1) Provide one full APA page of text (minimum) that identifies your company, it's primary products, markets, subsidiaries, risks, and any special highlights about your assigned corporation. Corporation: The Brink's Company So far this is what I wrote, I'm not sure if it's even right....: The Brink’s Company is best described as an American private security and protection company. The company was founded in 1859 and has its main headquarters located in Richmond, Virginia. Brink’s has earned the title of...
What is your best estimate of the WACC for Kraft Foods, Campbell Soup Company, and Del...
What is your best estimate of the WACC for Kraft Foods, Campbell Soup Company, and Del Monte Foods? How do these WACCs influence your thinking about the WACC for Heinz?Exhibit 4     H. J. HEINZ: ESTIMATING THE COST OF CAPITAL IN UNCERTAIN TIMES     Comparable Firm Data                      Campbell Del Kraft Soup Monte Financial Summary     Revenues (in millions of dollars) 40,386 7,589 3,739 Book value of equity (in millions of dollars) 25,972 728 1,827 Book value of debt (in millions...
your duty in a private medical device manufacturing company is to develop, manufacture, and CE certified...
your duty in a private medical device manufacturing company is to develop, manufacture, and CE certified osteoinductive bone tissue engineering scaffold. Select one proper scaffold and scaffold manufacturing method that would allow manufacturing osteoinductive scaffold, and briefly explain. Define and explain two different adequate vasculogenesis strategies that you can apply to your scaffold. This scaffold will be implantable and permeable (long term). Define and explain the biocompatibility process for CE certification. What would be the classification of your developed medical...
Suppose you work for the Pittsburgh Steel Company. Your company specializes in rolling specialty steel alloys and titanium.
Suppose you work for the Pittsburgh Steel Company. Your company specializes in rolling specialty steel alloys and titanium. Material is purchased in slabs that may be up to 6 inches thick and is rolled into plates (about 0.5 inches thick) and sheets (.060 to 0.25 inches thick). Pittsburgh Steel Company's marketing strategy is to fill smaller orders that their competitors cannot produce profitably and to specialize in orders for materials that are difficult to process (like certain steel alloys, etc.)...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT