Question

In: Operations Management

9.   Columbia won’t discriminate on the basis of religious belief. Historically, some creeds have been singled out...

9.   Columbia won’t discriminate on the basis of religious belief. Historically, some creeds have been singled out more than others for abuse, but one that’s not often found on the list of mistreatment is Haitian Voodoo. Houngan Hector of New Jersey identifies himself as an asogwepriest of Haitian voodoo. His story is interesting. He claims to have been hit by an ancestor at the age of seven, and so began his spiritual journey. Eventually, it led Houngan Hector to perform spiritual cleansings for money. They haven’t always gone well. According to this newspaper story in the Philadelphia Daily News: “Lucille Hamilton paid $621 to have her ‘spiritual grime’ removed by voodoo high priest Houngan Hector in an ordinary townhouse in Camden County. Hamilton, 21, a male living as a woman, flew in on Friday from her home in Little Rock, Arkansas to take part in the three-day spiritual cleansing. By Saturday night Hamilton was dead, and authorities are awaiting results of an autopsy and toxicology tests to determine exactly what happened.”[1]

Here’s Houngan Hector’s advertisement for his services on his MySpace page, as it was reported in Odd Culture: “I have over 15 years of experience helping individuals resolve their issues, and well over 9 years of helping people through the means of the Haitian Voodoo tradition. Having gotten individuals out of jail, brought lovers back, and improved people’s financial situation, I keep myself humble remembering it is not I who does it. It is God and Ginen who resolves.” [2]

The three basic ethical arguments against discrimination (and, in this case, discrimination based on personal religious belief) are fairness, rights, and utilitarianism.

  • Choose one and make the case that Houngan Hector—who was never charged with any crime—should be treated like any other applicant for a job at Columbia University.
  • Can any of the three arguments be used to show that discriminating against Haitian voodoo believers is ethically acceptable, even recommendable?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer:

Discrimination is usually even attributable to cultural norms; however, these standards get conflict once 2 or a lot of cultures act to conduct business. It’s not honest to Hougan Hector as a result of he was ne'er guilty of against the law and therefore the offense should be to the particular position and maybe handled constantly as all different candidates applying for employment. beneath Title VII employment discrimination attributable to faith is prohibited. Hector’s ethical beliefs are preserved despite if the ideas don't seem to be associated with anyone's organized or formal faith. I believe the philosophical system in a concert of the arguments which will be wont to show that discriminating against Haitian voodoo believers is ethically acceptable, even recommendable. The philosophical system is represented because the greatest smart for the best range and everyone’s interest as equal. Voodoo is Hector’s faith and what he practices; the law prohibits nonsecular discrimination within the work. Also, there are totally different denominations of religions, which was based on folks throughout the planet and therefore the centuries, all of them warrant mutual regard and recognition.


Related Solutions

. “Some religious belief systems were useful in the conservation of wetlands prior to formal initiation...
. “Some religious belief systems were useful in the conservation of wetlands prior to formal initiation of wetland conservation measures”. Discuss this statement in relation to the management of Sakumo Lagoon (Sakumo II Lagoon) in Ghana.
Historically, the population average waiting time to check out of a supermarket has been 4 minutes....
Historically, the population average waiting time to check out of a supermarket has been 4 minutes. Recently, in an effort to reduce the waiting time, the supermarket experimented with a recommendation system that generates real-time information to management the on number of cashiers to staff. The system involves infrared cameras that measure the amount of body heat in the checkout area of the store. The data from the cameras are feed in to an analytical software system that determines how...
outline the factors which have been used to explain why historically there has been diversity in...
outline the factors which have been used to explain why historically there has been diversity in accounting practices internationally
As you have been witnessing, historically science has been an elite road traveled by the rich,...
As you have been witnessing, historically science has been an elite road traveled by the rich, religious leaders, and the privately educated. Today, we are seeing a movement in STEM and STEAM to promote scientific endeavors in the public school system and in the community. In fact, you have just finished a community based science project. Your job is to compare and contrast the ways in which science was disseminated throughout the culture in the renaissance to today. Your ultimate...
Historically, 20% of graduates of the engineering school at a major university have been women. In...
Historically, 20% of graduates of the engineering school at a major university have been women. In a recent, randomly selected graduating class of 210 students, 58 were females. Does the sample data present convincing evidence that the proportion of female graduates from the engineering school has shifted (changed)? Use α = 0.05. Determine what type of error (Type I or II) could be made in the question above.
Historically, 20% of graduates of the engineering school at a major university have been women. In...
Historically, 20% of graduates of the engineering school at a major university have been women. In a recent, randomly selected graduating class of 210 students, 58 were females. Does the sample data present convincing evidence that the proportion of female graduates from the engineering school has shifted (changed)? Use α = 0.05. ***I ALREADY HAVE A-E ANSWERED*** A.State the null and alternative hypotheses to be tested and indicate whether the test is left-tailed, right-tailed or two-tailed. B. List the conditions...
Historically, weights of polar bears have been known to be Normally Distributed with a population mean...
Historically, weights of polar bears have been known to be Normally Distributed with a population mean of approx. 550 kg and a standard deviation of about 110 kg. Researchers are studying the effect of climate change on these animals; their hypothesis is that, because of the diminishing size of their feeding habitats, the average polar bear will be smaller than in the past. 1.) What is the probability that a randomly selected polar bear would weigh less than 480 kg?...
Religious tensions have been a common theme throughout the subject matter we have covered. Providing specifics...
Religious tensions have been a common theme throughout the subject matter we have covered. Providing specifics and examples, explain the religious turmoil that has marked societies up until this point in class. Back up your work with evidence and detail (Based on martin luther protestant reformation, the witch hunts, 30 years war, and sunni and shia) (at least a page or two, but anything is fine)
How have our social and community trends been influenced by, and in turn impact, our religious...
How have our social and community trends been influenced by, and in turn impact, our religious institutions?
Some DRM systems have been implemented on open systems and some have been implemented in closed...
Some DRM systems have been implemented on open systems and some have been implemented in closed systems. a. What is the primary advantage of implementing DRM on a closed system? b. What is the primary advantage to implementing DRM on an open platform?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT