Question

In: Physics

Given: Law of Conservation of Angular Momentum. Reverse spinning with dense atmosphere (92 times > Earth...

Given: Law of Conservation of Angular Momentum.

Reverse spinning with dense atmosphere (92 times > Earth & CO2 dominant sulphur based).
Surface same degree of aging all over.
Hypothetical large impact is not a sufficient answer.

Assuming any object large enough to alter a planets rotation or even orbit would likely destroy most of its shape, yet Venus has retained a spherical property with a seemingly flat, even terrain indicating no volcanoes,and few if any visible meteor impacts. It would be fragmented and dispersed for billions of years. Even the question of what meteor, comet, asteroid composition could survive traveling that close to the sun's temperature, radiation, electromagnetic energy, solar flares, or gravity to equal a mass reactionary change as to alter it's spin.

Solutions

Expert Solution

This is a very late response, but there is no accepted answer as of yet, and none of the answer quite hit the mark.


Regarding the magical collision hypothesis, that smacks of being rather non-scientific. Scientists as well as Missourians are wont to say, "Show me!" Other than the fact that Venus's rotation is anomalous, what, exactly, is the evidence for a collision with enough oomph to create this anomalous rotation? Even more problematically, this collision hypothesis hand waves away the problem of Venus's thick atmosphere.

Part of the problem here is thinking that the current rotation rates and rotation axes of the terrestrial planets are somehow related to the initial angular momentum of protoplanetary disk from which the planets formed. That may well be the case for the two gas giants in the solar system, but it's not the case for the terrestrial planets. The primordial angular momenta of the terrestrial planets is not a conserved quantity thanks to external torques from the Sun, Jupiter, moons, and other planets. Mercury is in a 3:2 spin-orbit resonance. Mars has suffered chaotic variations in its rotational state due to perturbations from Jupiter. Whatever angular momenta those two planets had initially is long lost. The Earth's Moon has apparently stabilized the Earth's rotation axis, but has sapped its primordial rotation rate. So what about Venus?

Helder Velez's answer to me comes closest to the mark but misses some key points. Helder explicitly discounted Venus's thick atmosphere as playing a role. That Venus has a very thick atmosphere may well be a key part of the answer. Helder referenced the second of two papers published in Icarus on Venus's rotation by Correia and Laskar but did not the reference the first (or the similar Nature article by Correia and Laskar published couple of years prior to those Icarus articles), and Helder did not pay attention to the key point in the Correia and Laskar: Venus rotation is a natural consequence of Venus's thick atmosphere. No collision is needed.

A parsimonious explanation of Venus's rotational state would not need a magical gigantic impact that even more magically did not blow away Venus's primordial atmosphere. This parsimonious explanation is exactly what Correia and Laskar argue happened in their Nature paper and their two Icarus papers. Venus rotates the way it does because this is one of the four final states in which a collision-free terrestrial planet with a very thick atmosphere would rotate. Two of those final states have Venus rotating prograde, the other two, retrograde. The prograde rotational states are statistically unlikely compared to the retrograde rotational states. Venus's thick atmosphere plays a key role in determining Venus's final, stable rotational state


Related Solutions

Conservation of Angular Momentum A female figure skater is spinning on ice. Assume that that the...
Conservation of Angular Momentum A female figure skater is spinning on ice. Assume that that the surface is basically frictionless. The skater is wearing weighted bracelets as part of the costume for the performance. These weighted bracelets weight .75 kg each. The skater has a spinning routine in the middle of the performance and initially starts spinning with arms stretched wide such that the weighted bracelets are 1 m from the axis of rotation. She has an initial angular velocity...
A zero-momentum spin stabilized satellite has a momentum wheel spinning at 5000 rpm. The angular momentum...
A zero-momentum spin stabilized satellite has a momentum wheel spinning at 5000 rpm. The angular momentum of the wheel is 100 N-m-sec. a) What is the spin rate of the satellite if its moment of inertia is 500 kg-m2? b) What is the moment of inertial of the wheel? c) If there were a problem with the wheel and it was stopped, what would be the spin rate of the satellite? d) Assuming the problem was fixed, how long would...
given an electron has orbital angular momentum and spin angular momentum, l and s respectively. given...
given an electron has orbital angular momentum and spin angular momentum, l and s respectively. given the following relations: [lx,ly] = ih(bar)lz , [ly,lz] = ih(bar)lx , [lz,lx] = ih(bar)ly [sx,sy]= ih(bar) sz , [sy,sz] = ih(bar)sx , [sz, sy\ = ih(bar)sy (a) prove first that for an arbitary operator A, B that AB=BA+[A,B] (b) show that [lx,l^2] = 0 where l^2 = l*l = lx^2 + ly^2 + lz^2 (c) show that similarly, [ly,l^2]=0 and [lz,l^2]=0 (d)given that the...
-Derive the law of the conservation of momentum using Lagrange Formalism. -Derive also the conservation of...
-Derive the law of the conservation of momentum using Lagrange Formalism. -Derive also the conservation of the angular momentum
With the sun at the origin, compute the total angular momentum of the earth, and compare...
With the sun at the origin, compute the total angular momentum of the earth, and compare the magnitude of the contributions from the angular momentum of the center of mass and the angular momentum about the center of mass. You can make simplifying assumptions, like that the orbit is circular, that the earth is perfect sphere, etc.
1) What is the direction of the angular momentum for the rotation of the Earth? 2)...
1) What is the direction of the angular momentum for the rotation of the Earth? 2) If you give a hard boiled egg a spin on the table, it will keep spinning for a long time. If you do the same with an uncooked egg, it stops relatively quickly. Explain this. 3) A dumbbell consists of two uniform spheres of mass M and radius R, joined by a thin rod of radius r and length l and mass m. a)...
a) What is the angular momentum of the Moon around the Earth? The Moon mass is...
a) What is the angular momentum of the Moon around the Earth? The Moon mass is 7.40e22 kg and it orbits 3.80e8 meters from the Earth. b) And what is the angular momentum of the Earth around the Sun? Mass of the Earth is 5.98e24 kg and it orbits 1.50el 1 m from the Sun.
1. What is the direction of the angular momentum for the rotation of the Earth? 2....
1. What is the direction of the angular momentum for the rotation of the Earth? 2. If you give a hard boiled egg a spin on the table, it will keep spinning for a long time. If you do the same with an uncooked egg, it stops relatively quickly. Explain this. 3. A dumbbell consists of two uniform spheres of mass M and radius R, joined by a thin rod of radius r and length l and mass m. a)...
Part A Calculate the magnitude of the angular momentum of the Earth in a circular orbit...
Part A Calculate the magnitude of the angular momentum of the Earth in a circular orbit around the sun. The Earth has mass 5.97
A: What is the angular momentum of a figure skater spinning at 3.4 rev/s with arms...
A: What is the angular momentum of a figure skater spinning at 3.4 rev/s with arms in close to her body, assuming her to be a uniform cylinder with a height of 1.4 m , a radius of 15 cm , and a mass of 48 kg ? **Express your answer using three significant figures and include the appropriate units B: How much torque is required to slow her to a stop in 4.5 s , assuming she does not...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT